Yet another ID thread

yardboy

Advanced Bewilderment
I traded for this today Thought it might be a mini-maxi of a cool color, but not sure since the guy I traded with said it was something else. Any clue?
It's about the size of a 50 cent coin.

IMG_5973adjwithcanon.jpg
 
It looks like you're correct. I'd give it a little time to relax and spread out before declaring a positive ID though. My money is definitely on tapetum though.
 
If the underside/foot has orange dots and slashes then it is a mini-maxi or maxi-mini (S. tapetum). If there are no markings, it could be a small S. haddoni, but it is hard to tell at this point.
 
If the underside/foot has orange dots and slashes then it is a mini-maxi or maxi-mini (S. tapetum). If there are no markings, it could be a small S. haddoni, but it is hard to tell at this point.

I will have to sneak a peek under it's skirt to see. :D
The guy I traded it for said it was an S. haddoni, but I've never seen one so small, though they must exist.
I wish the rock was flatter. It might be easier to look.

Seems like I remember a discussion about the mini-maxi anemone being a different species, but undefined. Anyone have a followup on if anything has been decided?
 
Last edited:
My moneys on baby Haddoni.

look whats turned up in one of are LFS in the
UK.

31052012192923sof_95.JPG


31052012192923sof_50.JPG


3 baby red haddoni;):D

There only around 1.5" across:crazy1:
 
3 baby red haddoni

I doubt it. Haddonis do not asexually reproduce. Finding two babies together (or three, take your pick) that display exactly the same rare morphology would be extremely unlikely. S. tapetum, however, is known to asexually reproduce and form colonies of several clones.
 
Last edited:
Additionally, and I'm surprised no one pointed this out, haddonis are sand anemones. I have never seen one (of any size/age) that would stay on a rock when a sand bed was present.

I don't think any of these anemones are haddonis, personally. They just don't look like it to me. But who knows? Maybe I'm wrong?
 
Additionally, and I'm surprised no one pointed this out, haddonis are sand anemones. I have never seen one (of any size/age) that would stay on a rock when a sand bed was present.

I don't think any of these anemones are haddonis, personally. They just don't look like it to me. But who knows? Maybe I'm wrong?

I do agree that they are sand dwellers, however I have notice that many small haddoni tend to prefer rockwork. Certainly true in the case of the two smallones (4") I've had in the past. Both found the rockwork and disappeared never to be seen again:hmm6:
Perhaps they need to anchor their foot and if the sand is to deep they move to the rockwork. Would make sense for small anemones to attach to something thats not going to be easily disturbed.
 
I do agree that they are sand dwellers, however I have notice that many small haddoni tend to prefer rockwork. Certainly true in the case of the two smallones (4") I've had in the past. Both found the rockwork and disappeared never to be seen again:hmm6:
Perhaps they need to anchor their foot and if the sand is to deep they move to the rockwork. Would make sense for small anemones to attach to something thats not going to be easily disturbed.

Not trying to be rude, but if they disappeared and never came out, wouldn't that tend to suggest they were doing something unhealthy, or abnormal?

I believe that almost all sand dwellers will need something to attach to under the sand, but given the option, even the babies will attach to something as far down as they can reach. The point of this is that, when in danger, they can quickly withdraw underneath the sand.
 
I'm 99.9% certain they're not baby haddoni. I bought one from my LFS and they had SIX in stock. As bonsainut has pointed out, to find one would be a lucky baby haddoni find. But to find six + of the same colour morph (presumably in the same relative location) I would imagine is just about impossible. Despite regular feeding mine hasn't really grown much, if at all, either. Still nice though !
 
Despite regular feeding mine hasn't really grown much, if at all, either. Still nice though !

If these reproduce asexually, I would actually prefer to have these than baby haddonis. I think they look cool, and haddonis just get too big for me. Plus, you don't even want to KNOW how many fish I've lost to haddonis over the years... :(
 
I'm 99.9% certain they're not baby haddoni. I bought one from my LFS and they had SIX in stock. As bonsainut has pointed out, to find one would be a lucky baby haddoni find. But to find six + of the same colour morph (presumably in the same relative location) I would imagine is just about impossible. Despite regular feeding mine hasn't really grown much, if at all, either. Still nice though !

How much did you pay for them?
 
Back
Top