Collecting angelfish west of Key West with a legend

copps

Premium Member
Hey guys, as many of you may know some of my many passions related to this hobby involve both scuba diving and fish collecting. Combine it with my love for angels (I own over 40) and I'm in Heaven. I always tell people to get fish that excite THEM, not other people. Well, while these days it's usually the rare and unusual that excite me, I am also excited by fish that I am able to collect myself. I've posted some other threads in the past on RC"¦ like collecting the personatus angel, collecting with Julian Sprung, and others"¦ here is one collecting in Hawaii for those interested"¦
http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1708758
Last month I was down in South Florida again speaking for FMAS, the Florida Marine Aquarium Society, a great and historic club now over 50 years old. The day before I spoke I met up with Eric Pederson, a friend of a few years and a legend in the Keys. Eric has been a long time collector/ wholesaler in the Keys since the 80s, and has discovered many things along the way"¦ most notably Pederson's cleaner shrimp which many of you have heard of, named after him. Eric is one of so many great guys in the business, with a treasure trove of information that could only be amassed with THOUSANDS of hours of dive time in a specific area. I love meeting up with guys like this. Eric is a hardcore fishhead and on top of the amazing diving we did I got a full day of excellent stories. I had been fish collecting in the past in Florida, but I gave Eric one request"¦ I wanted to collect my own queen angels. I had never collected in the Keys before, just further up north I'd collected blue angels (and frenches and grays), but never a queen. Queens can be seen up north, but they are found in much greater numbers out on the reefs, and further south. Eric needed to catch some angels anyway to fill an order, so it worked out perfect.

The day was excellent and ended up being a full 18 hours for me. I started at 4 am from my mother's place in Lighthouse Point, in the Fort Lauderdale area. I arrived to Eric's facility in Marathon at around 7 am, and in his truck we drove an extra hour or so to Key West. Eight hours round trip for the day but there is perhaps no more of a beautiful drive than this in the US. We launched in his boat and off we went"¦ here we are leaving the harbor"¦
1_leaving_harbor.jpg

Just for the boat ride alone it was worth it"¦ after a little while we passed downtown Key West"¦ with beautiful weather!
2_key_west.jpg

Next came Sunset Key, a developed island only accessible by boat full of cheap real estate"¦ :D
3_sunset_key.jpg

We shot the gap between Sunset Key and Wisteria Island"¦ this little beach on Sunset Key was where the final scene of the movie "œOffice Space" was filmed"¦ when Milton was on the beach drinking margaritas"¦ :D If you have not seen this movie it is a must see, particularly for anyone who works in an office!
4_sunset_key.jpg

We headed out about six miles until we got decent visibility"¦ this was a clean up boat we passed on the way, still contracted for an insane amount of money per day in case oil from the Gulf rolled in"¦
5_clean_up_boat.jpg
 
Alright… enough about the journey… we hit the water and did three long dives. The diving was excellent. On most of my dives in Florida blue angels by far outnumber the queens, but here was different, as was expected. It is generally believed that queens (and French angels) evolved as an off shore species, and blues (and grays) as a coastal species. The queens by far outnumbered the blues here, and the townsend’s. The townsend angel is now known to be a naturally occurring hybrid between the blue and queen angel, after being described originally as a separate species (Holacanthus townsendi). They are relatively common throughout Florida, where the ranges of blues and queens overlap. Today though mainly, the target was queens. Eric has I believe thousands of GPS sites... and knows where to find a few things… :) Here are some shots of the resulting livewell… the fish that I caught that I was keeping for myself were kept separate and are shown below. Sorry there are no underwater shots, but we had no photographer… and my hands were full enough chasing angels!
12_catch1.jpg


13_catch2.jpg


14_catch3.jpg


15_catch4.jpg

Everything I kept for myself I caught on the last dive. The last dive happened to be when I saw the most small queens and other things. Also, the first dive I was a bit of a spectator just admiring the beautiful reef, forgetting that I was there to collect! I caught a large queen (between 7 and 8 inches) on the first dive. Eric told me it took him six months before he caught his first queen… I told him I had collected before, just hadn’t collected queens… ;) It took me a bit to get my bearings… every collector, and region really, has their ways of collecting fish. I was given just one hand net… no barrier net, and no “chase” net. The chase net is usually a net I use to show the fish… used to scare the fish into the actual collection net. Well, the chase net on these dives was my HAND… :) which ended up getting pretty beat up and now weeks later the scabs have just healed. Each species has their tendencies, and queens and blues usually quietly hide in a crevice, or just out run you. Careful placement of the hand net, followed by “digging” with my hand to scare them out, netted some good results (pun intended). It was a bit risky, as there are many eels, and I saw a number of lionfish on these dives (sigh :(), but it paid off!
 
Everything I caught on my first two dives I gave to Eric, and six of the fish I caught on my last dive I kept for myself. Here’s the fish riding back to port… I kept mine in the red bucket…
10_live_well.jpg

Here are the three queens I caught on my last dive to keep for myself… I don’t care who you are… even someone who knows nothing of reef fish… the queen angel is arguably the most beautiful fish in the ocean, and we should be proud as Americans to host this species!
Queen #1 I collected, bad pic but an amazing fish and the perfect size!
21_queen1.jpg

Queen #2…
26_queen3.jpg

And queen #3… while there is no ugly queen angel, these are some of the most beautiful, showing much more blue than Brazilian specimens…
25_queen2.jpg


24_queen.jpg

I also wanted to collect my own rock beauty, another species I hadn’t collected before. After collecting some larger ones, on the last dive I snagged this small specimen.
27_rock_beauty.jpg

I collected a large juvenile french also…
23_french.jpg

… and a spotfin butterfly…
22_spotfin.jpg

All six fish made it safely back to Virginia and are currently in quarantine…
 
Here’s a good sized townsend Eric caught…
6_townsend.jpg

… and a shot of it next to a full queen for comparison…
townsend.jpg

Eric in his office on the steam back in…
11_eric_driving.jpg

Going back through Key West… I’d rather be on our boat than one of these cruise ships… :)
7_cruise_ships.jpg


8_key_west.jpg


9_cruise_ships.jpg


Eric transferring the fish into a bucket for transport from the truck to his facility… only about 20 feet so don’t worry about all these fish in a bucket!
16_eric_and_queen.jpg
 
Last edited:
How about these shots… again they were in the bucket for about 30 seconds so don’t worry… :)… but what a sight!
BUCKET ‘O ANGELFISH…
17_bucket1.jpg


18_bucket2.jpg


19_bucket3.jpg


Thanks again to Eric… another page in the angelfish memory book for me!
20_eric_and_me.jpg


Copps
 
Last edited:
Thanks so much guys... :)

Time for car key pictures...

Thanks for sharing this wonderful adventure !

Key shots coming soon... :) I had a rental down there...

The wound on your thumb courtesy of a queen angel ?

Anyways the green on that queen angel in that french angel picture is almost wrasse-like

Yeah... the back of my hand was torn up... funny what evolution did putting fatty tissue on the palms of our hands to protect them... :)

The queens colors are tough to capture in a photo... they show a different color and sheen deending on the angle and light source...
 
Thanks again guys... Collecting your own fish is rather easy in Florida... with a standard fishing license you are able to do it, and many species could be collected at many locations with just a hand net. Most of the issue is actually the logistics of getting the fish back home. Juvenile french and gray angels are rather easy to find and catch at many of the inlets and coastal reefs in South Florida... blues could also be found but are much tougher to catch...
 
Great looking fish, must have been a fantastic trip! Thanks for sharing! I got a question about that Hamlet, was it a Blue one (Hypoplectrus gemma) or an Indigo (H. indigo)? It looks more like an Indigo to me, but the colors look off, and I heard the Blue gets those bars when stressed...
 
Back
Top