Following on from many responses regarding my Sola Tubes & skylight and after listening to Marc and Evan on their latest Reefcast, I thought I'd do a little update.
Natural light - 3 years on
Well it's been 3 years now since I installed my skylight and Sola Tubes!! Doesn't time fly!!
My thought was that the extra natural light would be supplemental to my Mh's and T5's and wouldn't replace them. During winter, for example, we don't get a lot of sunshine and at night artificial light is still required to enjoy the tank.
Living in a high bush fire danger area I didn't want to use the plastic Sola Tube domes, so instead I used a standard flat skylight with a sheet of 1/2" clear laminated glass for strength.
Fortunately my roof faces north so the skylight picks up maximum sun. (Southern Hemisphere remember) After discussions with Sola Tube it was decided that considering the pitch and orientation of my roof, I would get very similar levels of light through my configuration as I would through their domes. You can see in this pic that I have cut the tubes at the same angle as the skylight.
FAQ
Q1 "Has there been any additional heat brought in from the Solatubes?"
A1 The amount of heat coming down the tubes is about equivalent to what you'd feel if you went outside and put your hand out and felt the sun on it. Negligible really, compared to the heat from a Mh.
Q2 "Could I substitute the standard tubes with polished aluminium?"
A2 The idea of using polished aluminium has arisen before. (After all that's what the Solatubes are) I considered doing it to the point of looking at types of aluminium. I think it could be done, but you'd have to polish it with car polish and then seal the surface with a clear finish so it didn't tarnish again. I'm not sure how you'd go then rolling it up. Also how reflective would it be?
Q3 "Could I use flexible ducting -- highly reflective foil wrapped over a wire coil -- much like ventilation duct. The amount of light that it transfers is quite impressive, but I don't know how it compares with Solatubes"
A3 The flexible ducting simply doesn't compare with the Solatube style rigid tubes. When you look at it all those creases and bends reflect light in all directions, even back up the duct! I'm no expert but I have been told that the flexible ducting reflects about 50% where the Solatubes reflect 98%.
Even bends in the rigid tubes lose some light!
Q4 "Are you able to switch off your Metal Halides during summer?"
A4 Yes.
Q5 "Isn't the light really yellow?"
A5 I think you'd be surprised at the colour of the natural light. It's not yellow as most people think it would be. I'd rate it in appearance to a 10000k Mh bulb.
Q6 "Doesn't sunlight cause algal blooms?"
A6 From what I've read algae need two things to grow. Light and nutrient. If you take away one it simply can't grow. If your water quality is exceptional (As in near zero nutrient) there shouldn't be a problem.
If you check Calfo's book "Book of Coral Propagation" he has coral in glass houses and discusses this issue at length.
Photo of my old system. 2001 - 2008 - TOTM March 2007 RTAW, TOTM Turkey, TOTY 2007 RTAW
Photos of my new system 2008 - Today - TOTM July 2009 RTAW
FTS with just sunlight; (The shafts of light traverse across the tank as the sun moves across the sky) Jan 2009
Sunlight and T5's. Jan 2009
Sunlight, T5's and Mh's. Jan 2009
Latest FTS
I love the natural light!!
Rod. :thumbsup: