cschweitzer,
I agree whole-heartedly, and I am a stickler for the rules, both for myself and everyone on my boat. If anyone needs infromation regarding the state fo Florida rules, here is a good reference...
http://myfwc.com/marine/recreational/recharvestmls.htm
The laws are very liberable in what you can collect, too much so in my opinion. I typically do more looking than collecting, but it's always a fun trip whether you bring something back or not. That's why I started my tank, to recreate a little piece of that environment I see while diving.
I collected that Seargent Major with a hand net. It took me about 45 minute to get that one (at the time) tiny guy out of a school of ~20 in less than 10" of water. That was about the time I gave up on the idea of trying to collect wild fish (that and the blue crab incident).
I do go down to the area quite a bit though, and I have a boat, so I am more than willing to offer a ride to a group that wants to see what they can find on a collecting trip.
For brazengrrl, Seth, and anyone else interested...
I'm really up for any kind of trip. I'm free most weekends, and usually try to get over there at least once a month to run the boat. I have not dove on monster hole, the boat traffic on weekends is usually too crazy for me to feel safe diving that close to the mouth of the inlet.