Carpet Anemones

Kent D.

New member
I wanted to see from the experts out there what the take is on having multiple carpets in one tank. I recently got a green haddoni from a person that had three in the tank with no issues. I then picked up a red haddoni and all is well. Of course I have my eye on a blue one now to round it out but want to see what others have and experience with multiple carpets in a tank.

CIMG5909.jpg
 
I think most folks would say having 3 different haddoni anemones shouldn't cause you any trouble. Those are all different color morphs of the same species, Stichodactyla haddoni. You also have a BTA in there, I see from the pic. That is of course an entirely different species and could potentially lead to problems. The most obvious issue would be direct physical contact from the two different species. They could sting each other quite severely. Also, some people report problems from having two or more species in the same system, regardless of whether or not they're touching. Here the issue is called allelopathy, and has to do with chemical shedding into the tank water that ultimately irritates other species. The suggested remedy, if not keeping the tank dedicated to one species, is to run activated carbon and regularly change out the carbon.
 
All three the same species will be fine but mixing nems like you have in the picture is not reccomended. I would get that condy or bta (cant really tell which it is) out of the tank or at least moved further away from the haddonis.
 
I have kept different color morphs of S. Haddonis in the same tank for years without issue. However, I have always had issues when attempting to mix species, and would suggest sticking to just one.

Also, very minor concern that the red one is on the rocks.
 
I've also had no problems with multiple carpets (even two different types once). I've also had little issues with mixing one BTA type (e. actinostoloides) with giganteas, but no success mixing carpets with other anemones otherwise.
 
Make sure the new anemone that you add into the tank is healthy. Quarantine it if you can. I have lost two helathy carpet when I ordered a blue one that turn out to be sick. It died first and the other two, one one year and the other two years in my tank follow within 3 weeks.
Becareful or your 600 dollars worth of carpets will go down the drain.
 
Thanks for all the information. I really appreciate the feedback. I will most likely get the condy out of the tank. The red moved today up on the rock more but has moved closer to the sand like the green one is.

Are Blues the most senstive of the three colors for haddoni's? I am getting the blue from a very good store i have done business with for some time now. He has had it for two weeks and said his wholesaler has had it for three weeks before he got it.
 
Over the last 12 years I have had....green, green stripe, green with purple rim, red, blue and finally tan. I have notice zero difference in their care/difficulty. The only thing is that for rare color morphs one might be willing to purchase one that isn't 100% -- meaning if it was a "plain" one it would be passed over since it wasn't healthy enough.
 
As Todd says, it really depends on the health of the anemone. Even an anemone in poor health can last a few weeks and then suddenly go poof.

Here in Japan, it is pretty easy these days to find a healthy gigantea (green, blue, purple, tan). Many are harvested relatively locally, and they are fairly common in the local trade. However, a healthy color haddoni is rather rare, especially as they don't tend to be found in such local waters. And people tend to buy these poor specimens anyway at the mad premium prices charged here (including myself early on).

My first carpet was a red haddoni that was not in the best shape. Needless to say, it didn't last very long. The only haddoni I managed to keep was a small blue-greyish one that wasn't spectacularly colored, but was in great health and locally caught. Learning firsthand what "CHEMICAL WARFARE" meant led to this anemone's demise, which was very sad.

In any case, color is pretty meaningless if it's not going to live more than a month. I've never been able to rehabilitate a haddoni in bad shape, but I'm sure there are people who can.
 
CIMG5987.jpg


CIMG5989.jpg


CIMG5982.jpg


anemone crab seems to prefer the green carpet :)

CIMG6017.jpg




working on getting the condy out.....any sugestions of the best method? The red carpet has almost moved complete off the rock the condy is on. The green I believe is barried under the rock so once the red moves all the way off I can work on the condy in a bucket. I attempted once already in the tank and the condy is barried into a hole that is going to be very tough. I know I can do the power head on it to help it decide to move. Is the ice cube trick really work?
 
*if you can remove the rock the condy is attached to*

you should be able to tease it's foot off the rock.

suspend it's rock in the air and allow the anemone to hang upside down over a bucket of water. Gently tapping the rock (to cause vibrations) may speed up the process.
 
use a strong powerhead (MJ1200 is good choice) or pump to blast water at the anemones foot. Get it to move or lift up it's foot so you can get a finger under it.
 
Back
Top