my new carpet

150W LED SPS tank with Gig does not sound right.
If 120g tank, I would say 150W is definitely not enough light for SPS.

it is definitely enough light, coral growth is better than when I had 250W MH
you can throw the rule of thumb 2-3 watts per gallon when dealing with LEDs

I dont recall asking if I had enough light I recall asking if a low nutrient system would effect the color of the GIG
 
Last edited:
gig is doing well
but is in a sps tank with very low nutrients
color could be better
gig is fed silversides soaked in selcon every 2-3 weeks

would low nutrients cause colors to be a bit dull?

tank is lit with 3 50w LED multichip (epistar 10000K/ actinic mix)

coral growth and color is awesome

thoughts?

You asked for "thoughts." I would think if someone were to make a comment about your lights, then you would consider that a "thought." Would you rather that someone simply reply "No" to answer your question about low nutrients, without much explanation?

I think lighting with nems is more important than nutrient load. The zooxanthellae within the nem can oftentimes determine the color -- or perceived color -- of a nem. Low light = dead zoax = bleached nem. With gigs, they like a lot of light, and those under a lot of light tend to be browner (a majority of the zoox is typically brown in gigs) but the tips of the gig, where the color is, can also be brighter.

What do you mean by the color could be better? Do you mean that it looked better at the store? Did it change color? In terms of overall color, nems can only look "so good" meaning that it will never drastically change color. For example, a typical green haddoni will never turn into a florescent green haddoni.

Typically if your corals are doing well, so should your gig. They can easily survive and are happy in low nutrient tanks, especially if they're fed (though they don't need to be). The main culprit of a color change could definitely be your LEDs. I've witnessed it myself when I switched from halides to LEDs. While my gig was happy, it went from a brown to more of a mauve -- this probably has more to do with how the LED light reflected than a drastic shift, but it did change nonetheless. This also occurs when corals adjust from halides to LEDs -- some colors get better, but others get worse.
 
You asked for "thoughts." I would think if someone were to make a comment about your lights, then you would consider that a "thought." Would you rather that someone simply reply "No" to answer your question about low nutrients, without much explanation?

I think lighting with nems is more important than nutrient load. The zooxanthellae within the nem can oftentimes determine the color -- or perceived color -- of a nem. Low light = dead zoax = bleached nem. With gigs, they like a lot of light, and those under a lot of light tend to be browner (a majority of the zoox is typically brown in gigs) but the tips of the gig, where the color is, can also be brighter.

What do you mean by the color could be better? Do you mean that it looked better at the store? Did it change color? In terms of overall color, nems can only look "so good" meaning that it will never drastically change color. For example, a typical green haddoni will never turn into a florescent green haddoni.

Typically if your corals are doing well, so should your gig. They can easily survive and are happy in low nutrient tanks, especially if they're fed (though they don't need to be). The main culprit of a color change could definitely be your LEDs. I've witnessed it myself when I switched from halides to LEDs. While my gig was happy, it went from a brown to more of a mauve -- this probably has more to do with how the LED light reflected than a drastic shift, but it did change nonetheless. This also occurs when corals adjust from halides to LEDs -- some colors get better, but others get worse.
with respect the poster has 5 posts here and obviously did not read my post. have grown tired of the MH vs LED issues

the color of the nem actually got better in my tank than it was in the store
the body has actually turned more of a mauve color with Blue tips the foot was much bluer/

for the first month or so the nem was in the tank my PO4 was closer to 1-1.5 PPM now depending when I check it hovers between .01-0.0 on hanna meter nitrates are undetectable using a la Motte test kit
 
150W LED SPS tank with Gig does not sound right.
If 120g tank, I would say 150W is definitely not enough light for SPS.

5 months growth under 3 50W multichips
and gig today
 

Attachments

  • gig101413.jpg
    gig101413.jpg
    59.7 KB · Views: 0
Back
Top