ATI Bubblemaster 200 vs. MSX 200
- Thread starter grandp10
- Start date
luke33
In Memoriam
The point is that the skimmer sometimes can't handle the pump, and its because of the large riser tube in the reaction chamber. It turns the skimmer into a smaller diameter and it can't take the air. So in return you have to throttle it down and don't get the performance out of the pump you should. It still works, but it could work better if it were designed differently.
luke33
In Memoriam
Sjm, on a differerent note instead of arguing as we both like our skimmers and they both work how long have you ran the mesh without re meshing it. I've ran mesh for over a year straight on a couple differnt skimmers with no problems. I've never had dirt or anything build up on it either. But i will say the flatback mesh is much stronger than the regular pf4.
dobly_1999
Member
Concerning the durabilty of the mesh, do you guys use a filter sock before the skimmer? I would like to go without a sock, or use it to "polish" the water.
Now, the cost is a big factor. I am considering the AquaC EV-240 Protein Skimmer because of concerns with Mesh wheel. After reading the above responses, the mesh doesn't seem to be a problem. The other factor, when will Marine Solutions have the skimmers in stock?
Now, the cost is a big factor. I am considering the AquaC EV-240 Protein Skimmer because of concerns with Mesh wheel. After reading the above responses, the mesh doesn't seem to be a problem. The other factor, when will Marine Solutions have the skimmers in stock?
The original mesh on the BM250 lasted a little over a year. What happened is the tie wraps broke on one of the pumps. The original mesh was the flatback type. I replaced it with the same and it has been fine since. Never had any any accumulation in the Mesh. I use filter socks since I like a clean sump.
dobly_1999
Member
SJM, do you have pictures of your tank and setup? I would like to see them.
