Any “Top of the line" GAC and GFO free SPS tank?

I think perhaps the biggest problem with gfo is that people have used it incorrectly. If you are using gfo and don't change it out and your levels rise then all of a sudden you chuck a new load in it will strip the phosphate very very fast which will definitely cause stn or rtn in my past experience.

I use gfo and gac. I don't see any negative effect from either tbh. I have found that by not stressing about zero coming from the reactor that the media lasts a lot longer and maintains low levels which are essential. Straight zero is not good.

I used to keep sps around ten years ago and did alright, I certainly didn't have a system like I do now and I certainly wasn't as anal with it. I have forgotton a lot as well. I do remember having problems with stn and rtn though, some of which was down to poor gfo use.

I am going to run a small experiment with gfo, I have a large algae bed and on this next due change of gfo I'll see where levels go, I would love to eliminate it, for cost more than anything.

I found that by running the gfo with zero coming out the reactor I was having to change it every 2-3 weeks and the algae bed wasn't growing at all, now I've sped the flow up through the reactor the algae is growing well

My tank does seem to lose some colour when gfo needs changing. I will say that. I'll also say at the moment my colour could be a lot better. My system runs zero or unmeasurable nitrate and very low phos. I recently changed to a ati hybrid and have been very careful with the light as I know how powerful it is. I believe I need to up the led, every time I do it seems a bit better. Low nutrients high light, higher nutrients lower light.
Even though the nutrient levels are low I've seen some acros brown off a bit since the lighting, this makes me believe more light is needed (btw I've had led set around 30-40% I'm now at 50 and adding a couple of percent every couple of days.
 
I have tried GFO a few times and got dead clams and STN for it. For some reason my tank is very sensitive to excess iron levels and GFO is a no-go for me. I have not had issues with keeping phosphates low even without it, I have used various carbon dosing systems with varying degrees of success but I have been very stable now for the better part of a year with NP biopellets and now All-in-one biopellets. If the all-in-one pellets contain some sort of GFO it gets skimmed out immediately.

GFO can easily be overdosed, and other than the "Too low nutrient" issues others have spoke about here, too much Iron can trigger STN in a carbon dosed tank in my experience.

My tank - All in one biopellets and a big skimmer only:
picture.php

I just wanted to say your tank is amazing
 
Lets keep this thread going. I'm interested to see more non gfo tanks too. I've had stn from the base up with sps when I was running gfo but with this current tank I'm not running it and have pretty good success so far. Can't say that it's a direct correlation but it's what is working for me.

Question for those who aren't running gfo. How are you keeping your po4 down? My tank is at .11. My colors are pretty good but I want to bring that number down but just a little hesitant on putting the gfo back online as I want to leave well enough alone. Thanks
 
Chaeto and caulerpa refugium. Skimming. Shallow sandbed with tons of flow. Regularly agitated sand. Usually reads between 0-6 PPB on the ultra low range phosphorous meter. Test one or twice a month
 
Has anyone used those phosphate removal drops? I've seen my lfs use them but a bit skeptical of it as it is too easy
 
Has anyone used those phosphate removal drops? I've seen my lfs use them but a bit skeptical of it as it is too easy

While I've never had any experience with any of the liquid removal methods, my main concern would be stripping the tank too quick or completely stripping it and causing rtn.

I do know Lanthanum Chloride will work and it's used in public aquariums around the world but were talking about multi thousand gallon systems here not your typical reef tank.

The only time I've ever had a bad phosphate battle was when I cooked some old rock that continued to leech PO4 even after an acid bath and bleaching. I eventually just got rid of the rock and started fresh with new live rock and never looked back.

I agree with the others that most of the time GFO is used inappropriately and a lot of time is the cause of other issues.

i can't say my system is carbon free because I do run a very small amount in a bag for a couple days every other month or so.
 
I have tried GFO a few times and got dead clams and STN for it. For some reason my tank is very sensitive to excess iron levels and GFO is a no-go for me. I have not had issues with keeping phosphates low even without it, I have used various carbon dosing systems with varying degrees of success but I have been very stable now for the better part of a year with NP biopellets and now All-in-one biopellets. If the all-in-one pellets contain some sort of GFO it gets skimmed out immediately.

GFO can easily be overdosed, and other than the "Too low nutrient" issues others have spoke about here, too much Iron can trigger STN in a carbon dosed tank in my experience.

My tank - All in one biopellets and a big skimmer only:
picture.php

Awesome tank

Do you have a tank thread?
 
That is a great looking tank, ocellaris. Big stags add such a nice touch to a reef if you are willing to sacrifice the real estate to them.
 
I dont know if they are running GFO, but when I went into World Wide Corals store, they told me their PO4 was somewhere around .15-.20 and their tank is by far the most beautiful I have ever seen. I imagine with those numbers, they arent running GFO.
 
No Gfo here. I do run carbon though. Even without GFO my po4 ranges from .02-.04

I run a macro packed fuge with chaeto and caulerpa and a dsb as well. Nitrates run between 1-3. I feed very heavy and use a bit of vinegar to help export along. Po4 was around .04-.05 until I upgraded my skimmer and is now around the lower part of that range. All po4 tests are by the Elos pro kit, which is my favorite btw.
 
I dont know if they are running GFO, but when I went into World Wide Corals store, they told me their PO4 was somewhere around .15-.20 and their tank is by far the most beautiful I have ever seen. I imagine with those numbers, they arent running GFO.

It is my wish to one day visit World Wide Corals. They were my main inspiration in having barebottomed tanks.
 
It is my wish to one day visit World Wide Corals. They were my main inspiration in having barebottomed tanks.

Well your tank is no slouch man, well done there. Make a trip to Disney they arent far at all, and you wont be disappointed.
 
Back
Top