The best skimmer for performance / cost

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deep Reef
  • Start date Start date
If you are at all handy Avast Marine sells a DIY smoked acrylic recirculating skimmer kit.
You asked about best bang for the buck and I think this is it!
Uses a Sicce PSK1000
Well under your budget too.... including the not shown Swabbie Kit for "Swabbing the poop neck...ARRR!"
Sexy smoked acrylic....mmmmm
LG-cs1_blackpearl_lg_kit.jpg

I found it very easy to put together.
http://www.avastmarine.com/ssc/do/product/youbuilt/CS1-Cone-Skimmer-Kit
 
Last edited:
I went from an RO NWT-150 like you had to the Avast CS1 listed above. I like the smoked acrylic because the light from the refugium doesn't grow coralline algae inside the skimmer body. I think the whole package for the DIY kits ran about $400 including the pump and the Swabbie and it has worked great so far. JMO.
 
I'll just add that I would never run a non recirculating skimmer ever again just because I never have to worry about finiky water level in the sump. I skim during water changes and pretty much all the time even when the return is off for feeding + maintenance.
 
Only as noisey as the pump you choose , mine is completely silent

Agreed! My Lifreef has been running the Mag 9.5 for almost 4 years now and even for a mag pump it's really quiet. But then again I'm used to the a macaw squacking at me while I'm messing with my tank. And Jeff at Lifereef is super helpful as well.
 
Thanks all for your input and help. Alot of great suggestions here. I'm leaning towards the lifereef skimmer. My only issueis that I can only fit the 24" model and I hear you want the 30".
 
Thanks all for your input and help. Alot of great suggestions here. I'm leaning towards the lifereef skimmer. My only issueis that I can only fit the 24" model and I hear you want the 30".

I'm running the 30" on my 200g tank with another 150g in sump, frag tank, mangrove tank and refugium. I'm pushing it, but 24" should be enough for your tank.
 
It's killing me cause I have 29" clear below my tank. Just a little short. I emailed Jeff and we'll talk further as I get closer to pulling the trigger beginning oh july
 
Well if you are looking at Lifreef you may as well take a look at Aqua C EV-120 or EV-180 the 120 uses a Mag 5 and 180 uses Mag 7. I just picked up the EV-120 for my 100 gal. and it has not been 24 hrs. yet and its putting big globs dry foam into the cup. I am impressed so far with this unit, I thought I would try some old school. I have a Beckett skimmer but I don't want to get a pump to run it as you need a Mag 18 min. to get it to work right which I believe is like 145 watts. I remember when the EV line came out and wanted to get one but never did. Now I have one and I think I am going to like this one, pump is 45 watts at .8 amps I can live with that and the foam its pumping into the cup is better then any of the 6 NW skimmers and 4 different brands I own. The one thing I noticed after it was running for a few hours was the Tank looked cleaner, the water just looked clearer. I thought to my self its just me but after looking at some reviews they where saying the same thing.

Anyhow just something to think about or just another option to frustrate you.
Good luck on your choice.

Skim
 
Yeah if I had seen that diy kit when I first started I would have bought it.
 
Well if you are looking at Lifreef you may as well take a look at Aqua C EV-120 or EV-180 the 120 uses a Mag 5 and 180 uses Mag 7. I just picked up the EV-120 for my 100 gal. and it has not been 24 hrs. yet and its putting big globs dry foam into the cup. I am impressed so far with this unit, I thought I would try some old school. I have a Beckett skimmer but I don't want to get a pump to run it as you need a Mag 18 min. to get it to work right which I believe is like 145 watts. I remember when the EV line came out and wanted to get one but never did. Now I have one and I think I am going to like this one, pump is 45 watts at .8 amps I can live with that and the foam its pumping into the cup is better then any of the 6 NW skimmers and 4 different brands I own. The one thing I noticed after it was running for a few hours was the Tank looked cleaner, the water just looked clearer. I thought to my self its just me but after looking at some reviews they where saying the same thing.

Anyhow just something to think about or just another option to frustrate you.
Good luck on your choice.

Skim
I looked at the Aqua C I liked the idea. However, they recommend having a filter on the pump inlet in order to keep the nozzles clean. I have had issues with my reactor filters clogging with algae or 2Part so I think I'll pass on the EV as I want minimal maintenance.
 
LIFE REEF or go back again later.

LIFE REEF or go back again later.

My 2 cents
Yes to LIFE REEF flat out love mine! heavy duty, simple, works, stable running. I went with the svs24 and mazzi injector mag 9.5 on mine. sort of loud, runs on a mag 9 what do you expect. "Water Blaster will be my next pump I put on it when the mag dies to fix that" still quieter than the chiller which goes back to the MAG 9 pump again.

No to Reef octopus RO-ps-1000int works great for me as well. But its very fussy about water level. Has to be the right depth and stay there all the time or it will flood the cup.

NO to SWC 300A little funky on the pump and materials they make it out of "delicate" but cheap and works well for the cost. HUGE for 600$ but I would have made a better life reef investment had i had a choice as it Came with a tank tear down buy.
No to aqua C EV-120. They had good Customer service.. I never got there skimmer to work for me. but they were built heavy duty. Too fussy

Most skimmers are fussy about stability of water level out side the unit and inside the unit. if you understand how they work and why they are doing what they are doing you can adjust most any skimmer to work great.

In closing I'd always buy a Life Reef. I prefer the internal model you can break down. the flange model, and bigger is better. All my other skimmers are garage buys and tank tear down saves. The life reef is on my mixed 100 gal SPS tank that i care about the most because I trust it. You don't need anything cool looking to skim good. Put your money where the performance is not the frills!

curent tanks are
Main display is 100 gal sps tank Bare bottom, auto water change, KALK top off, dosed, Fuge, Reef bright led n t5 combo with attached 20 g frag system. 50 gallon quarantine set up. Loaded 30gal Red sea LPS tank REEF bright led n t5 combo.
100 gal FW tank custom filtration.
NEW Growing 400 gallon mixed reef t5 led BB.
 
On our second DC Reef Octopus Skimmer (my fault).

Both have been great. Very quiet and do their job.

Fixed the DCS300 and it's running on our frag tank now... looks to be running well.

Coralvue also got us a new pump extremely fast for the broken one.
 
ended up with the Lifereef. it took a couple of days to really get going but now it's really rocking. you guys steered me in the right direction. Thanks for the help.
 
I looked at those but the failure rate of the early wave line pumps was about 2/3rds. I had the clone of that same pump in my last diablo and it also failed.

Supposedly they are better now but it sort of soured me on them. I have the new version of the Reef octopus pump on my cone elite 150 DCS in my 90g and its too soon to tell if the investment was worth it.

I'm currently back to wanting to stick with a product where replacement pumps are not super crazy expensive assuming I might have to replace them every 8 months or so....ha ha ha....

Hopefully that wont be the case with the new RLS you have.
 
I went to their site. I read your post with others from their link on their site. I am very interested. How noisy is it?
The pump you use is the only noise, I am using external 36 with a blueline 40hd in my living room and I don't stink it's loud at all, is the most hand off skimmer I have used.
 
Back
Top