Where can I post?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your post is in violation of the terms and conditions of use of this web site and has been edited. Further violations will result in revocation of your posting privileges.

Got me!

I'm gonna join the MTRC even though I'm not gonna be able to go to most of the meetings. The main reason I will join is the people I've already met on here and the help given. The discount to AC (am I allowed to say AC?)is another.

I hope yall work it out to set up your own forum (with rules of course). It sux having people from across the country telling you what you can and can't do in your own club. Atleast if someone from within finds a violation that would probly explain and be nice about it.

Darrell
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15371470#post15371470 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by andywe
Larry,

Obviously there are many of us that have issue swith RC staff and practices, but again Id efer to the reason this forum is here. Is it to support the reefing community or not?


The board is here to further the hobby, in order to facilitate that, we do offer forums free to use by local clubs around the country, and even the planet. What's expected in return is that the users of said local club forums conform to the rules set in place for the entire 200,000+ member community. Not a lot to ask, and whether you agree or not, the staff here does an exemplary job, and there are no plans to change people or methods.

Many of us pay money to the site, so I wouldn't go too far down the road of "free". RC staff chose their revenue model. The key is keeping users, because advertising revenues are generated not by the site, but by the users who participate.

Take it easy there cowboy, a quick look at this thread shows a lot less than "many" premium members. The vast majority of complaints here are coming from people that have given nothing to the community as a whole, and are now taking up valuable time that I, and others on staff could be spending in a far more productive way.
To a degree, you are correct, keeping users is important. Keeping this particular bunch of users is becoming less and less important when I consider the effort being put into it.

A common theme seems to be amongst the attitude of staff, which you exhibited with yourself with you " could care less " statement.

To expand on what I said above, it's a cost/benefit analysis thing. I feel like my time is being wasted here. No matter what I say, I feel the only way to stop the whining in this forum is to close it to new posts.

How about some accountability for the mods, whom interfere with many of us dramatically..whether it be speaking up in our club forum when no reason was given for them to, interfereing with selling threads becasue they were afraid something would happen that never did, or attitude I got when I asked who the mods were accountable too several months ago because I wanted to lodge a complaint. Yet if you follow these same power players as I have, you see them abuse and violate the terms they themselves "supposedly" uphold.

The staff here will never be accountable to you. You are in OUR house, simple manners dictate that you, as a guest here will comply with the rules set by us.
This thread is quite interesting, it has been mentioned a number of times here how our staff are coming into "your" local forum and dictating to you how to run "your" local club forum.
Albeit, yes this IS a public forum, it is a forum within a privately owned bulletin board. So, you are actually coming into "our" forum and telling us how to run "our" forum.
Now, realize something;
The entire staff here has global authority. Just because a particular Moderator is not listed as a mod of a specific forum does not mean that mod has any less power in that forum, than any other. Everyone on staff here is here to uphold the rules of this community, be they selling rules, flaming rules or profanity rules, etc.
I would love to see links to support your allegations. I find it difficult to accept, as
1)I know the people I work with here
and
2)you're the only one coming forth with these alleged infractions committed by our staff.

Then we get insulted with holier than thou attitudes and generic statements of " your wrong and we are right"

Nobody is telling you that you're wrong. What you're being told is that the rules are in place, if you are not willing to abide by our rules, you're not welcome here. It's as simple as that. Again, I do not care if you stay or go, my concern is that you stop being a thorn in my side. If you think you can have it both ways, you are mistaken, and I am prepared to take any action necessary to put this to bed. One trip to the control panel, and this could have been ended within minutes of it starting. I gotta tell you, I'm beginning to regret the course I chose to take here.

Heck, even the emails to my personal account, which I got from a mod, had a disclosure that was a clear violation of the TOS...and..not subject to RC TOS since it was ent to my personal email through Gmail....So when I changed the disclaimer in my reply, I got the expected childlike rant from the mod.

Interesting that you would make that choice of words. That same "disclosure" goes out with every email. For those that have not been in a position of receiving it:
RC retains ownership of this message and all associated contents, which are to remain confidential. This message is intended only for the designated recipient(s). Sharing, forwarding or posting of this information, without prior consent, may result in the loss of posting privileges on Reef Central's forums.

These types of issues are what I am seeing as a common theme. The fact that there are many of us here complaining should really be viewed as issues that are very real. this isn't one person, or a singular isolated complaint.

There's that "many" thing again. Look around, you are way in the minority. "Many" describes the members that are happy to be here, follow the rules, and enjoy this free resource without being a problem to the people that run it.
You are obviously never going to be happy here.
As a rule, we do not refund premium membership payments. I am personally willing to send you a check if you'll go away. What do you say?

Since you asked, the first change I would like to see is tha attitude of the staff. The second the attitude of the mods.

What you view as an attitude problem is not being seen that way by the masses, and there is no plan to make changes.

The only feature that should be opened is the search function, that would be my feature request.

Finally, something we can see eye to eye on. Search improvements, along with several other functionality issues are currently being addressed with our new software that you should all experience in short order.



I am happy, and available to have a phone conversation and talk about specific incidences if you would like. Just PM me and let me know.

Regards,

Andy Weinberg
Paying subscriber


I see no benefit to taking this discussion off line, and to be totally honest, I'd prefer not having my home phone number available to who ever might eventually get it if I start giving it out.
 
Last edited:
VandyTime,
I just removed the web address from your signature. We do not allow URLs in sigs for anyone other than sponsors of the site.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15371583#post15371583 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by gabberjaw
DgenR8... I think that everyone is getting fired up over the inconsistent mod monitoring. Some people on this forum have been attacked yes, I mean attacked! There have been instances where a member has tried to get help with this problem and you (all mods) sided with each other and never really asked what the real problem was. Giving sites to investigate is great...If they work. This one did not if someone has a problem with a certain mod they have difficulty getting it moderated fairly. I realize you are all human and can only catch so many infractions as you would call them. However, is this conversation you are having in our personal forum good form for a moderator??????? I believe you are working for the companies that advertise here and we are the supporters of those companies since we buy their products. Supply and demand has a way of making the world go around. You are being bad advertisement with is type of behavior.

I honestly don't know what you're seeing as inconsistent, and as far as "attacking", all I can say is that perhaps you should consider why a mod from across the country would be in this forum to begin with.
We deal with every breach of the <a href=http://reefcentral.com/agreement.php target=_blank>User Agreement</a> we see. Admittedly, we don't see every one. There are literally thousands of new posts here daily, and our staff is minuscule by comparison. We can not "stumble" onto every problem, a lot of them have to be reported to us before we see them.
Nobody on staff would have ventured into this forum if there wasn't some sort of problem to bring us here. Now, I know of at least six off the top of my head that are involved in dealing with your little club forum. Believe me, all of us would prefer to be doing other things.
Again, I don't know what to say about "attacks", but if there were no problems to bring staff in here, there would be no staff posts for you to view as attacks.
You need to stop seeing this as "your personal forum" This is Reef Central's forum, it's moderated by the same staff that Mods the other two hundred or so of Reef Central's forums. We graciously provide this forum for your club to use, free of charge, but it is not a no strings attached agreement. It's still our house, and we have certain expectations, even demands regarding how you will behave while you are a guest in our house.
Personally, I consider it tasteless, and rather poor form for you as a group to use the free resources provided to you by Reef Central to trash Reef Central. For you to be here challenging the rules of the community after agreeing to those rules is ludicrous. To take it a step further, and mention in a discussion taking place at Reef Central how you plan to set up a "new, no rules" forum elsewhere to take the place of this one, yet return here to take advantage of the wealth of info RC has to offer lacks tact.
When someone has a problem with a mod, it's because they were caught breaking the rules, and rather than say "I'm sorry", and fall into compliance, they chose to push the issue.
We do NOT search out people to mess with for no reason, we are busy enough without turning innocent people upside down for no reason.
 
Last edited:
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15373084#post15373084 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by VandyTime
Honest mistake, sorry

That's how most people handle it. There was an issue, the issue has been solved, we all get to move on with a new understanding. There are no hard feelings, Vandy.
 
It's funny how some people can get over 7,000 post and not have a problem and others with less than 25 post manage to get most of them locked.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15372525#post15372525 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by james3370
personally i'd like a bit less of the codescending attitude i have seen expressed from some of the people in charge when a legitimate complaint or question is being addressed

If your perception of my posts is that I am condescending, telling you that it's not intended that way will be pointless.
All I can say is that what I'm responding to will effect how I respond. When I am approached in a reasonable manner, I can be a very nice guy.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15373366#post15373366 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by DgenR8
If your perception of my posts is that I am condescending, telling you that it's not intended that way will be pointless.
All I can say is that what I'm responding to will effect how I respond. When I am approached in a reasonable manner, I can be a very nice guy.

i never stated you specifically....in fact, i went out of my way to name specifics.

all i'm saying is in the past, i have had a few issues where i asked for clarification & got nothing but condescending attitude instead of a simple answer to a question or issue i posed

vandytime's issue is a general one that speaks to this. he posted a link to his aquarium in his sig, it was edited w/ a geralized post that has what some would construe as threatning/condescending language.....especially the last sentence, yet no mention as to what the violation was

Your post is in violation of the terms and conditions of use of this web site and has been edited. Further violations will result in revocation of your posting privileges.


the generalized post tells him he violated the policy, yet gives him no indication as to what the violation was......now if somebody had simply removed the violating post & then something to the effect "sorry, but urls in your sig are not allowed" then that would go along way towards keeping the bad feelings from surfacing...especially from new members

a police officer doesn't pull you over & give you a ticket for "breaking the law" & threaten to revoke your license if you do it again w/out telling you which law you broke
 
Last edited:
You're seeing this as a very personal thing, but it's far from that. What you posted;

[violation]

is a "tag" it's something that I (or any staff member) can post by simply typing the correct single word between two "[ ]"
It's a way to speed things up, and it's a general catch all for edited posts. I believe that when it's used, it's more than reasonable for us to expect the member in question to be fully aware of why their post was edited. I don't usually concern myself with whether or not others will understand the violation, it's not them that we're addressing, and the rules are available for anyone to read, at their leisure.

It's probably not important, but in the name of keeping things clear, I didn't edit vandytime's post. I used the control panel to remove his signature as what he had there was not permitted. I then posted explaining (pretty clearly, I think) that his sig had been changed. He responded that he understands, and all is well.
Sometimes those exchanges happen behind the scenes, other times they happen in the open. They routinely end amicably, just like what you saw unfold in this thread.

a police officer doesn't pull you over & give you a ticket for "breaking the law" & threaten to revoke your license if you do it again w/out telling you which law you broke

Consider the possibility that the "police officer" had pulled that same person over a few days prior and let him slide with a warning for the very same infraction.
The membership here may not be privy to the gory details. In fact, just about every (if not every) case includes a back and forth behind the scenes that is instrumental to the resolution, or complete melt down of user status.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15374341#post15374341 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by DgenR8
Consider the possibility that the "police officer" had pulled that same person over a few days prior and let him slide with a warning for the very same infraction.
The membership here may not be privy to the gory details. In fact, just about every (if not every) case includes a back and forth behind the scenes that is instrumental to the resolution, or complete melt down of user status.

well in my experience, it was never explained to me what i had done wrong & then when i addressed/questioned it, i was met w/ the vague threat of "loss of posting priveledges"

it's not every mod but from reading other's complaints before, there seem to be a few mods that don't like their authority questioned in ANY way....whether it be asking for clarification on a rule or whatever & i think that is what most take issue with
 
i think the original post brings up the question of when you have a question on a post violation, or a TOS question, where is the best place to post something like that?? some instances the questions have been levied in the actual thread where the violation happened, but in alot of the cases the thread gets closed.

then the person is at a loss as to where to address the issue & who to address it to.....

is there a specific place where these issues can be addressed?? is there a list of mods/admins & a hirearcy list of sorts, so if somebody can't get a response or clarification, they can in essescene address it to someone in higher authority??

these things i think would help the entire membership & community as a whole
 
That's what the "Feedback and Questions" forum is for.

There is no "higher authority." We moderate as a team. Every action is available for review by the entire team.
 
RC has a place to bring up those questions. It's called the Feedback and questions forum.
As far as a hierarchy, not really. The board has an owner, but he's been pretty hands off lately. He has entrusted Reef Central to the Mods and Admins that have been running it for a few years now. Mods and Admins critique and are accountable to each other, not to mention work together on community issues. There isn't a single boss on site.
 
Doug types faster than me, I guess. Please notice that we both said the same thing.........
 
This thread has become rather entertaining to follow. It reminds me yet again why I only post on RC to communicate with other MTRC members. The statements made and the general attitude of the staff make me think even less of RC in general.

The fact that admins and mods have taken an interest in this thread also says to me you do somewhat care, otherwise you'd just leave us alone, and simply let us discuss where we plan to take the forum. No rules were being broken, no need to interfere.

DgenR8, your statement that "we are in your house, we follow your rules" is true. Folks should follow the rules and be held accountable if they do not. However, in many cases, an explanation is sometimes necessary. Your "house" would collapse without the members. The entire reason you are here is to support the members. Without us, you are nothing. One would think that you would like to keep as many members as you can - if the site didn't get as much traffic as it did, advertising revenue would decrease, and paid memberships would decrease. So, in fact, you do owe something to the members.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15374601#post15374601 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by DgenR8
Doug types faster than me, I guess. Please notice that we both said the same thing.........

Ok, so this is one of the exact incidences I refer to. I did post in feedback and questions, and got nothing but attitude, runaround, and jokes about how mods are infallable. I asked politely, just whom the moderators were accountable to.

Doug responded as well, with an "I told you in the other forum" answer, even that answer had not gotten to me until later and was just the webmaster address.

I got rhetoric and runaround, rather than a straight answer, and only when I pushed back did I "sort of" get an answer to my question. So if you were not aware, then please be so now that experiences in that forum were less than positive and unhelpful. 1 out of many actually responded with clarity and showing respect and openess. My request was non inflamatory, nor did it disclose the issue I had. I merely asked whom I should bring an issue to.
Things are not the way you seem to beleive they are. You keep syaing you are not aware..well, these comments were origianlly brought out to make you aware...so I have said my peace.

I am done talking here. It is not productive, and since our VP asked that we take the discussion offline, I am doing just that. Thanks guys.
 
c23270a2.gif
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15374656#post15374656 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ZachB
This thread has become rather entertaining to follow. It reminds me yet again why I only post on RC to communicate with other MTRC members. The statements made and the general attitude of the staff make me think even less of RC in general.

The fact that admins and mods have taken an interest in this thread also says to me you do somewhat care, otherwise you'd just leave us alone, and simply let us discuss where we plan to take the forum. No rules were being broken, no need to interfere.

DgenR8, your statement that "we are in your house, we follow your rules" is true. Folks should follow the rules and be held accountable if they do not. However, in many cases, an explanation is sometimes necessary. Your "house" would collapse without the members. The entire reason you are here is to support the members. Without us, you are nothing. One would think that you would like to keep as many members as you can - if the site didn't get as much traffic as it did, advertising revenue would decrease, and paid memberships would decrease. So, in fact, you do owe something to the members.


You are under the impression that you are far more important than you actually are, and you are very mistaken. Rules were being broken, or I'd never have set foot in here.
I said I didn't care if you stayed or went, that's becoming less and less true by the minute. I'm of the mindset that I'd prefer to see you leave given your quoted post above.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top