Biggest difference in a large vs. medium sized tank?

Catastrophi

New member
So my cousin is shutting down his 200 gallon and made an offer I couldn't refuse. I currently have a 75 gallon.

My question is whats the biggest difference from going from medium sized tank to a large one? and what would you have done differently then you had in the past.
 
in your case at least 125 gallons...LOL i had too...i am in the planning stages of a custom 100...so i cant help you with the logistics of a bigger tank..:(

but i will certainly stay tuned for help as well...
 
Haha I dont think I could get away with that. I still live with my parents and they allowed for the 200 since I'm gettin such a good deal on it lol.
 
Thing about the electric bill is

You took the words right out of my mouth!

For one you can have more fish.
You can have bigger fish.
Because you have more water volume, its my belief that your tank will be more stable.
Because you tank is larger, your tank will be less effected by ambient temperature changes which makes for a healthier envoirnment for the fish.
You will be able to have more sand and live rock which will provide more indiginous food to your fish while being more self sustaining.
I think in you can afford a larger tank, it usually better when it comes to salt water.

That said, I am always amazed when newbies to salt water that start with these little nanos and have great success with corals and such. My brother is a great example. No experience and a 20G nano and his corals are thriving. Go figure.

On the smaller tank side, you have less exposure when disaster strikes.
Its easier and cheaper to correct issues with water changes to avoid potential disasters. A large water change in a small tank is much easier to do which makes it easier to people with little experience to have more success without burning themselves out. Rarely do you read a thread in the drygoods for sale section titled " Nano for sale. Leaving the hobby" followed by "due to economic issues, I cant afford my tank anymore".... Its most always a larger system.
 
Last edited:
You took the words right out of my mouth!

For one you can have more fish.
You can have bigger fish.
Because you have more water volume, its my belief that your tank will be more stable.
Because you tank is larger, you tank will be less effect by ambient temperature changes.
You will be able to have more sand and live rock which will provide more indiginous food to your fish while being more self sustaining.
I think in you can afford a larger tank, it usually better when it comes to salt water.

That said, I am always amazed when newbies to salt water start with these little nanos and have great success with corals and such. My brother is a great example. No experience and a 20G nano and his corals are thriving. Go figure.

On the smaller tank side, you have less exposure when disaster strikes.
Its easier and cheaper to correct issues with water changes. A large water change in a small tank is much easier to do which makes it easier to people with little experience to have more success without burning themselves out.

Thanks those are some awesome tips! In my 75 I have always been wary to buy any larger fish since I didnt want to overstock or cramp them. With this tank, Ill have so much more room. I've always wanted some nice tangs.

So do you have any tips for waterchanges, basically carrying 20gallons of water! It was a lot easier with my 75, I Just did about one bucket a week.
 
I use a Brute trashcan to mix my new water, and vacuum out my sump to remove settled detritus.
After I bring the new water up to temp, I then pump it into the sump and turn the return pump back on.
The fish never know what happened.
 
I use the wheeled attachment for the Brute.

If you don't have a water supply on that floor, you can get a 25 ft. long (or longer) polytube for your ro/di to reach the can.

Am I confused about carrying 20 gallons of water?
 
Adding more fish? Might need a larger skimmer.

Adding more corals? Might need a reactor. :D

It all depends on bioload and calcium requirements.
 
Skimmer first. you can does a 2-part or maybe get away with water changes on Calc. Water changes help with cleaning, but there are very few things in a Reef tank that are more importand then having a good skimmer.
 
technically, i can't comment because i started with a 200gal.
however, i had read for 2 years prior thinking about ~120gal
and so maybe can comment.

the biggest issue i cam across was that i had utterly underestimated
how big a supply of premixed saltwater i needed. in common
with many folks, i had a 32gal brute bin, and this just isn't enough.
(given my 80gal sump, 32gal is about 12%, and i regret not having more.

otherwise, the 200gal is just great. it will give you more options
for aquascaping and allow fish that need more space (e.g. tangs).
 
Back
Top