I had some errands to run today in the Merriville area so I figured I'd check out both Crystal Clear and Exotic Aquatics......
First I stopped at the "Ark".......... I'd been there before and knew what to expect......... and I wasn't disappointed........ Usual VERY overpriced corals / fish / supplies........ I asked for a price on a small coral not shown on the tank front, and was told that the "saltwater" people didn't come in for another hour........ If this store could get quality help they might actually be someplace I'd make a special trip to, rather than just be someplace I stop in at because I'm in the neighborhood....... Overall, I give it an "A" for "the look", a "B" for the merchandise, and a "D" for the staff.
Crystal Clear was my next stop........... It's small, cramped feeling, with a limited coral / fish selection, but the staff was attentive, and they were willing to discount a few frags when I bought 4......... Nothing special about the place in my eyes, and not worth a "special trip"........... I rate it a "C" for the look, a "C-" for the merchandise, and a "B" for the staff.
Exotic Aquatics was my last stop.......... Very surprising to me that it is strictly saltwater........ NO freshwater at all !!!!! It's run by a father / son team that almost seem to need a vacation from each other. I was there as they were unpacking their shipment from California. While most of the stock looked healthy, and they had some pretty rare and expensive items, many of the tanks were in need of MUCH attention, and the stock seemed to be lacking in the most commmon items of fish, corals and inverts. They had lots of expensive frags that were obviously all from the same original colony and recently cut up........ It kind of hurt thinking they had cut up a nice looking Duncan colony of about 30-35 heads into about 10-12 separate frags. Pricing on many items seemed to be whatever number they pulled out of the air......... But, each of the father / son team seemed knowledgeable, attentive, and willing to help. I rate it a "B-" for "the look", an "A-" for the staff, and as far as the merchandise goes, I guess if you're looking for a $500 pair of wrasses, or a handfull of $100 Acan frags this would be the place for you........ If you're looking for a clean up crew, Xenia, or some peppermint shrimp, (I mean common stock in trade items), you'd probably be better off calling first to check availability.
Of the 3 stops I made, I'd have to put Exotic Aquatics first, The Ark second (only because of the depth of supply inventory, even though they're overpriced) and Crystal Clear 3rd.