Myths & Myth Busting !!!

MUCHO REEF

2003 TOTM Recipient
Premium Member
What are some of the myths you've heard recently or in the past as it relates to the zoanthids and palythoas we keep and anything associated with them.


Mucho Reef

PS, Can we keep this thread serious and on topic if possible. I really want to hear the actual myths that are out there. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
I heard that some 10 polyp frags were worth more than my car payment... Now thats a myth if I ever saw one...
 
Lets see-

Zoas are great low light corals- MYTH! They may suvive under low light, but they dont do great by any means. (with a few exeptions)

Lighting is the most important factor for growing zoas- MYTH! There are many more important factors for zoa growth.
 
Zoas like nutrient rich water- TRUE!

Zoas liking DIRTY water is still kind of in the air.....I vote MYTH! (although some can handle dirty water pretty well)
 
Nutrient rich I think yes...

fully dirty as in 100% trash, all nitrates, nitrites and ammonia...and live there for a long time. ( No form of skimming or ocean constantly replenishing new water around it.... skeptical.
 
Hey, what's this forum?!?! :p

I think the biggest myth with zoanthids is that they will all do well in the type of conditions. They are a very diverse bunch, some will do best with more moderate lighting, some being blasted with light, some like higher nutrient water, others do not, etc. etc. Zoanthids are know to grow in areas closely related with sewage runoff, in tide pools, directly on the reef, in turbid water, in deeper water, you name it... Many zoanthids will certainly do well in a wide range of conditions, but there do seem to be some that favor fairly specific conditions. For some that seems to include "dirty" water or water with fair amounts of dissolved organic content if you prefer.
 
Bam !!!! I knew I would lure you out Peter E. I had several myths I wanted to share and this is one of them. I shake my head when I hear the adamant responses of this particular polyps grows very slow and that is why it is so expensive. People, IT AIN'T TRUE. Why so cocky Mooch ? Not cocky at all on the contrary. If we spent as much time talking about reef and tank diversity, half of the issues we experienced here would be put to rest. Now I hate names and I hate to use them, so I won't, LOL, GOTCHA, but this purple paly which everyone says grow very slow is pure Oscar Mayer Bologna. The polyp grows slower for one reefer and faster for another for one reason and one reason alone, tank parameter, environment including lighting, just as Peter said. I had them and they grew like crazy. My buddy Jim who sold an entire large colony of them grew them for years and sold them to everybody here in Michigan. Some polyps prefer less light depending on the region of origin, others prefer more intense lighting. Many confuse light adaptability to light necessity. If one is experiencing slow group, one needs to do nothing more than to research where the polyp was collected and make marginal changes and document those changes to see the growth that is desired.



Mucho Reef
 
Last edited:
Zoanthids and Paly's are great beginer corals..Myth!
I have spent the most $$$ on these corals and have had more casualties than I would like to admit. IMO I think its b/c of what was mentioned above by Mucho and Peter. Their is definitely not one set of good living conditions for these guys. They are soooo diverse its incredible. Also, they seem to be susceptible to lots of different issues, ie: bacterial infections, predators, diseases, etc. when compared to other corals I have kept in the past. I am by no means an expert, but this has just been my expeirience.
 
I'm glad to see Peter posting also.
Peter, if you're still here, I always learned alot from reading your posts. And I must admit to trying to get you over here that one time. :p
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14541307#post14541307 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by 650-IS350
Nice to see you posting again Peter. AWOL ?

Decided it was best for my sanity to stay out of the zoanthid forum for a bit :p Nice to see you, and you Lily, still around.
 
Yeah I hear you peter, I actually contemplated a couple of times of doing some AWOL my self or actually completely getting out after my last tank crash.
 
LE, which means Limited Edition. I chuckle every time I hear it. There's no such thing as Limited Edition, it's a myth, a marketing tool if you will. I've yet to read in any of my journals that the ocean is only producing X number of polyps this year. LE should be replaced with LS, Limited Supply, because that is what they have, a limited supply. When someone says, "I'm only releasing 10 of these, or Joe Reef Rock's Paris Hilton Powder Pink Palythoas have just gone LE....you need to run.

LE is a myth.

Mucho
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14545990#post14545990 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by MUCHO REEF
"I'm only releasing 10 of these, or Joe Reef Rock's Paris Hilton Powder Pink Palythoas have just gone LE....you need to run.

LE is a myth.

Mucho

:lol:
 
Back
Top