Skeptics, here's the proof that LED grows colorful SPS's

Acrotrdco

New member
Since a picture speaks a thousand words, so I'm gonna let the pictures do all the speaking.

Here we go:
A.Nana Frag:
21.6.2010
DSC_0395.JPG


5.7.2010
DSC_0550.JPG


13.8.2010
DSC_0382.JPG


14.9.2010
DSC_0785.JPG


29.10.2010
DSC_1139.JPG


17.1.2011
DSC_3053.JPG


29.1.2011
DSC_3384.JPG


1.2.2011
DSC_3569.JPG


14.3.2011
DSC_4401.jpg


DSC_4501.jpg
 
Bird's Nest:
30.9.2010
DSC_0860.JPG

21.10.2010
DSC_0939.JPG

17.1.2011
DSC_3062.JPG

29.1.2011
DSC_3441.JPG

14.3.2011
DSC_4510.jpg



Pink Cat's Paw:
10.11.2010
DSC_1652.JPG

17.1.2010
DSC_3081.JPG

DSC_3080.JPG

29.1.2011
DSC_3325.JPG

14.3.2011
DSC_4588.jpg
 
Last edited:
Good to see all your growth pics in one page. I've been growing SPS under my AI Sol Blue modules for a month now. Maybe in 3-4 months ill post my progress as well :)
 
Yep, LEDs work well. I stuck a bunch of brown acro frags under LEDs and already half of them are colouring up. Different colours too. A nice green tip with orange polyps, and a purple tip with green polyps, just for starters :)
 
and the million dollars question:

what kind of leds are you using?

A combination of different brands (Cree and Semi LED) and colors:
post-2746-1285175448_thumb.jpg

p.s. there's a typo in this sheet, it's 405nm violet not 503nm, 503 is cyan.

For more info you can always take a look at my tank thread:
http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1929512

Yep, LEDs work well. I stuck a bunch of brown acro frags under LEDs and already half of them are colouring up. Different colours too. A nice green tip with orange polyps, and a purple tip with green polyps, just for starters :)

Exactly, I've got this brown piece of efflo frag from LFS some 3 weeks ago:

23.2.2011
DSC_4310.jpg


Right now it looks like this - it's shown some improvement on coloration, hopefully in another few months time it'll turn into a real beauty! :)

14.3.2011
DSC_4405.JPG

DSC_4576.jpg
 
nice shots Acrotrdco !
same experience here with 3 months of leds (reefrepublic )

all my corals have colored-up and growth is great

avalida3.jpg


tenuis encrusting and started to grow for about a month....
Image1-1.jpg
 
Very nice!! I have a T5 & LED combo now and will eventually be going all LED....prob later this year. Glad to see successes hear! I will check out the OP's build thread when comes time to transition to full LED.

----------
 
very nice, I'm hoping if I luck out the maxspect g3 will be out when it's time to replace my current halide/t5 bulbs. Only bummer is I won't be able to get away with one fixture on my tank as it's 36x24x18
 
A combination of different brands (Cree and Semi LED) and colors:
post-2746-1285175448_thumb.jpg

p.s. there's a typo in this sheet, it's 405nm violet not 503nm, 503 is cyan.

For more info you can always take a look at my tank thread:
http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1929512



Exactly, I've got this brown piece of efflo frag from LFS some 3 weeks ago:

23.2.2011
DSC_4310.jpg


Right now it looks like this - it's shown some improvement on coloration, hopefully in another few months time it'll turn into a real beauty! :)

14.3.2011
DSC_4405.JPG

DSC_4576.jpg

Beautiful shots! Very encouraging for keeping sps under LEDs.
I understand you use a small glass aquarium to take the top view shot. Were you using free-hand and no stand to do that top view shot? Did you turn off any pumps at all?
By the way, the tutorial of taking tank photo you gave me a while ago, did help me a lot. I am still trying hard, thanks:dance:
Two of your shots were taken at almost the same time -- the snail still there.
 
skepticism-ignorance- who knows but LEDS are here to stay.

nice work and most important great husbandry
 
Beautiful shots! Very encouraging for keeping sps under LEDs.
I understand you use a small glass aquarium to take the top view shot. Were you using free-hand and no stand to do that top view shot? Did you turn off any pumps at all?
By the way, the tutorial of taking tank photo you gave me a while ago, did help me a lot. I am still trying hard, thanks:dance:
Two of your shots were taken at almost the same time -- the snail still there.

Thanks - I use my left hand to hold the aquarium in place and take the photo with my other hand. That's why I needed to use auto-focus and VR, it's pretty "challenging" to say the least. :cool:

And yeah I took the bottom 2 shots almost the same time, the snail was still munching algae around and I didn't want to bother it :)

skepticism-ignorance- who knows but LEDS are here to stay.

nice work and most important great husbandry

Thanks!

Nice pics. Got a question...do you target feed your sps corals? if so what do you use?

Since I'm using NPBP, I've noticed that the PE of all my SPS's are very noticable almost 24 hours a day so I'm pretty sure they're getting a constant stream of bacterias to feed on, therefore I only feed them with Reefpearls about once a day.

In fact, one piece of my leather coral, which was nothing but a small piece of tissue left behind under a liverock when I frag a larger piece, now grow to the size of a dime, it's got absolutely ZERO light because it's growing under a live rock, but it's still growing steadily so I'm sure it's got something to eat, most likely the bacteria in the water column.
 
Thanks for sharing your experience. I'm considering buying some reef brites for my new tank....
 
If I may... I'm am seriously thinking about switching to LED's. I don't know much about them (just what I've read in various posts). I read it everywhere and there's no doubt that LED's have been proven to grow SPS. My question would be: I know the actual LED will last a long time illuminating the tank but realistically, how long will they effectively grow SPS before the color shifts? What are the claims so far? A couple years? A couple decades?

And when the LED's are determined to have a better effect growing algae than growing coral, how do you replace the fixtures?

Thanks
 
If I may... I'm am seriously thinking about switching to LED's. I don't know much about them (just what I've read in various posts). I read it everywhere and there's no doubt that LED's have been proven to grow SPS. My question would be: I know the actual LED will last a long time illuminating the tank but realistically, how long will they effectively grow SPS before the color shifts? What are the claims so far? A couple years? A couple decades?

And when the LED's are determined to have a better effect growing algae than growing coral, how do you replace the fixtures?

Thanks

I don't know the answer to all your questions but I do know that it costs $200/module for the AI units if you ever need to replace ALL of the LEDs them.

I know maxspect sp? users have the ability to replace individual LEDs. CREEs being 10 each and semi's being 5 each.

Hopefully they last at least 3-4 years and someones whos owned them for 3-4 years now can chime in.

CREE states that we'd have up to 50,000 hours of usable light. Do LEDs shift in color after awhile? I really don't know. To be safe I cut the amount of hours of usable light in half. assuming everyone uses a 10 hour photoperiod for 365 days a year, math comes out to be 6.8 years.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top