PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not a proponent of any crabs except porcelain crabs; hermits will kill snails for their shells

What are the dangers from the emerald crab? As for the hermits, I placed a bunch of empty shells into the tank in an assortment of sizes and shapes. The hermits seem happy with it as I got to watch one of them change from his old shell to one I had just placed into the tank minutes before.

3 x Blue/Green Reef Chromis (research says these are happier in a group) most of the time a group becomes one as the dominant one kills the remainder over time

So it is alright to just choose one? Will the dominant Chromis of one color/pattern kill a Chromis from another color/pattern group?

Ocellaris Clownfish, Tank Bred (please recommend a soft coral this one would enjoy living in) nondeterministic; they pick what they want to associate with but that may damage the coral

Is there a recommended way to include this fish in the tank? I heard if an anemone dies it can wipe out the entire tank and that a soft coral was the better choice of companion for them. Can these guys be purchased already paired to a soft coral?
 
60 gallon (48 x 15 x 17) mixed reef w/ 40 gallon sump with refugium

2 Ocellaris clowns w/ H magnifica anemone
1 flame angelfish
1 coral beauty angelfish
1 yellow watchman goby w/ pistol shrimp

assorted shrimp etc.

How much "nipping" at SPS is normal from dwarf angels?

They are more dangerous with LPS corals; difficult to predict with SPS corals. However two in your sized tank means there is insufficient natural algae
 
Fish List

Fish List

Please see the fish list below and tell me if there might be any compatability issues. They will be in my 120 Long that is 4 months old. Fish in bold are already present. I have them listed in the order I plan to add them. Thanks for your replies.

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby

1 Yellow Tang
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Kole Tang
 
Please see the fish list below and tell me if there might be any compatability issues. They will be in my 120 Long that is 4 months old. Fish in bold are already present. I have them listed in the order I plan to add them. Thanks for your replies.

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby

1 Yellow Tang must be last fish added
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Kole Tang

fine except as noted
 
Hallo. Starting to plan an aquarium and was hoping for some advice.
Intended tank is a 30 Gallon Deep Blue (24x24x12) with a Model 1 Aqueon ProFlex Sump + 65 Gallon Coralife Super Skimmer

Planned Corals Include
Blue Carpet Anemone (Will be relocated when outgrows DP.)
Purple Cespitularia
Red Sea Pulsing Xenia
Orange Mushroom
Blue Mushroom

Planned Fish Include
2 Ocellaris Clownfish
2 Yellowtail Damsel
1 Blue Damsel

Please help this eager yet overwhelmed hobbyist. :spin3:

From what I have seen of a green carpet ..... I would put larger fish with it that damsel doesn't stand a chance.
 
From what I have seen of a green carpet ..... I would put larger fish with it that damsel doesn't stand a chance.

This thread is only answered by Reef Central Staff. Unlike all other threads on Reef Central, where your participation is encouraged, we would appreciate it if you would refrain from answering in this thread. Your cooperation is greatly appreciated. In any case fish size is irrelevant as carpet anemones can take any size fish.
 
I do not know if this question is "answerable", but if it is, I figure you are the guy to answer it. I also realize it is beyond the usual scope of this thread.

Is there an average time it takes for a fish to feel "at home" in a new tank? In other words, before they start displaying their true behaviors or aggressiveness?

I had asked about adding a flame hawkfish to my 39 gallon bullet-shaped tank, and was worried about it having issues with my yellow watchman goby.

You said you didn't see any problem, and things were wonderful between them. Almost 30 days to the day after introducing them, literally out of nowhere, the hawk suddenly started attacking the YWG, killing it in a matter of minutes before I could do anything to stop it.

I realize every fish has their own behavior above and beyond species generalizations, and certainly knew that was a definite possible outcome, I'm just curious if there is "honeymoon" period of sorts where fish do not feel comfortable enough in a new environment to start sorting out territories or hierarchy levels. Similarly, there are several fish that we always are told to "add last". Does this also play into the equation there?

I greatly appreciate all of your advice, and the service you do for everyone here at Reef Central!
 
I do not know if this question is "answerable", but if it is, I figure you are the guy to answer it. I also realize it is beyond the usual scope of this thread.

Is there an average time it takes for a fish to feel "at home" in a new tank? In other words, before they start displaying their true behaviors or aggressiveness?

I had asked about adding a flame hawkfish to my 39 gallon bullet-shaped tank, and was worried about it having issues with my yellow watchman goby.

You said you didn't see any problem, and things were wonderful between them. Almost 30 days to the day after introducing them, literally out of nowhere, the hawk suddenly started attacking the YWG, killing it in a matter of minutes before I could do anything to stop it.

I am very surprised and very disappointed. These fish do not occupy the same ecological niche and should not interact. The only thing I can think of is that the goby was protecting a pistol shrimp that the hawkfish wanted to eat. I am so very sorry that my advice caused you to lose a fish. :(

I realize every fish has their own behavior above and beyond species generalizations, and certainly knew that was a definite possible outcome, I'm just curious if there is "honeymoon" period of sorts where fish do not feel comfortable enough in a new environment to start sorting out territories or hierarchy levels. Similarly, there are several fish that we always are told to "add last". Does this also play into the equation there?

When I tell someone to add the fish last, I am trying to avoid the fish (e.g. a yellow tang) from establishing itself and claiming territory. The "new kid on the block", for a while at least, will feel insecure.

I greatly appreciate all of your advice, and the service you do for everyone here at Reef Central!

Thank you very much; I try hard to help. Yes, there are "issues" with establishment, ecological niche, and territorial imperative. Some fish take a while to establish (examples would be zebrasoma tangs, large angels) but once established, especially in tanks that are too small (in length not gallonage), are hyper aggressive to conspecifics. Fish that occupy the same ecological niche will not like others in that niche and in a tank that is too small may be aggressive towards them. In a tank that is really too small, they may kill conspecifics. There is also a change in territorial imperative (how much territory they feel is their personal space) as they mature. Sohal tangs, for example, when young, are relatively fine community fish, but once they reach a certain maturity level, feel they need the entire tank, and will kill other fish in their space. By the way, this is NOT a size issue, but a maturity issue. I see so many people who think size is the primary issue with tank size and that is not correct. This thread is about my attempting to predict the 5 year behavior of a group of fish in the tank/environment you are supplying.
 
ote:
Originally Posted by STX Diver
Please see the fish list below and tell me if there might be any compatability issues. They will be in my 120 Long that is 4 months old. Fish in bold are already present. I have them listed in the order I plan to add them. Thanks for your replies.

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby
1 Yellow Tang must be last fish added
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Kole Tang



fine except as noted

Is it okay to reverse the order of the Yellow tang and the Kole tang or should they be the last two fish introduced? Thanks for your help.
 
ote:
Originally Posted by STX Diver
Please see the fish list below and tell me if there might be any compatability issues. They will be in my 120 Long that is 4 months old. Fish in bold are already present. I have them listed in the order I plan to add them. Thanks for your replies.

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby
1 Yellow Tang must be last fish added
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Kole Tang





Is it okay to reverse the order of the Yellow tang and the Kole tang or should they be the last two fish introduced? Thanks for your help.

In a perfect world when both fish are quarantined, they can be added together. But if not together, the yellow must be last.
 
In a perfect world when both fish are quarantined, they can be added together. But if not together, the yellow must be last.

I'm sorry. I meant can I add the fish in this order:

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby
1 Kole Tang
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Yellow Tang
 
I'm sorry. I meant can I add the fish in this order:

1 Green Chromis
1 Yellow Head Goby
1 Kole Tang
2 Ocellaris Clown Fish
1 Orchid Dottyback
1 Royal Gramma
1 Yellow Tang

Yes, but the time between Kole tang and yellow tang must be short or there will be issues.
 
I meant to say specifically for these fish, I know they need to be introduced in that order I just am not sure of these which is most aggressive. I would imagine the angels would need to be last?

Sorry. If you can provide your stocking list again (my memory is not as good as it used to be and I do thousands of these), I will place it in order.
 
60 gallon (48 x 15 x 17) mixed reef w/ 40 gallon sump with refugium

2 Ocellaris clowns w/ H magnifica anemone
2 on the fish, anemone last
1 flame angelfish
3/4
1 coral beauty angelfish 3/4
1 yellow watchman goby w/ pistol shrimp
1

assorted shrimp etc. any time

How much "nipping" at SPS is normal from dwarf angels?
 
90G folwr - 110 lbs of LR and 80 lbs LS - running 13 months -
coral beauty, goby, racooon butterfly, clownfish, Kole Tang -
I'd like to add one more - thinking of a rabbittfish -
thoughts/suggestions ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top