Keep it! Maybe put him in his own tank and try to offer him chunks of meat? He's really cool, and it would be a shame to kill something that awesome. Or, if you don't want to keep it, see if anyone on here wants it.
I bet you can lure him out. Put a snail just out of reach. Don't just grab and yank, though, he might break off. Wait for him to get out as far as you can and then try to scoop him out.