Acrylic fabrication questions? I can help!

I honestly don't mean for this to come off as rude or anything, but your questions raise a big red flag and it makes me concerned so I have to ask: is this the first tank you've built?

The reason I ask is that your questions about the 4 seams and the assembly order are kinda basic, and the tank you are building is relatively large if this is a first project. Before you get started it's very important to understand why things are done in the order they are done. Because messing up means literally a thousand dollars in material down the drain.

After all your pieces are prepped, you should:

Bond both ends to the front (or back) panel, with back panel horizontal and ends vertical with 90 degree braces

Wait minimum of 8 hours before touching anything, longer with thicker material. I would wait 24 hrs personally.

Now prep the other panel, the back (or front) by getting it in position, and flip the whole front/sides assembly onto it. Front panel will bow so you need to support it so that the back/end joints are in full contact. Bond the other 2 joints. Don't touch for 24 hours.

Prep the 4 joints you just bonded to make sure that there are no lips between each panel. Use a razor to scrape, scrape, scrape until you have smooth transitions from piece to piece at the top/bottom bonding surfaces.

You don't have to do any flush trimming at this point - I usually wait until all bonding is done.

Now bond the top on. The reason you bond the top on first is that if you bond the bottom on first, then flip the tank to bond on the top, you have less air circulation in the tank and this can affect the joint curing (usually not). The more important reason is that if you flip and bond the euro on last, the bottom panel weighs a lot and can bow in the middle, resulting in a non-flush euro joint, which makes bonding less consistent, and it's nearly impossible to get inside the tank and add a brace to fix that. Another important reason is that if you bottom is on first, what happens if, when you set the joint, you need to run some solvent on the other side (inside)?

When bonding the euro first, when you flip to bond the bottom you a) don't have the weight displacing the joint, because of the cutouts b) you have air circulation c) you can get in the tank to add solvent from the other side of the joint d) you can add support.

For a tank this size, you definitely need to use the pins method and foam-covered MDF strips to even out the joint, shims if needed to make sure the joint is in full contact all the way around before adding pins (and adjusting after), a flat, level, and continuous working surface (i.e. not 2 or 3 tables pushed together), etc.

And I would assume that it is important to glue up all 4 seams in the same run, correct?

This is the question that threw up a big red flag for me. There is no other way to do it, you can't bond one half of a seam and wait to do the other, it just doesn't work that way. You have to run solvent into the whole seam, fix any bubbles if you are unlucky enough to get them, then start pulling pins and making sure the whole assembly doesn't start floating off, all in about 60 seconds.

If you have never used a #16 needle before, now is the time to practice. It looks super scary because the solvent comes out so fast, but it's not actually that bad once you get used to it, and it's about the only way you can run a 16 foot joint in less than 30 seconds. Using a standard #22 needle or the #20 flex needle will take you easily 4x as long, even when having a helper or two, you're going to be over 60 seconds before you start pulling pins and that's borderline too long.

Your tank is a pretty big undertaking and there are a couple steps that you really cannot afford to get wrong (well, I couldn't afford to at least!!!) so I'm just trying make sure you have your bases covered.

The other critical things are that the end pieces need to be perfectly square, or if they are "off" a little, both of them need to be identical and oriented the same with respect to each other (and not be that far off square). Then, the vertical dimension of the front/back needs to match the ends so that you minimize the lip you have to shave off with a razor. Make sure you leave a lip for a fillet on all final exterior joints & flush trim off after bonding is done.

General joint setting order: Blow off material with compressed air, wipe with denatured alcohol, blow again, position joint, add pins/shims, blow out with canned air, run solvent, pull pins, check joint alignment, wait for it to cure, flush trim, round, polish.

HTH
Bud
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, yes - first main display tank. Several sumps, etc, but nothing this large or this thick. I realize I might have gotten over my head but we will have to see how it goes at this stage of the game.

Luckily everything has been cut with a CNC and, so far, all of the pieces seem to be spot on as expected.

The #16 needle was a super piece of advice / info! I will need to find a source on that as the local suppliers only have 25 gauge. I also need to search for more info on the foam covered MDF. So far, I had only been using shims themselves. My flat surface is a full sheet of 3/4 MDF.

Thanks again for your time! It is greatly appreciated...

Shawn
 
This is the stuff I use (the specific brand)

http://www.menards.com/main/doors-w...l-foam-tape-weatherstrip/p-1914366-c-3624.htm

The stuff from Home Depot seems to be stick on the non-adhesive side, so your material tends to "grab" on to it. The Menards brand (Dennis) is not like this, so you can adjust the board once the piece is placed on it. The HD brand doesn't allow this, and sometimes it tears when you try to take it off so to me, it's useless.

Cut MDF strips about 6" wide and place 2 strips on each side. The bottom takes out the inconsistencies of your table, the top takes out material inconsistencies. Also this allows you to place a larger, wider shim under the MDF strip if you have a particularly bad area, this can minimize the shims under the joint. Very handy.

As for the needles, #25 is too small for anything really. #22 is what I use for almost everything except for top and bottom joints. Even on a 24x36 frag tank, I've switched to the #16 needle. It doesn't flex at all so you have to use it a bit differently (so you don't knock pins out of the joint while running solvent) but with a deep breath, steady hand, and a little practice, it's awesome.

Needles & applicator bottles:

https://www.craftics.net/ShowItems.aspx?Category=2&ParentCategory=3

2oz bottle for the #16 needle, item 1106058 (page 2)

#16 needle I thought came by itself but it appears they only carry it in the multi-pack, item 1106546 (page 3)

or in the 2 oz bottle + needles item 1106548

#22 needle 3 pack item 1106025

I would use WO #4 instead of #3, #3 tends to jump around in the joint, #4 allows for more joint handling time and flows better. Or make your own with MC and 5%-8% AA, if you can find the right stuff.

Most important is to not rush anything. It's good that you have the basic experience, you can build a lot of things with just that. Going to a large DT means you just have to pay attention to the fine details as they become more prevalent with larger builds.

I use (I think) 24 gauge picture hanging wire, cut it 4" long or so, then bend over & twist one end for a handle. On the joint side of that, I clip it with a sharp tool so that there is no burr on it (which would make it stick in the joint and hard to pull out - the built-in tool on the package leaves a bad edge). I've heard the dental wire is actually the best to use (for braces - stainless steel and durable)

For scooping bubble out, I get a dozen or so insulin syringes from a medical supply store. Most bubbles will push out when you pull the pins, but if you get a big one or are just really picky, use the syringe to "scoop" the bubble out. The needle is short, only about 3/4" long or less, but you don't need to "suck" the bubble out, just push the needle into the joint BEFORE you pull the pins, and slide it sideways and out so the air can escape, then follow with a #22 needle and 1/2 oz bottle to add some more solvent (if you have enough in the joint from the initial run, you may not need to do this). Like I said it's usually not a problem if you clean and blow the joint out but sometimes a bubble just gets in there no matter what you do and the insulin syringe is a very small needle that gets into the gap easily. Use once, throw it away - they're a few bucks for a dozen. Also you could use a thinner gauge wire instead of the needle.
 
I would use WO #4 instead of #3, #3 tends to jump around in the joint, #4 allows for more joint handling time and flows better.

I have always used #4, so i am good there.

I use (I think) 24 gauge picture hanging wire, cut it 4" long or so, then bend over & twist one end for a handle.

I started with 17 gauge guitar wire and found that it allowed too much solvent between the seams that squished out after I pulled it. I finally ended up with 10 gauge which gave me excellent results, but may take too long to apply. Also, with the 10 gauge, I can't stick anything in to scoop out bubbles.

Perhaps with the larger gauge I should just not attempt to put so much product in that I can visually see it fill the seam??
 
Hmm - I see the picture in one of your posts with the MDF and foam. Quite a bit of solvent outside of the seams. Is that same amount on the inside of the seam as well? Do you apply from the outside or inside?
 
Some people use garbage bag twist-ties and just strip off the paper. Wire gauge sizes get larger as the number gets smaller. 25 gauge is smaller than 10 gauge. You want smaller wire, use the 25 gauge.

You only need a gap that is enough to allow for the solvent to completely fill the joint. Too big of a joint will mean solvent will not capillary well into the joint and you have a higher propensity for getting air intrusion, and when you pull the pins, your solvent will squirt out everywhere. If you don't fill the joint completely, then your material will not have exposure to the solvent and you can end up with bad joints that look OK. EDIT: by that I mean the joint will "look good" but it's really not, there was no soak time and no bite into the material so the joint is inherently weak. Capillary joints are an example of this, they can be done so that they look OK, but they are weak and will snap at the joint vs a pin-set joint which will break at the material before the joint.

When you fill the joint and let it soak for 15-20 seconds, the material on either side will dissolve a bit and when you pull the pins and the pieces set together, the solvent/material mix will get pushed out of the joint and form a fillet on both sides. This is why you need to have a lip on your edge and not have the pieces cut to the exact finished dimension (which I hope you did not do). So for your front and back piece, you would want these to be 75.25 or 75.5 long, then you set up your joint such that you have 1/8 to 1/4" of extra material sticking out after you bond, and you flush trim that off. Ends are final dims all around (because they are bonded "inside" all the other parts), as are the height dimension of the front and back. The top and bottom are .25 to .5 extra on each plane, they get flush trimmed on all 4 sides.

You only should need to apply solvent from one side. The joint fills, you pull the pins, and the fillet forms on both sides. Occasionally I will run a very quick bead of solvent around both sides of the joint before pulling the pins but only on larger builds where the solvent starts to dry out before I can pull the pins. I stopped needing to do that after I switched to the #16 needle. But when I'm bonding on a bottom panel of a sump and have many baffles that I have to fill after making the perimeter pass, yes I will run a bead on the inside quickly.
 
Some people use garbage bag twist-ties and just strip off the paper. Wire gauge sizes get larger as the number gets smaller. 25 gauge is smaller than 10 gauge. You want smaller wire, use the 25 gauge.

Sorry - I mean .010 and .017 measured guitar strings - not gauge. Not sure that that equates to a gauge off hand.

So for your front and back piece, you would want these to be 75.25 or 75.5 long, then you set up your joint such that you have 1/8 to 1/4" of extra material sticking out after you bond, and you flush trim that off. Ends are final dims all around (because they are bonded "inside" all the other parts), as are the height dimension of the front and back. The top and bottom are .25 to .5 extra on each plane, they get flush trimmed on all 4 sides.

Yes, I did an overhang on all sides that need to be flush cut later. But I have been trying to always avoid any significant fillet since you cannot remove it from the inside edge. I have never really looked closely at the inside seams of a tank to notice if there where fillets or not.
 
I think you would be hard pressed to find any tank manufacturer that does not have an inside fillet on a solvent joint. It's imperative to keeping air out of the joint while the solvent evaporates, that is it's primary function. It's been a while since I read this entire thread from start to finish, but I don't recall wanting to remove the inside fillet being brought up.

The solvent usually dries to a very low profile and is hardly noticable, our LFS has a 1200g tank built by big tank builder out of 1.5" material and it's solvent welded with a fillet on the inside and that was a $25,000 tank.

About the only way to get the perfect & flawless looking joints is to use WO40 and that is a completely separate discussion - the method is very different. And you can't tell if your joint is good until the tank doesn't explode when you fill it, you can tell a solvent joint is good right away.
 
Excellent - thanks again! I am going to pick up some of the materials and some scrap and get used to the larger dispensing needle. Also go up in wire size. It looks like I was using about 31g. The .017 was about 27g.
 
Mayday, Mayday, Mayday

Mayday, Mayday, Mayday

So today i came home and noticed one of my acrylic joints on the tank opaque, I was probably minutes away from a huge disaster.

I need your opinion on how to proceed, i'm not sure this joint is salvageable. I drained the water from the tank, applied Weldon 40 and most of the joint took the weldon, clamped it but there are a few places where barely any weldon went in. I'm not sure what to do next. I guess i could always put a wedge in the tank between the joints. Any help would be appreciated it.

I provide a pic of the joint prior to the weldon application.
 

Attachments

  • photo.jpg
    photo.jpg
    46.6 KB · Views: 5
How long has the joint been like this? You can probably add in a corner gusset but it's not going to look pretty, especially if it's done with the tank up and running.
 
How long has the joint been like this? You can probably add in a corner gusset but it's not going to look pretty, especially if it's done with the tank up and running.

found it today, probably only hours. I thought of the corner gusset myself and i'm really out of options so that's what ill have to do. Questions is do i do the entire corner or just the part where the weld is weak? I don't want to drain the whole tank and transfer the fish and corals if i don't have too.

Thanks.
 
FWIW there is a tank in our LFS with white seams like that (that you could stick a piece of paper into) all over the place and it's been sitting there like that for years.

Not that you don't have to freak out...I would be! But your WO40 temp repair will probably buy you some time.

I would say that right now you don't absolutely have to to the whole seam, but at least a few inches past the bad area. Then I would start saving up for a new tank.

Usually that type of damage doesn't occur quickly like that.

Can you take a few pics of it currently? Take them using a flashlight to highlight the area and no camera flash. The tank light makes it really hard to see.
 
Thanks for the advice. The tank is 60x28x24 so it's gonna be a hard replacement. I have faith that the repair and the extra piece in the corner will last.

FWIW there is a tank in our LFS with white seams like that (that you could stick a piece of paper into) all over the place and it's been sitting there like that for years.

Not that you don't have to freak out...I would be! But your WO40 temp repair will probably buy you some time.

I would say that right now you don't absolutely have to to the whole seam, but at least a few inches past the bad area. Then I would start saving up for a new tank.

Usually that type of damage doesn't occur quickly like that.

Can you take a few pics of it currently? Take them using a flashlight to highlight the area and no camera flash. The tank light makes it really hard to see.
 
Thanks for the advice. The tank is 60x28x24 so it's gonna be a hard replacement. I have faith that the repair and the extra piece in the corner will last.
Hope that fixes it Paul, you took it all in stride yesterday - a lot calmer than I would have been in the same situation.

48" notched internal box

IMG_3929.jpg


Both boxes

IMG_3931.jpg


Close-up of external box (3/8" cast acrylic)

IMG_3932.jpg


Here's how they line up (2" slip x slip pass-through bulkheads)

IMG_3933.jpg


As you can tell I put the holes for the pass-through such that the bulkhead flanges are very close to the side/bottom panel. Maybe 1/2 or less of space. This works just fine, it's a small box, probably weighs more than the water that fills it, so making it 3/8" means it's really overbuilt. But I don't like making anything without a euro that is less than 3/8" (even an overflow box).

Floyd, are you using extra gaskets between the pass thru holes and the outside box?
 
Yes, I use a gasket on either side of the tank wall. Flange in the exterior box, nut on the inside. So from exterior to interior it goes flange, external box, gasket, tank wall, gasket, interior box, nut.
 
Oh, forgot to ask, what are your thoughts on the type of bulkheads to use for the pass thru with an external box about the size you built (3/8" - 1/2" acrylic) - regular ABS or schedule 80 bulkheads?
 
ABS is fine for most applications. Schedule 80 are a little more robust, but if you are really that worried the better route to go is a commercial grade bulkhead like one by Greenlee or Banjo. Get your hands on one of those and you'll see what I mean - the threads are 3x as deep, most are double-gasketed, and left-hand threaded (so they tighten as you screw a fitting into it, instead of loosening).

These are heavily used on farm implements such as sprayer tanks, etc. But $$
 
Back
Top