reeftivo
Skim junkie
I just thought it interesting that skimmers that are 4 times the cost of a Bubble Magus will only really pull out a little bit more. At the beginning, the big expensive skimmer may seem to outperform the cheaper one, but once the bigger skimmer runs out of stuff to pull out, it becomes useless if too big.
I did find it funny that the worst performing skimmer was the Reef Octopus. Yet that is the skimmer everyone will recommend over the Bubble Magus.
I have a little 100g rated counter current CADlights skimmer that came with my system. It has no bubble plate,pin wheel, a 250gph resun pump, a 2 1/4 inch neck, pulled 250lph air and it out performed my deltec, bermuda, and euroreef skimmers. I think the skimmer w/ pump probably cost CADlights $60 bucks. The skimmer doesn't have alot of air but the dwell time in the chamber seems to be very good with its slow spinning motion downward. I also have a 2009 Reefocto nwb110 that I will not use because the skimmer was not even close to what I was hoping for when I ran it for initial cleaning. I dont want to bash any skimmers that others have had good luck with but I will stay away fron octo skimmers that come with the octopus pumps. I'll take an Atman over those any day. IMO, the only competition BM has is Vertex, with their Euroreef style skimmers. But even they have resun pumps on the smaller in-sump versions.
I think alot of people are miss led when they keep hearing "you cant overskim a tank", so they go out and get a much bigger skimmer than they should (me included). IMO, you really cant overskim a tank but you're right about getting a skimmer too big to match your system. Too big and it will skim everything quick and then wont be able to be fed enough to develope a consistent foam head because of the shear size of the unit.
Last edited: