Reduck
Because I can....
So to go back a bit, I mentioned that I saw a sharp pH increase last time I changed my filter media but couldn't pinpoint it or explain it. Forgot to mention it, but over the weekend I changed out the bag of BRS Rox carbon again. That's unquestionably what caused the pH swing, as it did it again. This time the only thing I changed out was the carbon. Wore nitrile gloves from the time I pulled the basket out of the tank until I reinserted it. Rinsed a BPA-free plastic bowl out with RODI water to carry the basket in and hold it while I was changing the carbon. Dumped the old carbon in the trash, poured fresh carbon into the same sock, rinsed it under RODI water for ~ 1 minute, placed the bag back in the basket and the basket back in the tank.
This time I followed Bizacon's advice and just waited it out instead of adding vinegar. Within a few hours the pH was back to normal.
Totally baffled on this one. This is my second container of BRS carbon and I definitely didn't see any changes at all with the first container. Haven't changed anything in my replenishment process, and I've narrowed it down to the carbon definitely being responsible for the pH change. Doesn't make any sense though. Since it doesn't seem to be causing any real damage, I think I'll probably use up what I have left. But it doesn't give me a warm fuzzy feeling about that particular brand of carbon... although I have to admit that it's amazingly "clean" with virtually zero dust.
Anybody have another brand they really like? Preferably one that's really clean.
Thats pretty interesting. Its great you found out what caused it.
I am using plain activated carbon. API. (I actually won it in a Facebook contest) I also have a massive 5G bucket of drinking water filter grade carbon that I use in the pond and I steal a cup full from that on occasion. Just rinse well and use..Can't see buying more till that bucket is gone..Its going to be a while too!