PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Thanks for the Info Steve.

What group of Tangs get along best?
Is that NO to Angels in general or just choose a smaller one?
Best to get rid of the 6 line?
 
Thanks for the Info Steve.

What group of Tangs get along best?
Is that NO to Angels in general or just choose a smaller one?
Best to get rid of the 6 line?

A dwarf angel is doable but they are not reef safe. The question of multiple tangs is a difficult one to answer. The ones that are the most peaceful get very large and really need a ten foot tank (length is more important than gallonage). The ones that are the most aggressive for sure need an 8 foot tank minimum. Ctenochaetus tangs would work in your tank, but only one. Since tangs eat constantly, it is critical to have sufficient algae for grazing and a long tank so that they do not perceive their territorial imperative being violated. Note that as tangs (and some other fish) mature their perceived needs for territory increase. So what will work for small immature fish will stop working as time passes.

When asking follow up questions please resupply tank size and stocking list. I do thousands of these and my memory is no longer wonderful and page changes mess me up from going back.
 
Thanks Again Steve

Is there any specific order they should be introduced, can I still go with the Mandarin?

pair of Ocellaris Clowns
Coral beauty Angelfish not reef safe for meaty LPS
Yellow Watchman Goby and Pistol Shrimp
Red Firefish
Green Mandarin definitely do not do the six line wrasse
Pair of Sexy Shrimp
Four Green Emerald Crabs
2 Yellowhead Jawfish
McCosker's OR Carpenter's Flasher Wrasse
Tailspot Blenny
Pair of Spotted Cardinals
2 Blue Reef Chromis will become one over time
 
Thanks Again Steve

Is there any specific order they should be introduced, can I still go with the Mandarin?

pair of Ocellaris Clowns most aggressive
Coral beauty Angelfish not reef safe for meaty LPS
Yellow Watchman Goby and Pistol Shrimp
Red Firefish first
Green Mandarin definitely do not do the six line wrasse
Pair of Sexy Shrimp
Four Green Emerald Crabs
2 Yellowhead Jawfish
McCosker's OR Carpenter's Flasher Wrasse
Tailspot Blenny
Pair of Spotted Cardinals
2 Blue Reef Chromis will become one over time

always, most passive first, most aggressive last except the mandarin must go at the end so that there will be sufficient copepods
 
Your opinion please.

Your opinion please.

90 gallon fish only with 30 gallon sump

2 ocellaris clowns
1 cleaner wrasse
1 diamond goby
1 Kleini Butterfly
2 blue chromis
1 coral beauty
1 mimic tang
1 kole or tomini tang.
1 cleaner shrimp
1 sand sifting starfish.

Any issues with this list. Tank is currently populated with clowns, shrimp, starfish and cleaner wrasse
 
90 gallon fish only with 30 gallon sump

2 ocellaris clowns
1 cleaner wrasse survival rate is poor; has no effect on parasite control
1 diamond goby
1 Kleini Butterfly
2 blue chromis will become only one
1 coral beauty three grazers including two tangs will not work
1 mimic tang three grazers including two tangs will not work
1 kole or tomini tang. three grazers including two tangs will not work
1 cleaner shrimp
1 sand sifting starfish. will deplete beneficial organisms in sand bed then starve

Any issues with this list. Tank is currently populated with clowns, shrimp, starfish and cleaner wrasse
 
Hey Steve. What are your thoughts about a Lyretail Hogfish in a 280g FOWLR. The other fish are in my signature. All are currently doing well with no fighting or issues with any of them. The Hogfish I saw is on the smaller side - about 2 inches. Very cool looking fish.

Thanks so much.
 
Hi Steve,

Tank specs:
135 gal (48 X 24 X 27)
40 gal refuge/sump
150 lbs live rock
2 inch sand bed
typical snail CUC - no crabs

Planning mixed reef - SPS/LPS

Inverts:
An anemone and clam later
Lysmata amboinensis - Scarlet cleaner shrimp pair


Fish list:
2 Amphiprion Ocellaris - (Clownfish, mated pair -tank bred)

1-2 Cryptocentrus leptocephalus, possibly mated pair - with Alpheus Bellulus (Pink spotted Watchman Gobie, with Tiger Pistol Shrimp)

2 Nemateleotris Magnifica (Flame Firefish)

1 Macropharyngodon meleagris (Leopard Wrasse)

1 Siganus unimaculatus or Siganus magnificus (Onespot or magnifcant Foxface)

2 Pterapogon kauderni (male/female Kaudern's cardinal, tank bred)

1 Salarias fasciatus (Lawnmower blenny - added after 6 months)

1 Opistognathus rosenblatti (Bluespotted jawfish)


Thanks again for the advice!!
 
Brackish Puffers?

Brackish Puffers?

Can you truly convert a figure 8 puffer or spotted to saltwater?

If so what kind of compatibility would it have?
 
Hey Steve. What are your thoughts about a Lyretail Hogfish in a 280g FOWLR. The other fish are in my signature. All are currently doing well with no fighting or issues with any of them. The Hogfish I saw is on the smaller side - about 2 inches. Very cool looking fish.

Thanks so much.

Lyretail Hogfish are on the aggressive side and will do ok with tank mates that are somewhat similar in aggression. You do have some relatively docile fish, so difficult to predict. Your tank as a whole is on the aggressive side.
 
Hi Steve,

Tank specs:
135 gal (48 X 24 X 27)
40 gal refuge/sump
150 lbs live rock
2 inch sand bed
typical snail CUC - no crabs

Planning mixed reef - SPS/LPS

Inverts:
An anemone and clam later
Lysmata amboinensis - Scarlet cleaner shrimp pair


Fish list:
2 Amphiprion Ocellaris - (Clownfish, mated pair -tank bred)

1-2 Cryptocentrus leptocephalus, possibly mated pair - with Alpheus Bellulus (Pink spotted Watchman Gobie, with Tiger Pistol Shrimp) only one unless you get a male + female for long term survival

2 Nemateleotris Magnifica (Flame Firefish) unless you get lucky with a male female pair, only one will survive longer term

1 Macropharyngodon meleagris (Leopard Wrasse) wait until tank is mature

1 Siganus unimaculatus or Siganus magnificus (Onespot or magnifcant Foxface)

2 Pterapogon kauderni (male/female Kaudern's cardinal, tank bred)

1 Salarias fasciatus (Lawnmower blenny - added after 6 months)

1 Opistognathus rosenblatti (Bluespotted jawfish) does best with cooler temperatures 74-75F


Thanks again for the advice!!

fine with annotations
 
Can you truly convert a figure 8 puffer or spotted to saltwater?

If so what kind of compatibility would it have?

Impossible to answer this question without tank size and tank mates. However, I would not suggest trying to do so. I always keep animals as close to the environment they originated from as possible.
 
Okay... I'm back! Let's try this out:

-60 gallons
-2 ocellaris clownfish
-1 longnose hawkfish
-1 green mandarin dragonet
-1 wrasse (carpenters/mystery)
-1 blenny (starry/lawnmower)
-1 angel (coral beauty/flameback/flame)
-1 top feeder (damsel/chromis)
-1 coral banded shrimp
-1 fire shrimp
 
Okay... I'm back! Let's try this out:

-60 gallons
-2 ocellaris clownfish
-1 longnose hawkfish not shrimp safe
-1 green mandarin dragonet tank is marginal for this fish
-1 wrasse (carpenters/mystery)
-1 blenny (starry/lawnmower) lawnmower would be better but if you are planning a dwarf angel do not put an algae eater in this small a tank
-1 angel (coral beauty/flameback/flame)
-1 top feeder (damsel/chromis)
-1 coral banded shrimp not fish safe
-1 fire shrimp
 
On liveaquaria under firefish it has these 2 options, but does not tell the difference between the two and I cannot find anything on web either explaining the difference between Indonesia and Maldives Firefish


http://www.liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=15+2971+168&pcatid=168


SW - Firefish (Indonesia) - Medium
CN-71133, $ 9.99


SW - Firefish (Maldives) - Medium
CN-80287, $ 21.99

the issue is that collection and shipment from the maldives will be much more expensive for the supplier. There is no morphological difference in the two.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top