Pix & ID: Critters that come in your rocks: the good and the bad.

Is it hard or soft? It might be a calcareous sponge of some type or perhaps the remnants of some type of macro algae. Also, exactly what color is it? It looks bone white, but it's kind of hard to tell with the blues on.
 
I checked on the internet but probably it's not the worm you mentioned. Moreover my tank it's running for last 3 months without any snails or fish, so I doubt this can be Fulgida worm.

Sent from my ASUS_Z00ED using Tapatalk
 
Is it hard or soft? It might be a calcareous sponge of some type or perhaps the remnants of some type of macro algae. Also, exactly what color is it? It looks bone white, but it's kind of hard to tell with the blues on.



Thank you.

It is bone white, moves with flow a bit. I have removed the blues and added another two images, the second is a different one I have noticed?

8b1df70f6608a22689867c0c42c62e12.jpg
5841b3d99385003dc44653055b3f563d.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Thank you.

It is bone white, moves with flow a bit. I have removed the blues and added another two images, the second is a different one I have noticed?

8b1df70f6608a22689867c0c42c62e12.jpg
5841b3d99385003dc44653055b3f563d.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk



I must add that my tank is just clearing after the live sand so there is a bit of silt/sand that has settled on the rocks so it may not naturally be as white as it seems?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
From these last two pictures it just looks like a sponge of some sort. In most cases these are harmless, but keep your eye on them just in case.
 
From these last two pictures it just looks like a sponge of some sort. In most cases these are harmless, but keep your eye on them just in case.



Thank you. Is there anything in particular I should be looking for that should ring alarm bells?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Some sponges have been known to smother corals over time, but being that your tank is new you should be ok for now. When you start adding corals to the tank then you'll need to watch out. One good thing about sponges though is they can be real easy to "thin out" so to say. The ones you have look like they would be real easy to manage.
 
If I'm not mistaken (and for your sake I hope I am) that sounds like a Fulgida worm.

They're meat eating worms that secret a mucous around their prey which seems to paralyze/suffocate them, then eat them.

They look kind of like a bristle worm, but have a flatter/rounded shovel kind of head, and they retract crazy fast for changes in light or if they feel anything bumped/water movement near them.

They tend to only like to come out when it's dark unless they're starving.

If you've noticed some of your CUC shells empty and a snot blob nearby, that's likely your culprit.

I got a rock that had a ton of them and didn't realize. I've been trapping and removing them now for about a month. I think I've removed about 40 so far.

If you need help making a trap let me know, but the design floating around online using PVC pipe, pantyhose and scallops for bait has been the most effective for me.

They will kill your CUC snails and any clams you have in the tank. I have seen them eat a bristle worm or two as well.

edit: also forgot to mention they aren't nearly as sensitive to red light. I ended up buying some red LED flashlights in order to hunt them at night, it made it much easier.
On the second thought, I cannot completely disagree on the identification. Thought the tank has been running without fish for last 2-3 months but do feed my corals occasionally and can see bristleworms thriving.
I'm a bit worried at this point as there are at least 5-6 such worms that I can find with only red lights on and expect a lot more to be hiding. The largest I can see is hardly 2 inch long and around 1mm thick, probably the only way to catch them would be something like a planaria trap that we use in Freshwater tanks.
Here's a recent pic, probably this will help in positive identification.
781ee3aad30208008fd46cbe58875ff2.jpg


Sent from my ASUS_Z00ED using Tapatalk
 
On the second thought, I cannot completely disagree on the identification. Thought the tank has been running without fish for last 2-3 months but do feed my corals occasionally and can see bristleworms thriving.
I'm a bit worried at this point as there are at least 5-6 such worms that I can find with only red lights on and expect a lot more to be hiding. The largest I can see is hardly 2 inch long and around 1mm thick, probably the only way to catch them would be something like a planaria trap that we use in Freshwater tanks.
Here's a recent pic, probably this will help in positive identification.
781ee3aad30208008fd46cbe58875ff2.jpg


Sent from my ASUS_Z00ED using Tapatalk

So i'm not sure what that worm is, but Fulgida worms don't have antenna on their heads.

That looks like a eunice worm (not the bobbit in particular, but likely a predator if it has antenna)

I'd remove that sucker as well. Scallops in a PVC pipe with pantyhose works pretty well for Fulgida worms, might work for other predatory worms as well, but you might need to cycle through bait types until you find what it likes.
 
That's cool, I had no idea there was a 'bristleworm' (this guy) and the 'common bristleworm' (the ones I've seen before)

There are so many critters in this hobby it's mind blowing.

Does your worm eat like this one?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ns0nrU8Y2xg
Thanks for all your input guys, especially alcimedea and ALSimmons.It's a relief that this isn't one of the" not so wanted type of worm".

Sent from my ASUS_Z00ED using Tapatalk
 
These just showed up on the glass the last 2 weeks or so. They are small but spreading relatively quickly. They move, so I thought they might be pods at first, but they only move with the water flow, they are attached. I know the pictures aren't great but it's the best my phone could do.

3.jpg2.jpg1.jpg
 
If that is indeed what they are I wouldn't worry about them too much. (harmless filter feeders) Being that they are on the glass though they should be real easy to remove with a Mag-Float or something similar. Just do this right before your next water change though.
 
Last edited:
unidentified critter

unidentified critter

Just set-up my new tank with live rock and I found this little guy. His he a friendly or should I be concerned. Currently in my second week cycle.

Thanks again for the help!
 

Attachments

  • critter_no1.jpg
    critter_no1.jpg
    75.7 KB · Views: 7
Back
Top