Favorite fish of all time

brett559

New member
Just curious what your fish favorite fish ever has been. I know many of you have kept reef tanks for 10 years or more. Has there been one fish that you enjoyed the most, or a species you keep going back to? Have any of you kept a fish for a long time, like more than 10 years? The owner of my LFS just lost his female clownfish that he had since the mid 90s. I was amazed that he was able to keep her so long.

I'd also like to why a particular fish was your favorite. Please share your stories.
 
of all the fish i have ever kept, i have to say my pair of longnose hawkfish has to be my favorite. they have a lot of personality and more than any other fish, will follow me around while i'm near the tank. their little eyes are constantly roaming.
 
When I managed a LFS I was lucky to keep everything from seahorses to cuttlefish but have always been less exciting in my tank and my favourite fish now is by far my marine betta. Only had it around a year though.
Algae blennies are always fun and I was particularly attached to my mollie miller blenny, probably the biggest character I've found in a fish.
 
Hmm, its hard to have a favorite, but my 2 oldest are my favorites. My ocelaris clown is 16 and certainly a silly clown. My flame hawk is 15 and more serious and focused on humans (food source).
 
Rhino blennies are awesome. They 'walk' around, and they look WILD. Rare to find in the trade, though. My guess is people just have a really hard time finding them to catch them.
 
As a kid I had a freshwater tank. My favorite fish was a certain red male Betta. He was very interactive and even learned to jump through a little hoop. My first salt water tank included a baby clown trigger that acted like a puppy. He was into everything. He even rearranged the corals. Sometimes while I was watching scary movies, that booger would start crunching coral and scare me. I've had other favorite fish through the years, but the all time favorite so far is my present McCoskers Wrasse. I didn't want him when I bought him. I was in the LFS getting carbon and there was a tank full of juvenile McCoskers wrasses. I watched them awhile and saw one guy getting bullied. There were some females getting chased, but this was a little male. He ate and seemed healthy, he was just a social wimp. So I got him. For months he was afraid of his own shadow. Then he began to figure out that the only other inhabitant was a Mandarin. That's when he began to flash. He'd come to the front of the tank, flash for a minute, then run and hide in case someone was around to answer his challenge I guess. It was pretty funny. He got bolder over the months, so it's been fun watching him get brave. About a year ago he discovered food stealing. Food apparently tastes better if its stolen. If he's too full to eat it, he'll spit it behind the rocks. He's such a silly. When I had a purple firefish, the McCoskers got a crush on it or something, because he followed it around, flashing and rubbing on it. He always like to be near that firefish. It was one of the many reasons this fish has become my favorite fish of all time. Because he's so weird and funny. He always seems to be into something. Twice he had a wrangle with a bristleworm and got a chin full of bristles like a little beard. A couple times my Ctenophore got its tentacle caught on him and he looked like a little dog pulling on a leash till he got free. I love how he used to get when I would bring food. He would shake all over with excitement and gobble the food as if he were starving. Even if it had only been a few hours, he would still put on that show. He's sick now, so I hope he gets well.
 
My favorite fish that I have kept so far has been the multibar angelfish. Sadly I haven't been able to keep one for more than 7 months, but hope to change that once I am settled down in one place and have more time to dedicate to acclimating a pair to captivity.
 
The yellow headed jawfish because it builds and is fun to watch... followed up with the bicolor bleeny which also have quite the personality. Mine was named "sneaky". He could play hide and seek quite well. I'd have the children that came over try and find him, but it's not always easy because he's sneaky!
 
Favorite fish I have personally had- nothing fancy-a psychedelic sixtine wrasse from years ago, this guy had too much personality.
Favorite fish I have not kept yet but always loved- blue face angel
Favorite fish in my sashimi- blue tuna
 
My favorite fish has to be my naso tang, always ready for some interaction. Always out and really mellow even if he is the biggest fish (8") in the tank.
 
My favorite reef fish that I've had over the last 20 years of reef keeping is probably my present Borbonius Anthias. I just got him about a month ago but there is something about this fish that I am really attached too. Maybe it's because it's a fish I've wanted for a long time and this is my first. I've only had this fish for a month but I know it will be around for many years to come. Second would have to be my cow fish. Personality plus.

My favorite fish of all time is an easy one. Hands down, my former green moray named Gorby is my favorite of all time. He was a 5' Caribbean Green Moray. He had a black birthmark on his forehead so I named him after President Gorbachev who had a similar one. No joke. I'm not Russian either. LOL

I had him for several years. He absolutely loved to be handled. His favorite was a good rubbing under his chin or having his body rubbed and scratched. He's lean into me when I rubbed him. When I scratched his sides, he'd quiver and really lean in. Not an ounce of aggression towards me at all. In fact it was completely opposite. He was more like a cat than a fish in personality. He would let me pick him up completely out of the water. When we had our huge Northridge earthquake back in 1994, I had a plumbing line break in my tank and lost all my water. Being able to pick him up like that to temporarily move him to a trashcan in the midst of the tank draining and tremors was a blessing. Sharks are easy by try moving a 5' moray while you are under serious duress.

I kept him in my tank with a pair of baby white tip reef sharks, a leopard shark and a horn shark. One day I was sitting in my living room when I head and felt a very big bang. At first thought, I thought a car may have crashed into the house. Then I noticed the tank water moving back and forth and a bit of water running down the front viewing pane. Then I noticed my leopard shark was literally cut in half. Two pieces. Gorby ,for what ever reason decided the shark was done or food or something and he hit the shark so hard, it shook the house and ripped a 2.5' fat leopard shark in half. He hit the shark so hard the entire two story house shook from the concussion in the water. At that point, I knew I was going to have to find him a new home and also knew reef was in the future for my tank.

I miss him to this day and always regretted not being able to keep him. Not only was he my favorite fish but he was one of my favorite pets of all time and I've had all kinds of cool pets. He ended up going to a dentists office tank via a friends LFS and I lost touch with the eel after that. Surely he was never handled like that again. If I could find him again, I'd make a tank for him but that was many many years ago.
Gorby.jpg


scan0002.jpg


scan0008.jpg


scan0003.jpg


Even swam with him one drunken birthday. I don't think he was amused though.
scan0004.jpg


scan0006.jpg


scan0007.jpg


scan0005.jpg
 
Last edited:
hands down would have to be my flamehawk. was My first ever fish and has so much so much personality, even reminds me when its feeding time by standing in the middle of the sandbed staring at me till i feed. Pretty much been a model citizen with no signs of aggression between any new edition except for 1 large false perc who chased for a day or two.

Hasnt laid a fin on any of my Hermits,Snails,or porcelain crabs either. Really think i lucked out attitude wise with this guy as ive read alot on here they're good behavior is usually short lived.
 
Favorite fish in my sashimi- blue tuna

:lol:

And as for you, Slief, you are a crazy, crazy man. Love the pictures, but the story of how powerful Gorby was, that makes my blood go cold. He sounds great when he was being affectionate. I didn't know Morays would get that affectionate! But biting he shark in half? Dude that could have been your arm.
( shiver)
 
That's a good question... Hmm.. Right now it would have to be a tie between my zebra moray and my new quoyi parrotfish. Both gorgeous, and definitely attention getting individuals. My favorite fish of all time though, probably has to go to a royal pencil wrasse I kept a few years ago, which was one of the most colorful (and finicky) fish you can get your hands on, full of personality too. As cliched as it is, I'll have to go with a moorish idol as well :fish1: I'm just waiting for the day we finally crack the code on that species, the same way we have for so many others :beer:
 
Slief

How long do green Morays live? Could he still be alive now? We should do a search through social media to find Gorby and reunite him with you!
 
:lol:

And as for you, Slief, you are a crazy, crazy man. Love the pictures, but the story of how powerful Gorby was, that makes my blood go cold. He sounds great when he was being affectionate. I didn't know Morays would get that affectionate! But biting he shark in half? Dude that could have been your arm.
( shiver)

I've been called crazy on many occasions. No doubt I resemble that remark. Inspite of the shark incident, I never had any fears or concerns about handling the eel. The shark was in the food chain but I was not. Unlike the shark, the eel and I had a symbiotic relationship and the eel knew that.

Most large morays are very docile. I've handled wild ones while scuba diving on more than one occasion and would litterally pet them them when I stumbled upon them. You just can't put your fingers in front of their face because if they mistake you for food or if they feel terribly threatened, they will bite.

Back in the day, I actually tried to catch them by hand while diving in an effort to bring them back to one of my tanks. There was this rocky reef in Laguna Beach California that we called Thousand Steps. This place bordered a marine sanctuary and there were dozens of very large and fat California morays all over the rocky reefs.

The Calfornia morays differ a bit from the Caribian one and other tropcal morays. The Ca ones don't get quite as long but get about double the width of their warm water counterparts. A 4' moray could be 10" or more in diameter. They get silly fat and are very mellow in the colder water.

I acquired a bottle of Quinaldine which is a tranquilizer used frequently for marine fish during transport. I'd mix that with isopropyl alcohal which suspends the Quinaldine in the water. I filled up large syringes with the mixture and was experimenting with different dosages.. I used a 2' piece of rigid airline tubing to extend the syringe. I'd swim up to the wild California Morays and stick the tube into their mount and empty the contents of the syringe in an effort to tranquilize them so I could pull them out of the rocks and put them in my dive bag. That was the plan at least. After playing with my mixture on several successive dives and not having luck knocking one out, I finally got frustrated and reached in the rocks and grabbed a big fat one by the scruff of the neck using my bare hands. My buddy was on the surface keeping his distance while also keeping a watchful eye on me. When I grabbed this moray, I could hear (10' above me) my buddy let out a scream in pure shock at what I was attempting. Frankly, I was young and dumb and it was really a stupid thing to do. I still can't beleive what I was attemtping let alone the fact that I had every intent on bringing this poor eel home to put in my tank. In hind site, it was a completely stupid and cruel idea but like I said, I was young and dumb back then.

Needless to say, the eel wasn't terribly enamored with my attempts to catch it. I yanked it out of the rocks and it did a quick twist of it's body and was free of my hands looking right into my eyes. A moment later he swam off. It was worth a good laugh and a lifetime memory that neither I nor my buddy Gregg will ever forget.


Slief

How long do green Morays live? Could he still be alive now? We should do a search through social media to find Gorby and reunite him with you!

Up to 30 years under ideal cicurmstances. I was wondering that myself the other night afte posting this. I don't think he's still alive but I plan on going down the my buddy's shop tomorrow and will ask if he can tell me the name of the dentist office where the eel was just so I can satisfy my curiosity. I've inquired before and I know the shop owner lost contact wiith the customer many years back. If he were still alive, I would be really surprised. Those pictures were taken over 22 years ago. That is a long time in terms of captive fish and he was several years old at the time of those photos.

If I found him, I would absolutely setup a tank for him. Not that I have any desire for more tanks but for him, I would make an exception. That eel was one of a kind and he is one of only a couple pets that I've always missed. I've put my hands in the water with many eels since and I am sure I could easily tame another if I had the desire which fortunately I do not. Keeping fish that large is a lot of work and a real stinking pain with all the food. I was feeding pounds of raw fish and squid evey day and it was costly and tiring. Ultimately those were major factors in my quitting sharks and eels and moving to reef. This was despite the fact that I made good money importing and distributing exotic sharks and eels. My lazy nature didn't work well for that endeavor but it was a lot of fun while it lasted and a good write off.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top