Where do bacteria come from?

Psychomantix

Psychomantix

New member
I've read that to cycle a new tank, you just ghost feed or throw in a raw shrimp or pure ammonia and wait for bacteria to grow. My question is: where do these bacteria come from, especially if I'm using dry rock/sand that has been sterilized. My tap water source comes from a river, which I'm sure has tons of nitrifying bacteria. But I also read that fresh- and saltwater are different and FW bacteria will all die off in SW.
So, without seeding bacteria either with live rock or from a bottle, can these bacteria magically appear out of nowhere if there is ammonia in the water?
 
These bacteria are everywhere. Some of them are the reason why a tuna sandwich that you leave on the counter for a few days will rot, some pull nitrogen from the air so corn can grow, some people even say that changes in atmospheric oxygen levels triggered by cyanobacteria allowed life as we know it to begin its evolution, like way before the dinosaurs.
It would be impossible to keep them out. Also, even if they weren't all over the place, and all over you, and in the air, there's nothing sterile about dry sand and rock.

Are you sure you wanna use tap water?
 
They're in the air, on your skin, they can live as dormant cysts for years until the environment is right for them to grow
 
Even you have bacteria, and lots of them. Every human being on Earth has more individual bacteria living inside them then they do human cells in their body! Hows that for a scary fact!
 
Technically speaking, the concept of spontaneous generation is bunk, bacteria have to come from somewhere. That said, I think you will have an extremely difficult time cultivating a thriving tank if you assume you will get oceanic bacteria from the air without seeding your system. Well, Ron might :) , but I wouldn't hedge your tank on it. A few pounds of legit live rock is all you need to get going. It takes more time, but it will get going.
 
You don't have to 'seed' a tank with any bacteria at all and it will work, it just takes longer. Some LR will make it happen considerably faster. Bacteria in a bottle may even be way faster. It's a matter of how you want to do it. I used some LR, it doesn't take much at all.

BTW, Nate, I'm happy with most of my bacteria! :lolspin:
 
toothybugs said:
Technically speaking, the concept of spontaneous generation is bunk, bacteria have to come from somewhere.
Click to expand...

I dont disagree about getting live rock. I highly suggest it. However, this statement misses the mark.

No one is talking about spontaneous generation. The bacteria needed to cycle the tank exist pretty much all over (see earlier posts). Just because you can't see them, doesn't mean they aren't there. It's only "magical" if one doesn't understand the process.

And to make matters even more cool - ever wonder why coralline algae will develop in a bare tank running decent calcium and lighting with artificial salt water in the middle of Kansas? The answer will either make you cringe or be amazed. And bacteria are smaller. :-)

- ryan
 
rsain said:
...

<snip>

...And to make matters even more cool - ever wonder why coralline algae will develop in a bare tank running decent calcium and lighting with artificial salt water in the middle of Kansas? The answer will either make you cringe or be amazed. And bacteria are smaller. :-)

- ryan
Click to expand...

So what is the process? Not just Kansas mind you, but say Wyoming, Idaho, Montana, Colorado, etc? That far inland I would be surprised if coraline algae existed especially considering the Rockys, BigHorns, Grand Tetons, etc...
 
ScienceRulez said:
So what is the process? Not just Kansas mind you, but say Wyoming, Idaho, Montana, Colorado, etc? That far inland I would be surprised if coraline algae existed especially considering the Rockys, BigHorns, Grand Tetons, etc...
Click to expand...

I was on an airplane with a good friend of mine. PhD biologist guy (Dr. Keats) - had some coralline algae named after him that grows on kelp stalks in one small by in South Africa only to be eaten by other algae. The flight was about 12hrs long so we had time to chat. Rather, I had time to ask a single question, and listen to his dissertation level response. The question I asked?

"How does coralline algae get into my tank even though I have nothing from the ocean in there and do not live anywhere near one?" He laughed. Then spoke for hours.

His initial response was "it's everywhere". Fast forward to a break in Senegal and getting sprayed with some sort of anti bug chemical. "Like that" he said.

Basically his argument is that it's in the atmospheric column. Something about cysts or spores, I don't recall. But I was and am amazed. Much like I am about how much feces you (we/us) breathe on a given day. :-) Y'all can look that up on your own. :facepalm:

Back to the original point. If algae can get everywhere - imagine where bacteria can get. Spontaneous generation is not the process, rather, a pseudo explanation of the process. Or as toothybugs put it:
toothybugs said:
the concept of spontaneous generation is bunk
Click to expand...
exactly.

- ryan
 
I dare you to google breathing feces
we breathe it just about all the time
I double dare you
youre breathing it right now prolly
 
CStrickland said:
I dare you to google breathing feces
we breathe it just about all the time
I double dare you
youre breathing it right now prolly
Click to expand...

While I was living in Kabul a team of rather funny, possibly inebriated, science types took air samples, in August (from random locations across the city, spread out throughout the day). They quantified the result of feces breathed per day in teaspoons.

TEASPOONS.

- ryan
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Nutrient Export
Replies
0
Views
2K
SantaMonica
S
Dr. Reef
Bacteria in a bottle, Myth or Fact
Replies
3
Views
1K
jcarlilesiu
J
Niven
I'm back....and ready to jump back in, feet first in the deep end, speedo, everything!
2
Replies
20
Views
474
vlangel
vlangel
S
Nutrient Export
Replies
5
Views
2K
wvned
wvned
E
What's Old is New Again
Replies
2
Views
441
Uncle99
Uncle99
Back
Top