Lets see those steel stands!

[MeuserReef]

Im soon going to begin building a stand for a 120 gallon (60"x18")aquarium and would like to build it from steel tubing. Im also looking to have it powdercoated so it will stay nice for many years of exposure to a saltwater environment. Im not a "pro" welder but I have had some practice. I have a place local that does the powdercoating but have no idea what they will charge (or what I should be charged for something like this).



Here are some specs that may influence the design:

- Tank is 60"x18"
- Stand height is to be 32" tall
- Stand will sit on Engineered Hardwood flooring
- Some other things I havent thought about yet (or havent been reminded of by the RC community )

I know that I have seen many awesome steel stands here on RC and would appreciate any information (tubing size, costs, "lessons learned", etc) that I can get prior to diving into this project. So with that said.... Lets see some steel stands!

 

[DarkFORCE]

This is one that someone made for me.

<a href="http://s249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/?action=view&current=IMG_0765.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/IMG_0765.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

<a href="http://s249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/?action=view&current=IMG_0766.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/IMG_0766.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

<a href="http://s249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/?action=view&current=IMG_0767.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg209/rmilyard/IMG_0767.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

 

[MeuserReef]

Thanks for posting DarkFORCE. What size square tubing is it made out of and how big of a tank is that?

 

[kcress]

Hi MeuserReef.

Whatever you do make sure you put in some shear bracing! I frequently see steel tubing stands that have none. All you need to do is lean on one end and you can get these stands to rack,(trapezoid to the floor). That would be really ugly, maybe even fatal if it racks onto someone.

It can even just be a mostly solid plywood back, just something! I'd add steel diagonals myself.

As for tubing. I would use 1-1/2" square. And since you say you aren't an experienced welder I would opt for thicker. Use 0.125" wall. It is heavier but much harder to blow through and mess up than the thinner walls.

I'd expect to pay about $150-$200 for a powder coat job. You can ask around as almost all powder coaters do motorcycle frames and I would see them as being about the same. A motor cycle takes more effort as it has many hidden angles, but a stand may have more surface,(material cost). So you can probably ask, "How much to do a motorcycle frame"? And avoid the, "I don't know I have to see it first", responses.

 

[mflamb]

 

[MeuserReef]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11948156#post11948156 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kcress
Hi MeuserReef.

Whatever you do make sure you put in some shear bracing! I frequently see steel tubing stands that have none. All you need to do is lean on one end and you can get these stands to rack,(trapezoid to the floor). That would be really ugly, maybe even fatal if it racks onto someone.

It can even just be a mostly solid plywood back, just something! I'd add steel diagonals myself.

As for tubing. I would use 1-1/2" square. And since you say you aren't an experienced welder I would opt for thicker. Use 0.125" wall. It is heavier but much harder to blow through and mess up than the thinner walls.

I'd expect to pay about $150-$200 for a powder coat job. You can ask around as almost all powder coaters do motorcycle frames and I would see them as being about the same. A motor cycle takes more effort as it has many hidden angles, but a stand may have more surface,(material cost). So you can probably ask, "How much to do a motorcycle frame"? And avoid the, "I don't know I have to see it first", responses.

Excellent information. Thank You!


mflamb.... What size tubing is that? It looks really good. If mine comes out even 1/2 as nice as that one, I will still be happy!

 

[DarkFORCE]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11941731#post11941731 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by MeuserReef
Thanks for posting DarkFORCE. What size square tubing is it made out of and how big of a tank is that?

It was made with 1 1/2" tubing. The tank is 120g 60x18x25.

 

[mx36]

Here is one someone made for me. It was made out of 1.25 tubing. I decided to save some money and used a DIY pickup liner called Herculiner to protect the metal from the salt water.

 

[kpc01]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11951630#post11951630 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mx36
Here is one someone made for me. It was made out of 1.25 tubing. I decided to save some money and used a DIY pickup liner called Herculiner to protect the metal from the salt water.

is the tank up and going now? I'm curious how the bed liner held up to the salt and other conditions....I am going to be making a steel stand so I'm keeping an eye on this thread.

 

[a1amap]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11951630#post11951630 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mx36
Here is one someone made for me. It was made out of 1.25 tubing. I decided to save some money and used a DIY pickup liner called Herculiner to protect the metal from the salt water.

Wow, that doesn't look strong enough facing us. The inside has 4 and the side closest to us has 3. I am not knocking it, I have no experience with using steal. I am about to build a stand for a 220g in wall and like the open access that steal will provide.

 

[MeuserReef]

OK... so I finally got a chance to play around with Google SketchUp and here's what I came up with. It may be WAY overkill (perhaps not) but I think it will hold (especially after seeing the tank posted above ).

FRONT VIEW

REAR VIEW

SIDE VIEW

kcress, whats your opinion on the steel diagonals? I used larger diagonals on the rear to add additional stability.

mx36... Im not sure what impresses me more; Your stand, or your plumbing. Very neat and "clean" looking.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11952084#post11952084 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kpc01
is the tank up and going now? I'm curious how the bed liner held up to the salt and other conditions....I am going to be making a steel stand so I'm keeping an eye on this thread.

Id like to know how this is holding up also. I would consider this should the powdercoating threaten to break the bank.

 

[kcress]

mx36!! I greatly suggest you quickly provide some shear bracing!! You are running on borrowed time. Please add some 1 inch flat stock. Drill holes and add one between each of the outer two verticals.

If that setup gets a side load your whole system will collapse, probably faster than your eye can follow.

I could guarantee that stand would collapse in California sooner or later.

Very scary.

But yeah! You've got some nice plumbing going on there. Very neat. :thumbsup:



MeuserReef; That looks great! You could service your main battle tank on top of that.

If it would be easier a single diagonal on the back from one bottom corner to the opposite top works two. It would be six less welds actually 18 less weld lines and three less pieces. What you have is fine! Just an option to consider.

You don't need the cross piece at the middle bottom. There is almost no force in play there and that cross piece will raise havoc with a sump.

I'd put two more cross pieces at the top. Divide the two sides in half with them. This will support the plywood I expect you'll use much better than just the edges and one in the middle.

If desired you can pitch the diagonals and use gussets instead. They're just a triangle of metal. You'd make them the same 0.125 thick steel and they'd go in all the vertical corners. They should be about five or six inches. Again just an option. If you put them out on the outer edge they can be used as easy wood mounting points, if that's a future desire.

Hmmm. WHOA!! Just noticed you have no center braces. 1,200lbs would be a problem. If I got the math right you would be looking at about a 1/4" of deflection in the center. More than enough for most tanks to go south.. Or at least one side to go south while the other goes north. Picture your tank sitting on two 1/4" dowels at the ends on an otherwise flat surface. Not a pretty picture.

You need center braces. If you can't get a sump in then you can make the front one removable. Just make sure you use two snug bolts in it. And don't consider pulling the brace with a full tank riding on the stand unless you do some serious, calculated, temporary auxiliary bracing.

 

[mx36]

Thanks for all the comments on the plumbing.

As for how well the herculiner is holding up, so far very good but the tank has only been set up since Oct. 2007.

kcress..... Thanks for the info i will get something added.

 

[MeuserReef]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11954431#post11954431 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kcress
MeuserReef; That looks great! You could service your main battle tank on top of that.

If it would be easier a single diagonal on the back from one bottom corner to the opposite top works two. It would be six less welds actually 18 less weld lines and three less pieces. What you have is fine! Just an option to consider.

You don't need the cross piece at the middle bottom. There is almost no force in play there and that cross piece will raise havoc with a sump.

I'd put two more cross pieces at the top. Divide the two sides in half with them. This will support the plywood I expect you'll use much better than just the edges and one in the middle.

If desired you can pitch the diagonals and use gussets instead. They're just a triangle of metal. You'd make them the same 0.125 thick steel and they'd go in all the vertical corners. They should be about five or six inches. Again just an option. If you put them out on the outer edge they can be used as easy wood mounting points, if that's a future desire.

Hmmm. WHOA!! Just noticed you have no center braces. 1,200lbs would be a problem. If I got the math right you would be looking at about a 1/4" of deflection in the center. More than enough for most tanks to go south.. Or at least one side to go south while the other goes north. Picture your tank sitting on two 1/4" dowels at the ends on an otherwise flat surface. Not a pretty picture.

You need center braces. If you can't get a sump in then you can make the front one removable. Just make sure you use two snug bolts in it. And don't consider pulling the brace with a full tank riding on the stand unless you do some serious, calculated, temporary auxiliary bracing.

kcress, I appreciate your valuable assistance in this thread.

I like the changes that you suggested and have changed the design a bit. The corner braces are 6"x6"x8.5" triangles.

FRONT VIEW (version 2)

END VIEW (version 2)

CORNER BRACE DETAIL

I liked the idea of using the flat angle pieces in the corners for mounting surfaces for my exterior cabinet that I will have covering this. Im planning on making the wooden exterior "skin" removable so I can maintenance the sump/components as well as clean any spills that will most definetly happen along the way. This tank will be in my living room that will have brand new hardwood flooring so I want to make sure that any spils wont hurt the floor (long term).

As far as sump access, Im using a 20L for a sump so Im sure it will fit without having to remove the center brace. One challenge that I have is that ALL equipment (except DIY Chiller) will have to live in the stand under the tank. If this means that I have to have a smaller sump... so be it. I actually cant go too big with the sump as it will take up too much valuable space that could be used to house other equipment.

With regards to your suggestion that I split the top section to provide additional support for potential plywood; Do I really need these supports if I dont plan on using plywood? My tank is made of glass and has the plastic trim that supports the weight of the tank along the perimeter. I have always made my stands for these types of tanks open so that they only support the tank under/along the trim. Suggestions/concerns with this? (The largest tank that I have built a stand for using this method is a 55 gallon, about 1/4 of the weight of my new tank )

-Are these supports critical if Im not planning to use any sort of material between the tank and the stand?

-Should I use plywood between the stand and tank?


mx36... How easily does the liner scratch off if bumped/scraped? How much did the DIY liner cost you vs. the powdercoating?

 

[mx36]

How easily does the liner scratch off if bumped/scraped? How much did the DIY liner cost you vs. the powdercoating?

So far the liner hasn't scratched off anywhere, but I really haven't bumped it real hard with anything. I slid the 75gal sump across the bottom and it didn't seem to do anything to the liner. It ended up costing me about $60. Never looked into getting it powdercoated just figured it would cost to much. Picked the Herculiner up at Auto Zone. If you decide to go with the Herculiner make sure you mix it up real good, alot of the the stuff settles at the bottom of the can.

 

[mflamb]

Mine is 1.5" square tube, 3/16" thick.

 

[dngspot]

This is my stand before it was covered in 3/4 inch oak ply. The oak is fastened to the 1.25 inch tubing. The stand does not rack in any way.

 

[MeuserReef]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11955775#post11955775 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mx36
So far the liner hasn't scratched off anywhere, but I really haven't bumped it real hard with anything. I slid the 75gal sump across the bottom and it didn't seem to do anything to the liner. It ended up costing me about $60. Never looked into getting it powdercoated just figured it would cost to much. Picked the Herculiner up at Auto Zone. If you decide to go with the Herculiner make sure you mix it up real good, alot of the the stuff settles at the bottom of the can.

Thanks for the tip on shaking the can.

I dont think that I will be able to find anyone that will powdercoat for $60!!! Now I have a low-cost alternative. Thanks.


dngspot... thats a nice looking setup. How is the bare metal covered? Paint, powdercoat, etc?

 

[Konadog]

Here's mine, sprayed with Line-x truck bed liner:

 

[mx36]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11956243#post11956243 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by MeuserReef
Thanks for the tip on shaking the can.


If you go with the diy bedliner you will be better off mixing it with a stick and Not shaking the can. The stuff is pretty thick on the bottom and doesn't mix well with shaking.