Comparing notes and habits

dgasmd

New member
It seems most, if not almost all, threads in this forum are from someone setting up a larger tank. That in itself has surprisingly gotten so extremely popular that nobody even raise an eyebrow anymore when someone says they are doing a 300g tank!! I guess the economy must be really good............ Back to topic!!

I always wonder what does people do in their maintenance and what products they use not in the set up as those are obvious ones, but rather in their daily/weekly/monthly maintenance. We sort of assume we all do the same with some minor variations, but I am aways curious to see if there is more to differences than similarities. So, why don't you copy/paste the questions in bold below and just fill in with your answers. Many of us may learn a few things.

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I do a bi-weekly 100g water change (10% of my system). I will be stepping it down to monthly.

What salt do you use and why? I use IO. Because I have been using it all along with good results. Also, it is the cheapest I can find.

What type of carbon do you use and why? I use Two Little Fishies hydrocarbon. I change it every 6 weeks. I use 2 Lb each time (1/2 bucket). It is the "best" (subjective data only) I have found although not the cheapest.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? I use Phosban 600gr (1/2 bucket) and change it every 6 weeks. No difference in performance compared to Rowaphos regardless of how much they love to say it is. Cheaper too.

How often do you feed and why/what? I feed every other day to every third day. I feed frozen Pro-Salt foods and PE mysis shrimp. I also feed decapsulated brine shrimp eggs and cyclopeeze once per week. I was feeding multiple times per day and all I got was a bunch of unwanted algae. My anthias don't seem to be missing the daily feeding either, and I can't tell a difference from looking at any of the fish.

How often do you clean your glass? About once per week I pass the magnet. About once per month I scrape any extra coralline.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? From every week to every 6 weeks. Average is about every 4 weeks or so.

Do you dose anything else? I "squirt" a good amount of 20% strntium chloride of ESV brand weekly and a few dropper full of Kent's lugol solution every other week. I seems to have boosted my coralline like wildfire and the colors look better on the corals too!!

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? Currently use the Schuran media. Will be going back to crushed coral when it runs out. No difference really and so much cheaper. Also locally available.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? If my LFS would get the stuff I order in the sizes I want, I would give them the business even at a higher cost. I currently buy it all, except for the frozen food, online and get it to last me a few months at a time. Even with shipping included the LFS can't come even close in cost either.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? Realistically, about every 5-6 weeks. Should have been doing it more often, but it is a PITA. I will get a shallow sand bed in the future.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? I do it about every 4-6 weeks. I wipe off everything and try to clean the cooling fins on all the pumps. I wanted to take apart all the pumps and soak the wet ends on vinegar for 3 hours at least once per year, but it has not happened in the first 2 years yet.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? I solely use a Ca reactor these days. I was also using Kalk and found no added benefit. I was an extra piece of equipment to mantain and had to also buy kalk by the buckets (TLF brand).

Your turn...................
 
593968_13_05_1_rc.JPG


Before the break but when it was running ........
How often do you change water and what % of the total system? Weekly/15%

What salt do you use and why? Oceanic because I like the Ca and Mg levels.

What type of carbon do you use and why? Chemgon because it works well and requires very little rinsing.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much?
Don't use.

How often do you feed and why/what? 3 times a day because the fish load was high and had a lot of high energy fish.

How often do you clean your glass? Every few days.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Had three units and would clean one every three our four days.

Do you dose anything else? Just a two part Ca solution.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Local sort of.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vacuum the bottom? Every couple of weeks.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? Only when needed.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? With a MTC Dual Doser.

When the new tank is up I'll still do all the same things as before.
 
O.k. I'll play-

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? Weekly 40 gallons, 12% total volume.

What salt do you use and why? SeaChem Reef Salt. Parameters are very close to my targets.

What type of carbon do you use and why? SeaChem Matrix carbon. It works for me.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Zeovit.

How often do you feed and why/what? Once or twice daily. A mixture of frozen, flake and pellet. Soon I will try making my own.

How often do you clean your glass? Every 5-6 days.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? BK 300 internal cleaned every 4 days.

Do you dose anything else? Amino Acids, Potassium Iodide Flouride, Potassium, Iron.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Online

If you are barebottom, how often do you vacuum the bottom? N/A SSB

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? Only when needed.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? MRC CR-6 Dual calcium reactor. Schuran style media with ~15% Mag granules.


CAReefer
 
I'm not sure that I really qualify as having a large tank anymore - some people on this forum have monsters that make my 215 look like a foot bath! :cool: I just drool over DGasMDs tank! Anyway......

How often do you change water and what % of the total system?

Once per month I change 25 gallons (about 10%)

What salt do you use and why?

Seachem Reef. I like the Ph buffering and calcium levels. Mixes well.

What type of carbon do you use and why?

Marineland. I run about 4 cups at a time and change it once a month. It works just fine and is available in the bulk sizes at my favorite LFS.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much?

No.

How often do you feed and why/what?

Daily - Spectrum marine pellets. All of the fish eat them and seem to do great on them.
Twice a week - A whole silverside for my anemone. Frozen marine-plankton, cyclopeeze, and Hakari baby brine shrimp for the corals. A little bit of chaeto from the sump for the tang and clean-up crew.

How often do you clean your glass?

Daily cleanings with the magnet. About once a month I break out the razor blade for the stubborn stuff.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup?

Once a month.

Do you dose anything else?

1) 5ml of Seachem Iron supplement a week.
2) Magnesium supplement (seachem although I'm going to switch brands based based on some input on the Reef Chemistry Forum) as required by testing.
3) Arm and Hammer baking soda as required to maintain alk at 9-10. This is usually 4 tsp per week.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use?

None. I dose lime (sold as Cal Mexicana at Fiesta Mart) with my top-off water.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally?

Most of the expensive stuff I buy on-line. I want to support my LFS but they can't compete with on-line prices, especially with free shipping and no sales tax. I buy most of my consumables from my LFS as needed.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom?

NA

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often?

Check everything weekly and do wipe downs as required. I also wipe off the T5s and reflectors.
Monthly I do a tear down of my skimmer and clean the main body and the venturi.
Quarterly the pumps gets vinegar baths and cleanings. I usually do one pump a month and alternate through.
 
Re: Comparing notes and habits

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? It varies but I try to do a bi-weekly 200 to 250 g water change (about 50% of my system).

What salt do you use and why? I use NSW I collect from a local university that is filtered down to 20 microns by them. It's been working great in my other reef so I just continued using it when I set up the big tank. That's all this tank has ever seen.

What type of carbon do you use and why? It varies. Right now, I use Seachem carbon and phosphate remover. Before, it was black diamond because it was readily available and cheap. I run it in a fluval canister w/ polyfilter pads as well.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? See above.

How often do you feed and why/what? I feed a large sheet of nori from the asian market every day. I feed pellets three times a week. I've tried frozen foods but my larger fish were acustomed to eating sinking pellets and won't look at any other foods so I just kept with it. I feed zoo playkton on occasion for the smaller fish but the big fish like it too.

How often do you clean your glass? About thwice a week when I think about it. I'll probably do it more often once I get the tank moved into the house.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Twice a week. I have large fish. I also have a large swimming pool canister fliter that I clean twice a week at the same time. Big fish poop a lot. ;)

Do you dose anything else? I don't dose anything unless it's needed.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? Some off brand I got from a comerical catalog. Just can't remember the name of the company but it's a big one. I built my own Ca reactor.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Where ever I can find the best deal. Usually online.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? NO. Maybe I should start.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? I solely use a Ca reactor these days. If I need to add more, then I use Seachem addatives.
 
Good topic dgasmd. I will give some answers a little later.

Could you guys add a question to be answered?

How often do you calibrate your controller/monitor probes?
 
How often do you calibrate your controller/monitor probes? Right now my PH one is broke and I think I also need a ORP one as well. When they are working, I cal them when they look like they are reading wrong, or once a month.
 
How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I try to do 20 gallons every 2 weeks.

What salt do you use and why? I use Tropic Marin. I've tried IO and Oceanic and wasn't happy with each. Tropic Marin seemed to have the closest balance in terms of elements for me.

What type of carbon do you use and why? Black Diamond. Honestly I haven't used carbon in my tank in about 6 months. I have 3 liters sitting by but honestly have not seen a need to add it.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? I use no PO4 media. I have 0 bad algae in my tank beside the normal small amounts of hair algae that grow on top of the inside overflows. I scrape it clean once a month and it is probably a golfball size worth.

How often do you feed and why/what? I feed 2 to 3 times per day. I have a school of anthias now so I feed small amounts.

How often do you clean your glass? I clean the glass about twice a week with my magnet if I get time or once a week if I'm busy. It doesn't get bad. Corraline if I don't clean the glass often will cover my glass in two weeks.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Once a week my skimmer cup is full usually.

Do you dose anything else? I do not dose any chemicals beside the occasional magnesium that I make myself.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? I use ARM because I was unable to find the Schruan. It is a 6" diameter x 18" high reactor. I believe I am dripping about 60ml-70ml a minute at a ph of 6.7.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? I only buy PE mysis locally and every other food I make myself. All other supplies beside salt and flake food I buy online.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? I'm not BB. I have a mix of DSB and SSB.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? I clean all my equipment and pumps every 6 months. My probes I dip in vinegar usually every 2 months for my ph and 3 weeks for my orp.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? Soley by my Calcium reactor. Occasionally if needed I'll top off with my calcium homemade mix or baking soda.

How often do I calibrate my probes? My Ph probes I only calibrate when I notice they are consistently off. I've noticed this generally happens for me in the 7 to 9 month range.

My growth on my sps can be seen within just a couple days. I have some that are an inch away and If I don't pay attention, will be touching the other pieces in just a couple weeks.
 
Re: Re: Comparing notes and habits

Re: Re: Comparing notes and habits

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? weekly - 5% to 10%

What salt do you use and why? Usually natural water; sometimes Reef Crystal or Tropic Marin

What type of carbon do you use and why? Kent.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? not yet. I´ll problably use Rowaphos

How often do you feed and why/what? Once or twice a day. Randomly: Mysys, Red plancton, Marine cuisine, Red and Black worms larvae, Nori, pellets and flake

How often do you clean your glass? weekly

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? weekly

Do you dose anything else? Only kalkwasser (limewater ?)

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? CA reactor is not in use yet

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Depends; most locally

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? Not yet. Planning on doing it every 6 months or so

How do you replace Ca/ALK? I´ll use a Ca reactor
 
Thanks for the responses so far. It is amazing that after 178 views, only 8 people have taken the time to reply. I think this is incredible data to compile actually. One of the things I loved about Paletta's last book was the ability to actually see what other 50 people with successfull tanks do and compare notes. Very educational in more than one way. Too bad others are not taking a couple of minutes to reply.
 
I'll also play....

How often do you change water and what % of the total system?

Weekly 30 gallons water changes, so alittle over 10%.

What salt do you use and why?

I also use Seachem because, like CAreefer said, it is closest to the levels I am targeting.

What type of carbon do you use and why?

I use the zeovit carbon, Korallen-zucht. I like it because it doesn't take too long to rinse and I get the added benefit of it absorbing some nitrate.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much

Zeovit

How often do you feed and why/what?

I feed 2 times a day....I have a lot of fish; have 5 angels, so I need to keep them well feed.

I actually feed a homemade food, basically the same receipe you use dgasmd ;). I alter is a little every time and my fish love it :).

I also feed nori every day. Between my angels and tangs, they go through a full sheet daily.

How often do you clean your glass?

Every 4-5 days I use a magnet and then once a month I try to wipe the coralline off, but only if I am not too lazy, haha.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup?

On my BK 300 internal I get a full collection cup of skimmate every 2-3 days, so I have to drain that. Then I try to clean it once a week.

Do you dose anything else?

I use the zeovit supplements:

- Pohl's Coral Vitalizer
- Amino Acid high concentrate
- PFI (PotassiumIodide Fluoride)
- Fe (Iron)
- ZeoSpur2
- K-balance

What type of Ca reactor media do you use?

I use a Deltec pf500 CaRx, with ther Deltec media.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally?

Online.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom?

I try to do it every week when I do my water change....

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often?

I try to wipe the pumps down every month, I should soak them in vinegar once a year, but so far have not done that (tank has been up a year).

Other equipment as needed.

How do you replace Ca/ALK?

I just use a CaRx.....

Very good idea Alberto;).

Nick
 
Re: Comparing notes and habits

Here's my input based on my 180. I have around 250 total gallons.

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I try to do about 30g per month. So a bit less than 10%.

What salt do you use and why?
I use IO. Because that was the first bucket of salt I purchased and I have no reason to switch. I also find good prices on IO locally.

What type of carbon do you use and why?
I actually don't recall the type of carbon I use at the moment.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much?
I run 1/2 a jar of phosban in a Two Little Fishes reactor.

How often do you feed and why/what?
I try to feed daily, but if I get home after the main lifghts are turned off, I don't bother. I feed a mix every other day. First day is all frozen. Mysis and something else. Maybe prime reef, angel cubes, formula I/II, sometimes fishy food (toofishy.com). On the other day I feed Omega flake food.

How often do you clean your glass?
I run the mag float over the glass one a day or every other day. I get the high duity scrapper out once a month or so.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup?
It various, but I'd say once per week or every other week.

Do you dose anything else?
I dose B-Ionic for CA and Alk.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use?
I currently have no Ca reactor, although I really need one soon.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally?
I get almost everything locally at Something Fishy (www.toofishy.com).

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom?
N/A - I run a SSB.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often?
I clean my pumps about once a month. I don't really clean plumbing.

How do you replace Ca/ALK?
See above - dose BIonic. I also run a ReefTek kalk reactor.

How often do you calibrate monitors
I only monitor temp and PH. I calibrate my PH probe whenever I suspect that it's reading incorrectly. In reality, maybe once every three months. I've never calibrated my temp sensors.
 
Re: Comparing notes and habits

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I do 5 gal or so a week by skimming wet. THen about 25% monthly

What salt do you use and why? I use IO. Because I have been using it all along with good results. Also, it is the cheapest I can find.

What type of carbon do you use and why? Marineland because of decent pricing with good reputation. I do not use it in the tank 100% of the time, but I should.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? I use Phosban in a Two little Fishes reactor and change it ocassionaly. I have not used Rowaphos.


How often do you feed and why/what? I usually feed at least once a day. About 50% it is spectrum pellets or flakes, the other 50% is frozen foods. Mysis, brine, prime reef. I feed frozen and freeze dried cyclopeeze some times.

How often do you clean your glass? About once per week I pass the magnet. About once per month I scrape any extra coralline.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Every 1 - 2 weeks.

Do you dose anything else? Salifert Amino Acids, strontium chloride One drop of lugol solution every day when I remember.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? ARM, but would like to try the Schuran

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? 90% online.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? SSB, but I replace the sand that I can get to 2x a year in small areas at a time.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? No schedule, but I recently got a H&S with two Eheim's, so I figure a periodic vinigar wash will be in the works.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? Primary source is Mrs. Wages picling lime for top off water I mix in 29 gal batches. Also run Ca reactor for some extra bump.

How often do you calibrate your controller/monitor probes? Right now I only monitor the PH in my reactor. Nothing else. So I calibrate whenever there seems to be a problem. Which could be not often enough.
 
How often do you change water and what % of the total system? 25 gallons (about 10%) every 2-3 weeks.

What salt do you use and why? Just switched from IO to Reef Crystals to get more CA

What type of carbon do you use and why? Kent Marine because our LFS carries it. Change monthly.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? RowaPhos about 50% of the time.

How often do you feed and why/what? Twice daily, mix of frozen Mysis, Formula One Angel Food, flake and pellets. Total two frozen cubes plus 2-3 pinches per day.

How often do you clean your glass? Acrylic cleaned every 3-4 days with magnet.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Every 1-2 weeks.

Do you dose anything else? Just started Prodibio

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? ARM

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? 75% online

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? I have a SSB

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? Infrequently unless visible issue.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? GEO CA reactor plus occasional kalkwasser.

How often do you calibrate pH? Recently every couple weeks because my Neptune controller has been going out of calibration.

I think it would be valuable to know to whether people have algae problems and whether their coral growth is slow, medium or fast. With some indication of people's success/problems we might see what is working and what isn't. (i.e., phosphate remover, carbon, frequency of water changes, etc.).

What level of algae growth do you have? Modest growth, no problems.

What level of coral growth do you see? Mine is slow but I am assuming it is because my new tank is young (3 months or so).

-Greg
 
225gl Starphire Inwall:
full20K1.jpg


How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I do a bi-weekly 40g water change (15% of my system).

What salt do you use and why? I use Seachem Reefsalt. I have been using it now for a few months and really like it.

What type of carbon do you use and why? I use Marineland Black Diamond. I change it every 4 weeks.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? I use ROWAphos and change it every 3 months.

How often do you feed and why/what? I feed everyday, sometimes twice a day. I feed Formula One flakes along with Spectrum pellets. I increased my feeding and my coral coloration exploded.

How often do you clean your glass? About twice per week I pass the magnet. I could go longer but I like the tank to look its best.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Every 3 days.

Do you dose anything else? I add 10 drops of Lugols Solution each week.

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? ARM.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Half and half.

If you are barebottom, how often do you vacuum the bottom?
No BB here, wheres the challenge in that. ;)

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? Every 6 months I clean the pumps and skimmer body. Every 2 months I clean my Kalk reactor.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? I use a GEO CA reactor along with a Deltec KM500 Kalk Stirrer.
 
Great idea!!

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? I do a bi-weekly 50g water change (12.5% of my system). Occa
ionally, I'll change more.

What salt do you use and why? I use IO and Reefcrystals. I've used IO since 1998. Dick Perrin at Tropaqarium recommended it and I stuck to it. I'll occasionally use RC's based on availability/price. Can't beat the quality and price. With a large system, my kid could never go to college if I used Tropic Marin

What type of carbon do you use and why? I'm in the school of thought that Carbon is Carbon (as long as it is activated). I slack on my chemical filtration, but change it about 3 months or so.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Haven't jumped on this bandwagon........(yet)

How often do you feed and why/what? I feed every day to every other day, while occasionally feeding every 3 days (rare). I make my own food combining a seafood mix (fresh), formula 2, spirlina, cyclopeeze and nori. When my tangs start to look like the Olsen twins, I increase my feeding.

How often do you clean your glass? When I become obsessive, daily with a magnet. I need a stronger magnet. The stupid magfloat doesn't have a good bond, so it leaves the tougher algae on the glass.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? Every other week. I get more skimmate that way.

Do you dose anything else? I drip kalkwasser about 3 times a week.
u
What type of Ca reactor media do you use? Currently I use Caibsea ARM media in my ATI reactor. I have a bigger reactor comming from Trigger systems and I am going to use the Schuran media.

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Online. LFS are so inflated. I have shopped in Michigan, Ohio, Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania and now Texas, and the DFW area gouges!!

If you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? Every water change

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? I should think about this in more detail. Other than my beckett, I haven't taken any of the pumps or other equipment out.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? I use a Ca reactor that is too small for my tank. I use Kalkwasser as above.
 
Here's the info on my 210.

How often do you change water and what % of the total system? 40G (10% of total) every 2 weeks.

What salt do you use and why? Started with Oceanic 3 years ago, got tired of constantly adding buffer due to low pH. Now using 50/50 Oceanic/IO until I run out of Oceanic, then just straight IO.

What type of carbon do you use and why? ESV, mainly because I could get a big 5 gallon bucket worth. I change 4 cups in my MRC fluidized media chamber once per month.

Do you use a PO4 removing media? Why and how much? No

How often do you feed and why/what? Varies daily: homemade frozen blend I make up every 4-5 months, newly hatched baby brine shrimp, frozen krill, squid, blood worms. I used to feed twice per week but since I got a group of twinspot anthias 2 months ago I went to twice per day. Now I have a slime algae outbreak so I'm cutting back again. Phtyo dosed every 3 days, homegrown zooplankton every 2-3 days.

How often do you clean your glass? Once or twice a week.

How often do you clean the skimmer cup? None since I got a Deltec with self cleaning head a few weeks ago. Prior to that my Euroreef once a week.

Do you dose anything else? No

What type of Ca reactor media do you use? ARM

Do you buy most of your supplies online or locally? Dry goods mostly online, livestock 50/50 LFS/online. No major issues either way so far.

f you are barebottom, how often do you vaccum the bottom? I have SSB which I vacuum with each water change just to keep the detritus from accumulating.

Do you clean your equipment and plumbing? How often? Pumps every 6 months, never on plumbing.

How do you replace Ca/ALK? Nilsen and Ca reactors

How often do you calibrate pH? Every 3 months

What level of algae growth do you have? Went through several cycles since we moved and I had to setup the tank all over again, about a year ago. Green hair to start, followed by red hair algae. Eventually they died out until I started feeding more frequently, now I have slime algae, which hopefully will also run its course.

What level of coral growth do you see? Steady improvement since I finally got Alk over 8 consistently now that I switched from Oceanic.
 
That is awesome guys. If enough replies come in, I will do some number crunching in what % does this or that, but I would like to ahve at least 50+ responses before doing that. I think it will provide a great deal of info for people with larger systems as to what is working very well for others.
 
Bump for a good topic.

I see a few others have posted a pic of their tank. Good idea. This lets us relate your posted methods with some visual evidence of the results of said methods.

If you have a tank pic, please post it. Please do not post a tank pic without filling in Alberto's survey.

Here's mine. I wish my colors where better.
June-06a.jpg




I hope dgasmd does not mind this request. How bout it, dgasmd?
 
Back
Top