Why is my true Perc hosting in my torch and not my rbta?

pRadaaaaa

New member
Hi, my friend was breaking down his tank and was cool enough to give me his true perc. I dont understand why the clown is hosting in my torch and not my rbta. I have 2 really big roses, about 7-8" but he decides to chill near my torch haha. In my friends tank he had a rbta and the perc was hosting in there, so im confused. Any input or suggestions on how to get the perc to host in the rose would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.
 
Clowns do what they want, and will host what they decide. You can't force the clown to host in the BTA.

I have 4 anems, 2 Crispa and 2 BTA. My clowns host the front corner of the glass. 1 of the anems is hosting my Bangaii Cardinals.
 
I acquired a bubble tip about 3 months ago and my percs do the same thing! They ignore the bubble tip and host in my brain.....I read on another post that its taken some people up to a year until they start hosting with there anemones....I hope ours wise up soon.
 
Some clowns will never host your anem. It's really upto what they are comfortable with.
 
is your clown wild? Most of the clowns you get today are tank raised and they never seen an anemone before. That could be why. Get a wild caught or get a different clown like a maroon.
 
Tank raised vs Wild Caught makes no difference. Hosting is instinctive, not learnt.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13371720#post13371720 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Zaita
I have 4 anems, 2 Crispa and 2 BTA. My clowns host the front corner of the glass. 1 of the anems is hosting my Bangaii Cardinals.

My biggest crispa is almost 1ft across. It could host a dozen clowns :P
 
Kobesan haha. Sorry to hear that Kobesan.

Chernandez, yes its a wild clown according to my friend.

I understand that its instinctive, but what i dont understand is why the perc was hosting in a rose in his tank but when brought over to mine he doesnt host in mine :( I mean, he/she does swim back and forth to the nem but it looks like he chose the torch as his/her main home.
clownandtorch.jpg


rose.jpg
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13372725#post13372725 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Zaita
Tank raised vs Wild Caught makes no difference. Hosting is instinctive, not learnt.

Kind of a bold statement. I'd say the verdict is still out on this one, although I tend to agree.

What appears interesting is that what might be instinctive is the memory of a smell -- even though they might never have smelled the smell before. Still, I don't think there is any doubt that CP clowns are more hesitant to host than wild ones. It seems to take them longer for some reason.
 
you could always try to lure it to the anemone with food
i did this in the past with a sebea
just get a turkey baster and some brine or mysis get the clown used to eating from it then staret putting the food in the anemone
took just a few days to get it to touch the anemone but once it did was like a warm blanket on a cold day
 
hey hey My clowns WILL host in this anemone I got for them.....OR ELSE!!!!


we get aquacultured percs, oce, and a cuople other species from a local breeder for our store and almost as soon as they hit the water they are all up in the anemones. I would agree its instictive.
 
I do agree that its instintive but I gave up on tank raised. I would tell you that from all 4 tanks I have that my best bet was buying a wild one. Within a day he was already hosting in an anemone. In the other three tank all are tank raised and they don't even look at the anemone. Maybe some day they will host who knows.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13379024#post13379024 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by chernandez88
I do agree that its instintive but I gave up on tank raised. I would tell you that from all 4 tanks I have that my best bet was buying a wild one. Within a day he was already hosting in an anemone. In the other three tank all are tank raised and they don't even look at the anemone. Maybe some day they will host who knows.

Alot of people have a more environmentally sustainable attitude though. They'd prefer to buy tank bred that may not host an anemone instead of wild caught that will host an anemone.

I've had no problems would our tank raised hosting anemones. They won't even get out of them :P
 
So I decided to move my rose where my torch use to be cuz I felt like it might of had to much flow there, turns out that my clown doesnt mind the nem there. Hes hosting in it now and hasnt really moved. Hopefully this will be his permanant home :)

Clownhostingrose.jpg


clownhostingrbta.jpg
 
Back
Top