best pizza in Rochester is where?

[Gary Majchrzak]

*PANDORA'S BOX ALERT*
this is a subjective topic... similar to "what's the best type of lighting for a reef aquarium", so let's not get into a fistfight here :lolspin:

I've established a sort of tradition with my daughter called "pizza night".
We like Boboli but we need new pizza to sample. Realistically, I'm not gonna drive to Syracuse or Buffalo for pizza... but I'll entertain your suggestions in case I'm in one of those cities.
It's time to go where no pepperoni has gone before... we need suggestions.
Where can you find the best pizza in upstate NY?

 

[Jacwil]

Pizza Hut FTW!!!

 

[Gary Majchrzak]

Pizza Hut FTW!!!

this is one of her favorites! Deep dish pepperoni lovers. And the "crane game" :lol:

 

[siobhan2086]

#1 Chester Cab
#2 Tony D's
#3 Pittsford Pontillos



sorry, I almost forgot Bay Goodman

 

[badinfo]

1) Carbones
2) Marks
3) Salvatores

IMHO

 

[Johnny C]

It's all subjective to your personal taste... thin crust vs. deep dish, plain vs. toppings, sweet sauce or not, so on and so fourth. Blue cheese is another major factor!

There's a ton of awesome places to get a pie in Buffalo, but Johnny's has the best (no pun intended)!

 

[chrisqueenz]

Pizza stop on on State street! If you enjoy NYC pizza, thats where you want it from

 

[teamdulski]

Have yet to find anything I like in Roc.

But for the Buff....
Mr. Pizza and francos are my fav.

 

[SkiFletch]

Franco's is good in Buffalo. But my two favorites are Bob and John's on Hertel or Leonardi's at Millersport and Eggert. Both are heavy Basil sauce, none of this sugar nonsense

 

[MichaelDavid]

Digirono pizza @ your local grocery store FTW. Haha

 

[Gary Majchrzak]

Digirono pizza @ your local grocery store FTW. Haha

ewww! I won't touch frozen pizza even on a bachelor night!
I like Chester Cab.
Tony D's is more for a "date night" than my daughter... but I might take her there some day.
We like Spencerport and Batavia Pontillos. I think the Batavia one is the original?

Mark's is good pizza.

Bay and Goodman was written up as one of the "best" years (decades?) ago in the D & C but I haven't had it since I was 16 years old.

 

[Gary Majchrzak]

Pizza stop on on State street! If you enjoy NYC pizza, thats where you want it from

never heard of this one!

I had Carbone's. It was good. Krony's is good, too.

 

[magdelan]

Mark's is good pizza.

Bleh! :thumbdown <--- couldn't find a puking smiley.

Carbones is probably closer to you (and is good), but my wife and I stand by Guidas. It's where it's at! Bay and Goodman is great too.

 

[Gary Majchrzak]

Every Mark's might be different. The pizza I had from Mark's in Webster was always really good!

I heard of Guidas... where's it at?

 

[jfl14609]

Gary not sure if you make it to perinton at all but perinton pizza has a garbage plate pizza but out this way I think kroys is my favorite or carbones. I hate the cams near you though sometimes its just terrible

 

[Firedog1962]

Salvatores in east rochester Rocks

 

[magdelan]

Guidas

Guidas

I've heard of Guidas... where's it at?

Here is their website Go find out.

 

[Conesus_Kid]

Guida's is in Honeoye Falls.

Main st. Pizza in Batavia is one of the best I've had.

 

[Willistein]

My house. Man, we make a mean greek pizza.

 

[reefer buddy]

I know it is not standard Pizza but Great Northern pizza in Brighton has some good Pizza. Lots to choose from and by the slice.