Seahorses and Corals

dmatt56

New member
Hello Everyone,

I am considering adding a pair of yellow tank raised seahorses to my 55G softie tank. I currently have leather corals, toadstool, mushrooms, zoas, daisy polyps, GSP, fish, and inverts.

Will they be compatible with all my corals? Will the seahorses attaching to the leather coral's arm bother either the coral or seahorse?

Thanks,

Matt
 
Hi Matt, I see you're fairly new to the hobby... WELCOME TO OUR ADDICTION!

Since you are new to horses too, let me give you some pointers that will hopefully save you money and heart ache. First, dont ever buy a seahorse based on color - or for that matter with a name like that. There are no "yellow seahorses". If the person or fish store selling you the horses cannot tell you the correct name (i.e. Reidi, Erectus, Comes, etc.), chances are the horses are not captive bred. The problem with horses that are not CB is feeding, since pen/net raised or wild caught horses may not take to frozen food right away or even at all. Then you run into the predicament of having to find live foods for them which is no easy task (and expensive too).

Anyways, to answer your questions... what kind of fish and inverts do you have? I ask because most fish are too aggressive to be housed with SH. Horses are very docile and gentle. They move slow and will be quickly out-competed for food. They can be kept with slow moving fish such as gobies or cardinals, and some firefish, but ideally should be kept alone in a SH dedicated tank. Also, the inverts you keep also need to be seahorse friendly. Take a look at this site/document which gives you an idea of what you can and cannot keep with seahorses: http://www.seahorse.org/library/art...tankmates.shtml

Some crabs can bother and harrass SH and some will even eat them! (I just found that horrible site in my tank yesterday as I am keeping a friend's livestock while he fixes his tank - he HAD crabs that ate my lovely little girl - emphasis on HAD...lol).

As far as corals go, softies are fine, especially leathers. Try not to keep anything in there with a mouth, such as acans, etc., which can eat the horses, or corals with stinging tentacles such as frogspawn or torch, as these will sting them. Leathers are perfect for SH tanks and in my experience, they are generally not bothered by the horses hitching on them. Another great coral for SH tanks are gorgonias. Not only do they add hitching posts for the ponies, but they provide bright color to the tank and some say it helps horses color up. You can also add lots of colorful macro algaes which look great and gove your tank a more "natural" look. A good supplier of macros is John Maloney at Reef Cleaners (www.reefcleaners.org). He is very helpful and knowledgeable.

I hope the above helps. If you have any more questions feel free to ask. This is a very friendly and helpful community.
 
Last edited:
Here is a different link to the tankmate list.

Seahorse Tankmate Guide

Seahorses will bug certain leather a bit, but not enough to worry about. They are more prone to bother gorgonia's IME, but most of my gorgs have come through just fine.

Personally I have never had issues keeping seahorses with acans, micro's, or blasto's but I only did it for a year or so. I am currently keeping some pipefish with some blasto's and acans as well.

JME

Kevin
 
Keeping a seahorse dedicated tank will increase your chances of success in the hobby.
Seahorses are very prone to infection from bacterial diseases.
The bacteria multiply at an ever increasing rate as the temperature of the tank increases. Most experienced hobbyists would recommend not going higher than 74°F.
 
lfs usually refer to kudas as yellow sea horses
and have been really small witch will be hard enough in a sh only tank
If you do decide to set up a tank and get them make sure they eat frozen mycid at the store !!
Most lfs just feed them brine shrimp and they will starve to death
even the mycid should be enriched
sea horses require a lot more care than most fish
 
hi i wouldnt trust seahorses with most soft coral they do better with hard coral wher ther is a less chance for them to be stung or caught on a sticky coral
 
I disagree on the statement about stony corals. They will find their favorite spot and if it happens to be SPS (and there is a good chance it will be)... goodbye SPS.

There are many soft corals which are perfectly safe with seahorses. My seahorses absolutely love the leathers which make tree formations. And colt coral!!!! They will rub their tails on it like a kid with a baby blanket.

At first the leathers may look a bit stressed from the hitching to them, but they seem to get used to it over time. My leathers no longer even wince when a seahorse hitches on it.

Stick to the tankmates guide above and you will be just fine.
 
nuff said...

Orboy2.jpg
 
Still would love to get seahorses one day.

I felt just like you and years ago put 2 seahorses in an aquarium environment totally unsuited for them and it ended in tragedy for the seahorses and me feeling awful. I didn't consider seahorses again for probably 10 years. I did a lot of research this time, weighed the extra considerations to meet their needs and in May I set up a tank for captive bred seahorses, that are arriving this Thursday. The moral of this story is avoid the heart ache and learn as much as you can about them and then pursue your dream when you are ready! Best of luck!
 
I keep thinking I might do a seahorse tank once the baby gets a little older. My fish are now too aggressive eaters in my display tank.
 
Back
Top