Sea cuccumber info, please!

Sports Girl

In Memoriam
I am interested in a sea cucumber to help clean and aerate my sand bed (60 gallon reef tank). A clerk at a LFS told me that if they "regurgitate their intestines" the toxins produced could kill all fish in my tank. Every website that sells marine livestock (liveaquaria.com, etc) says that they may produce a toxin that may "injure fish." Can someone give me a straight answer? I don't want to crash my tank just to get my sand a little cleaner. Also, does anyone have any experience with another creature that does the same job? I currently have a sandsifting star, a bunch of aestra (sp?), mexican turbo, and cat eye snails, and hermit crabs. Thank you!
 
Common concern that is true to an extent but overblown. I just posted a link on a separate thread :

here

Read the advanced aquarist article on "cuke nukes" I embedded in the link above. It's long but addresses your concern.

Generally speaking the drab sand-eating cukes are nothing to worry about. Just realize that cukes have no desire to "nuke" unless they think they are going to be eaten or are threatened in some way.
 
Hmm - was preoccupied with the intestines question I neglected the second part of your question.

If I may, I will break it down into two components:

1) What else helps aerate the sandbed

and

2) Does your existing crew help or not?

1 - I'm not familiar with cat eye snails, but two types of snails that are used to help aerate the sand bed are nassarius and cerith. Both burrow into the sand when not out and about. Ceriths will eat algae while nassarius like meaty leftovers (so don't get them if you expect algae duty). In addition these snails are commonly mistaken with another similar invert that is - Illynassa obsoleta. Check out this article by Dr. Ron on Nassarius Snails: snails

Alternatively one could look into investigating whether a fighting conch might help your sand bed. Incredibly interesting invert if you ask me. However - I believe conchs can outgrow a tank so do some investigating before buying.

So three possible inverts to consider - cerith snails, nassarius snails or a fighting conch.

2 - The sandsifting star is one that Dr. Ron feels is detrimental if trying to maintain a deep sand bed. So fyi. If however your bed is for aesthetics then no worries. The star sifts thru the bed looking for critters to eat - the very critters that likely help keep your sandbed clean.

Finally one last option that occurred to me just now is introducing more bristleworms - which nasty as they may appear do help with detris eating.

Good luck!
 
A fighting conch would also be an excellent addition to your sand bed crew. The hermit crabs and sand sifting star are not necessarily good for your sand bed. The problem is that they tend to eat the sand bed infauna which help to keep the upper layers of the sand bed loose and aerated.
 
Thanks to David and especially Phil, the article was extremely insightful and helpful, exactly what I was looking for. Thanks again!
 
Back
Top