blstravler
Member
You missed my entire point totally.....
My point being the DSB / BB debate got very nasty, as does the live with or without Red Bugs debate every time.
RED BUGS!! kill em or live with em?????
- Thread starter pham411
- Start date
You missed my entire point totally.....
My point being the DSB / BB debate got very nasty, as does the live with or without Red Bugs debate every time.
Stoney Mahony
New member
No, I see your point and no offense but I just don't agree. Im not a "shark", I just find it funny that you guys post in every thread that gets started about RB's, and then announce that everyone will attack you. Are you guys looking for a sympathy vote? If people send you nasty PM's it's pretty easy to forward it to a mod and get it taken care of. Now I don't send nasty PM's, I just read the crap posted and laugh. When I see people post things like wishing they had less PE, or telling people that the reason RB's have a bad effect is b/c there tank conditions are not up to par, it's very easy to see why you guys cause such a controversy. Theres so many threads on RC that get "Nasty" and the reason is b/c people comment w/o any experience or proof, just disbelief. If you guys shot up some detailed pics before and after RB's, and everything looked kosher, I think you would be able to prove your point. With no proof, it's gonna be the same argument everytime. When you read what clkwrk just posted, it looks like he came in here looking to start an argument, and then you guys are complaining about getting attacked! Reminds me alot of that kids book "The boy who cried wolf".
On a side note...good luck w/ your recovery Blues, surgery sucks!
On a side note...good luck w/ your recovery Blues, surgery sucks!
clkwrk
Active member
I never mentioned any names? Are you guilty? If not why respond?If you take my post as a comment trolling for an argument why bother wasting your time to type? I have nothing left to argue go back thru the other rb threads and you will see what I have to say . That is why I have said almost nothing here. All of my post are not speculation they are my experience.Also they are not my 1-3 month experiences either . I have more experience than you assume.
IMHO its not 100% kosher that we dump interceptor in our tank. We wouldn't go dumping interceptor in the ocean to kill the red bugs in the ocean.
IMHO its not 100% kosher that we dump interceptor in our tank. We wouldn't go dumping interceptor in the ocean to kill the red bugs in the ocean.
jay24k
Active member
That is true but the ocean has it's natual predators that keep this in check. Our tanks do not have the diversity of the ocean, thus other measures. Beside the genocide of little guy in our tank, I think it is necessary personally. Yes some can live with them but like I said before, there is something in your tank keeping them in check. Otherwise they would be covering your corals.
It's your decision to live or kill them but it seems like a few are saying that there are no issues and it isn't a big deal. IMO, I think it is wrong to tell someone that.
Fine if you want to tell them, YOU have no issues, but I wouldn't convince them to keep them unless they want to.
People on this board LOVE to argue lol.
It's your decision to live or kill them but it seems like a few are saying that there are no issues and it isn't a big deal. IMO, I think it is wrong to tell someone that.
Fine if you want to tell them, YOU have no issues, but I wouldn't convince them to keep them unless they want to.
People on this board LOVE to argue lol.
Mike O'Brien
New member
That's my opinion too. I think there are also alot more people living with them than people think. And most of them seem to be the veteran's with the most experience. I've personally heard from someone you'd all listen to that dosing the tank is not really a good idea. And no, I won't say who. But most of these people worry about flatworm's, not red bug's. The bug's won't nuke you're tank, the only like a few species od acropora and they are easily treated outside the tank if need be.
Just my opinion
poknsnok
New member
its not 100% kosher to treat with interceptor.. it kills useful crustaceans. that said i would treat again if i had to. my corals have greatly improved since i killed the little bastards.Most reefers agree that this is true. Corals are better off without red bugs on them. Flat worms are by far worse than red bugs obviously. FW can decimate your acros. red bugs wont. IMO this is a dead horse discussion. you either treat or dont treat. agree or disagree.
blstravler
Member
I don't understand you, you start by some what questioning my or clkwrk's experience and ask us to post pics, when you and I both know clkwrk and I have have posted many pictures of our tanks with bugs.
Then you say go in the opposite direction and say something nice....
And I do think you meant it in a nice way, I don't think anyone would make light of of a person having an organ removed. I'm lucky, over 600 internal stitches and 45 staples in my chest and I'm still alive and kickin' all be it slowly.
Then you say go in the opposite direction and say something nice....
And I do think you meant it in a nice way, I don't think anyone would make light of of a person having an organ removed. I'm lucky, over 600 internal stitches and 45 staples in my chest and I'm still alive and kickin' all be it slowly.
Stoney Mahony
New member
No, I am not. I was actually using you as an example, not responding to your troll ( Yes, thats exactly what it was). It's also a bit hypocritical to accuse me of that when you have been a "shark" in many of my recent postings. I have read every RB thread on here so I have heard what you have to say. I think you do have experience but you are in denial and don't want to post the facts. IMO it is irrisponsible to say that they have no negative effects on SPS. No one is debating whether or not SPS can still live and grow with them....we all know they can.
I agree that we wouldnt go dumping interceptor in the ocean to get rid of RB's but that is such a bad analogy. We also dont spray all the forests for thirps, aphids, leafminers and harmful insects although in a greenhouse or any closed facility you would. Our corals are in closed systems with specific animals, and a controlled environment. The ocean is EXACTLY the opposite. As Jay24 said, the ocean has natural predators and the biodiversity that creates a balanced ecosystem. It's like comparing apples and sausages.
Last edited:
Stoney Mahony
New member
Yes Blues, I know you guys have posted pics but there far away and blurry. No one is questioning wether or not your corals will live and grow. Many corals are unaffected color wise so that doesnt tell us anything to see a pic of your whole tank with a bunch of corals. If you want to make a statement against what is known to be fact by the vast majority, you should be able to prove it. You can't just expect people to believe it b/c you have a million posts or your profile says youve been reefing for 20 yrs (not you, just an example).
As for the comment...yeah, that was Stoney code for I hope you die? Cumon give me a break! When your feeling defensive I guess it's easy to take everything as an attack. No one is attacking you in this thread, just debating the facts. I actually remembered you posting up that you were having major surgery and that you would be out of commision for a while. You said that this was another reason that you were not treating for RB...b/c you couldn't lift all the water for changes. I thought that it was one of the few good reasons anyone would have not to treat for them. I have actually had major surgery in the past and been out for months and like I said, it sucks. Thats it, your off my prayer list....:lolspin:
Last edited:
MammothReefer
Active member
I've seen tanks with redbugs do fine..and I've had stuff go bad that I blamed on red bugs but can't prove as it could have been the combination of red bugs & paremeters.. Me personally now.. I would prefer to treat for red bugs just so I know i'm not spreading them if and when I trade.
blstravler
Member
Stoney- What I was tryign to say to you is that you seem like a nice person when you say things like that but then you go off like some is throwing rocks at your tank. I just want to speak on a subject that I have had experience with and if you want to have a reasonable talk about it that is fine. This board is about learning from others experiences, I'm going back to that now.
Not really a prayer person myself, though after coming close to getting to see the "man up above" my mother is slowly swaying my mind....
clkwrk
Active member
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8344285#post8344285 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by poknsnok
I agree it has been the same for me and I know the sharks have been waiting for me to join this one (clkwrk)
your gonna need a bigger boat
Na I just stick to my guns .....Just like I did when people were giving me hell about turnover rates above 50. I got lots of great comments when I broke 100x now lots of people are doing it . I also stuck my guns when everyone was tring to find a cure that worked on flatworms. I tried and reported on TMPCC before it ever got that short acronym. I said nothing to you so why quote me? You and everyone eles who has been in these rb threads knows we disagree.
just did my treatment. it worked great!! im bug free!!
bonus: my shrimps, acro crabs are all still alive. my 100g total water system only needed 1/2 a pill of the 25-50lb interceptor pill.
they literally hang on to the 6th hour and then fall off.
2 more treatments... how many days apart should i do this?
bonus: my shrimps, acro crabs are all still alive. my 100g total water system only needed 1/2 a pill of the 25-50lb interceptor pill.
they literally hang on to the 6th hour and then fall off.
2 more treatments... how many days apart should i do this?
Zoom
Premium Member
It will not work !! I know i treat my tank five times they way you did . Yes the will fall off and die and about three weeks to a month they will be back . You need half a pill of the large dog interceptor for 100 Gallons . A good indication that the treatment was not strong enough is that your Acro crabs still alive.
poknsnok
New member
i did a full pill on a 240 system and left it in for 24 hours. this was more than 3 months ago and Im still as far as I can see, red bug free and the improvement has been drastic. I read several comments about the 24hr treatment one time being more effective than the 3x6 hr treatment. so far so good..
