Phosban" Reactor Selection Help

shiveley

Active member
So, since I'll be needing a "Phosban" reactor to go with the GFO I'll be picking up from our bulk order I was hoping to get some advice on which reactor unit to get. As far as I can discern there are really only three units to choose from; so which do you think is best, and why?

Kent Marine Phos Reactor

Two Little Fishies Reactor 150

AquaC XP Plus Phosphate Reactor
 
The reactor in itself does not matter, as long as water goes through with enough pressure. Moves your media around and makes good contact with your media. DIY models are cheap and effective. I have a no name brand that cost 1/2 the price, and works just as great. Make sure you have enough water contact 200-300 gph I believe, even then that is too much.
 
I just ordered 2 Phosban reactors from DrsFosterSmith today (one for GFO and one for Carbon) along with an MJ900 for each. I don't have any experience with either, but Davey, kdblove_99, didn't like the Kent at all, so I just went with the other.
 
Don't forget this bad-boy

fr-616.jpg


This thing is SICK!
 
two little fishies all the way, had mine for a wile never had a problem. I'd
haved tried all kinds of media, rowaphos has to be the best media out there a little more expensive but worth the money, my water is crystal clear never had a problem with algae.
 
Just recently bought a TLF. After reading the boards there were many complaints regarding the Kent. Regarding the AquaC, I only saw folks inquiring about it - particularly it's size - but no reviews. I had planned on getting two, but was advised that for my size tank - 70g - it would be overkill. Rather, put both media Phosban and Carbon in the one reactor. I'll be running a MJ 606 on it so i can dial in the flow - both with the valve that comes with the TLF and the pump - to get the recommended 80 - 90 gph. If you do get two then you can daisy chain them so only one pump is powering both. Run through the Carbon first followed by the Phosban.
 
Last edited:
I've got a couple of the Kent's, and they are cheap and a PITA. That Deltec is sweet, but the price is a rather horrid joke. The Aqua C looks nice, but it is rather large for most of our tanks. I keep wanting to just trash the kent units and find something else, but would rather spend money on frags at the moment....
 
I'm happy with my phosban 150. Its easy to open up and change the media, its built well and it was inexpensive.

The Deltec reactor is sweet, I can't justify the cost for a reactor. I mean, there is no "performance gained" from buying the Deltec. Their skimmers and CA Rx are different, but for a media reactor, there really isn't much to it. And I'm all for the higher end equipemnt FWIW.

I've also heard some negative things about the Aqua C leaking and only being recommended for in sump use. Other than that, they are great for larger applications.

Jim
 
Keep in mind. It is just a media reactor, get your water to make contact with your media. Keep it in sump. If you are all for "high end" $$$, but they all do the same. Water makes contact with media then reacts chemicaly and exits. In 3 mos change out media, you don't need to pay a ton of $$$ for that. Even putting bags and media works too.
 
A while back I had a group buy. I don't remember, but I know they retail for like $45 - $50 if I remember correctly. I was getting it for $30 if I had an order of 6 or more. I don't remember. Saved everyone $15-$20 but that didn't fan out. I ended up getting myself one, and jumped on some livestock.
I don't mean to hi jack, but would people be interested in putting a group buy together?
 
Give some more specifics on the GB. With everyone purchasing GFO right now, I think a GB on reactors would definitely work. I just placed an order for 2 TLF reactors. Its probably too late for me to cancel it.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11122347#post11122347 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by edsimmons
Don't forget this bad-boy

fr-616.jpg


This thing is SICK!


that thing is ILL ( yeah I'm bringing it back)
 
I really have a hate relationship with my Two Little Fishes 150. The elbows are this soft plastic/rubber that leaks if you look at it funny, then as a quick fix comes with a non existent barb fitting, have had problems with it sealing lately and the "filter" is a joke. I have mine on the inside of my sump and am very worried about the ones I see hanging on the outside.

I was just doing a little research for the topic and liked the style of the Via Aqua and that it came with its own pump and was stand alone. Plumbing some of these accessories in, especially those with the el-cheapo fittings, can be a nightmare to find the fittings you need.

The KNOPs look pretty quality, and yes, the Deltec....If they can make a good skimmer......how could they screw that up?

I think there is still a better design out there waiting for this application, possibly a cross through design where the entire chamber is fluidized with some cool baffles to keep it where it belongs.

Oops, now I need to come up with another million dollar idea since I just gave that one away........
 
Yeah, the rubber elbows are lame. I just tossed them.

I have run mine externally for over a year now and have never had any issues.

Over time I think all sponges will get clogged, but I run a very low flow through mine, so I never have any media escape.

Schuran makes a nice model too. Also kinda pricey...and hard to find.
 
What did you think about the Via? Yeah I know, not the top of the line, but I have had some good luck with thier stuff in the past. Something like this, with pump included, may be something up their alley.
 
I guess I might as well throw these out there as well: Precision Marine Reverse-Flow Substrate Reactors. A bit more, but maybe worth it?
I recently worked with one of their protein skimmers, it was very effective, and it was built like a tank.

FT-SR35%201.jpg
 
Last edited:
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11128250#post11128250 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by shiveley
I guess I might as well throw these out there as well: Precision Marine Reverse-Flow Substrate Reactors. A bit more, but maybe worth it?
I recently worked with one of their protein skimmers, it was very effective, and it was built like a tank.

FT-SR35%201.jpg


I have a PM skimmer. It is great.

I'm sure their reactor is great too. I just can't see paying so much for a simple reactor when a cheaper one can get the job done.

I've been running a TLF for 2 years with no problems at all. I'm going to get another for carbon.
 
Back
Top