Reefkeeping History

In 1982, Adey got the algae scrubber concept going a bit, with his first scrubber patent after researching periphyton and algal cover for years at St. Croix reefs. While not the first patent or use of algae for filtration, I do think it was the first "scrubber" terminology for aquariums.
 
Like I said earlier, Adey's system was at the Pittsburgh Zoo for quite a while. If I remember right, he put it in after he did the one in DC. Basically water was pumped from the tanks up a hill to a greenhouse. The greenhouse was about 30 X 15. A row of tables up either side. On the tables, trays with screen within frames. All angled to the center of the greenhouse, where the water collected into a very large vat, then gravity fed back down to the tanks. HA was everywhere in the greenhouse. They would remove the HA off a few trays per week.
The worst problem were the yellow lighting over the tanks. Everyone blamed the color on the scrubbers, when really their lighting sucked.
 
It makes me feel good to know there are some geezers older than I am here. :D

You are a geezer if:

The very mention of a under-gravel filter still sends a thrill up you know where

Modern tank lighting means replacing that old incandescent light bulb with 2 "modern" "state of art" T12 tubes!

Collecting coral means taking fist size chunks of rose coral for that hard to please butterfly fish.

Diatom Filters made with a mason jar was your last line of defense against Ick.

You dreamed about that monster tank- a whopping 55 or even a 75 gallons of ocean.

Your power filter hung on the back of your tank and moved 120 gallons per hour. Your fish never had it so good.

You got your substrata a the local feed store. What was good for the chickens was great for the fish.

If you didn't like your bone white coral head decorations, you let let thick coats of algae cover them. You green coral kept you NO3 levels at healthy levels- anything under 100ppm. The real first algae scrubbers!

I'm sure you other geezers have much to add. :lolspin:

RJ
 
DSC_6633_zps820dbd26.jpg

We got one of these over a display right when it came out at the fishstore I managed. It was soooo blue! However, I'm quite certian that every single person on this forum has a considerably bluer bulb over their tanks now.

The other crazy thing is that a lot of equipment is either about the same, or cheaper today than it was back in the 80's...
 
You are a geezer if:

The very mention of a under-gravel filter still sends a thrill up you know where

Modern tank lighting means replacing that old incandescent light bulb with 2 "modern" "state of art" T12 tubes!

Collecting coral means taking fist size chunks of rose coral for that hard to please butterfly fish.

Diatom Filters made with a mason jar was your last line of defense against Ick.

You dreamed about that monster tank- a whopping 55 or even a 75 gallons of ocean.

Your power filter hung on the back of your tank and moved 120 gallons per hour. Your fish never had it so good.

You got your substrata a the local feed store. What was good for the chickens was great for the fish.

If you didn't like your bone white coral head decorations, you let let thick coats of algae cover them. You green coral kept you NO3 levels at healthy levels- anything under 100ppm. The real first algae scrubbers!

I'm sure you other geezers have much to add. :lolspin:

RJ

And Herbert Axelrod was God!!!
 
Speaking of Herbert Axelrod:

Herbert R. Axelrod Born June 7, 1927 Bayonne, New Jersey. Occupation, tropical fish expert, publisher of pet books, musical instrument collector, and entrepreneur

Ph.D. Alma materL: New York University,Subjects:tropical fish


Herbert Richard Axelrod (b. June 7, 1927 in Bayonne, New Jersey) is a tropical fish expert, publisher of pet books, and entrepreneur. In 2005 he was sentenced in U.S. court to 18 months in prison for tax fraud.

On April 13, 2004, Axelrod was indicted in federal court in New Jersey, accused of funnelling millions of dollars into Swiss bank accounts over 20 years without paying taxes. The following April 21, he failed to appear for his arraignment, having fled to Cuba. He was arrested in Berlin on June 15, 2004 as he got off a plane from Switzerland, and then extradited to the United States. On March 21, 2005 he was sentenced in U.S. court to 18 months in prison for tax fraud.

Back in the day, I thought he was the man. His books first got me into the hobby. Definately a part of Reefkeeping History...
 
Last edited:
I love that Burrfish Paul. Did you catch that thing? Really great looking fish.

Yes we collected him here in NY, after a year and a half he got to big and I gave him to a public aquarium where he is today. This is a picture of him as a baby.

The very mention of a under-gravel filter still sends a thrill up you know where

My tank must really thrill you as I still use a UG filter and it has been running since Nixon was President.

So I took a glance through a couple of the mags and figured some of you , at least Paul, Peter ans RJ, would remember these guys.

Yes I remember those books and probably have some, but my books from the 60s and 70s are in black and white. Julian Sprung is a Noob as he got into the hobby much later. :lmao:

boxfish007-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
I wrote this a couple of years ago and found it published it on the web, I thought it is relevant here:;)

Saltwater fish keeping in the 70s and 80s Was an adventure

Saltwater fish keeping in the seventies and eighties was an adventure. It all started in 1971 when Peter Wilkens published his book in Germany titled "Saltwater Aquarium for Tropical Marine Invertebrates" (unfortunately it was not translated to English until the mid 80s). Very few stores sold saltwater fish and if they did, it was just Blue Devils, Dominoes and Sergeant Majors. The places that did offer salt water had just one small tank of saltwater fish and a huge sign outside that read "We have Salt Water". If you had never seen saltwater tropical fish before, the sight of a blue devil was awe inspiring.The animals came out before any of the devices to keep them alive arrived. Powerheads were mainly for fresh water and none of them were submersible. They were designed to sit on top of under gravel lift tubes, and the first ones were made out of aluminum. That is not something you want to see in a freshwater tank, much less saltwater. There were also no GFCIs so we would have to unplug the powerheads before we put our hands in the water. The lighting was not much better. You had a choice of those long skinny incandescent lamps or fluorescent lamps which you had to push in the button and hold it until it lit. The first canopies to hold these lamps were metal, so after a few nasty shocks we learned to turn the lights on with a stick.By the eighties we had plastic powerheads but most of them were not yet submersible.Sanders sold a skimmer in the seventies but it was only about 12" high and was a counter current skimmer, meaning it worked with an air stone. The only air pump available to push enough air into it was a piston pump. The piston pumps cost more than the skimmers and they used a leather piston which had to be oiled about once a week. Some of the oil always managed to find its way into the water and the motors for these pumps were made very badly causing them to overheat. I always fitted them with a fan. Of course, I always managed to stick my hand into the fan blades. The pumps were also noisy and had to be placed in a closet or insulated box which made them even hotter.The fish were amazing. A person was looking at my tank once and asked me how I got the paint to stick on the fish. He was referring to a percula clownfish, and he was serious! One big problem was getting a healthy fish because there was no such thing. All of the fish had ich. If it were not for copper, there would be no saltwater fish hobby. The fish were shipped, sold and kept in copper treated water. We bought copper like we buy artificial saltwater today. We thought ich was just a part of life.Another bane of hobbyists was cyanide collected fish. Cyanide is a poison that was very commonly used to collect fish. The cyanide procedure called "blue stoning" was accomplished by squirting the chemical around a coral head causing the stunned fish to leave their hiding places and become lethargic so that they could just be hand caught and put into containers. Many of these fish lived for a long enough time to be shipped to retailers to be sold - the rest died. Unfortunately, even the ones that lived for a few weeks died soon after for no outward reasons. There was an article written about it in a 1974 issue of TFH (Tropical Fish Hobbyist) magazine. The chemical was banned in the Philippines in 1980 although it is still being used in some areas. Things stayed like that into the eighties when something drastic happened in the hobby which changed everything. The German government banned the importation of all butterflies and angelfish to appease environmentalists in that country. With those beautiful animals banned, people started to try to keep corals, which were legal to import. The Berlin Aquarium Society was instrumental in introducing high intensity lighting and the discovery of what supplements were needed to keep these unusual creatures alive.Also created by the Germans was the first HQI bulb which was 6,000K - it could keep corals alive but its color left much to be desired. Luckily they also came out with an actinic o3 lamp in the 420 nm range which offset the awful color of the high intensity lamps available. Actinic lamps were borrowed from hospitals, where they were used to cure infants of jaundice.In the US we still had no live or even dead rock. All tanks were decorated with dead coral skeletons, which were not cheap. When the nice white dead coral would get a little green tinge, we would remove them to soak overnight in Clorox. The tanks were filtered with under gravel filters and maybe a canister filter filled with floss and maybe some carbon. Now we all know that anemones can't survive in a tank with copper so we had a rough time there for a while. We had to get the copper out of the water along with the ich so we could keep anemones. It was not easy and we lost loads of fish. A blue devil was about $7.00 then, which is about $30.00 today. We eventually learned that if we fed the fish something besides flakes and we cultivated some bacteria while letting some algae grow, we could get the fish into a state of health where we could eliminate the copper.Of course any new fish had to be quarantined in copper treated water for a month or so.You have to remember this was way before internets or even computers. Very, very few people kept saltwater fish and the stores that did stock them had no knowledge of them whatsoever. The only magazine available was "The Marine Aquarist", and it was hard to come by and had limited information. Most of the foods available were designed for freshwater and even artificial saltwater was scarce. I first used "Lampert Kay's Marine Magic". It came in a small green box and was also not real cheap. Luckily for me, I lived near the sea and could at least collect water.Gradually more animals became available - coral banded shrimp and arrow crabs were starting to be common, as were yellow tangs. There were many fish for sale that even now we have a hard time keeping - fish like Moorish Idols (I had a few of them in the eighties), shrimpfish, clingfish and orange spotted filefish. Tanks then were fish only and many of those animals had a tough time in a reef - they had almost no chance in a fish only especially with the foods we had available.Corals were also frequently offered for sale. Going to an aquarium store was always a great day as you never knew what new animal they would have that you never saw before. By the nineties we had submersible powerheads, larger skimmers, powerful air pumps and other means to purify the water. Wet dry filters were state of the art and a variety of systems were replacing under gravel filters. We had the natural system which was invented by Lee Chin Eng in the sixties, the Jaubert system, and then we had plenums, pushed by Bob Goemans, the sterile system and then deep sand beds used by many people today.To me reefing was much more challenging in the seventies and eighties, although it was also more nerve wracking. You had to really take your time with any new animals you purchased because of the lack of information or just wrong information. We even considered ourselves lucky if we could get aiptasia anemones to live. Today I feel we have too much information, most of it conflicting. Much of the information in this hobby was created in Germany. Eventually it got translated to English but by the time that happened, a lot of the information was already outdated. Today millions of people enjoy this wonderful and educational hobby. The animals are easier to keep now but I feel there is a lot more that we don't know. -written by Paul Baldassano (Paul B)
 
If you didn't like your bone white coral head decorations, you let let thick coats of algae cover them.
RJ

My fascination is corals began in 1980 while collecting shells on the beach, I found a small acro skeleton and knew it was different so i kept it. Later that day while shopping for t-shirts I found out what it was by looking at a display of bleached corals. I bought many bleached skeletons and had amassed a large collection over the years, never dreaming I would one day be growing them. I kept my collection in a different glass box, a display case with multicolored lights.
 
NeilFox. Thanks for the seldom known info, but if I'm not mistaken your post is a direct plagiarism of Dr. Herbert R. Axelrod's Wikipedia page ...

Plagairism is the Cancer of Science ! It shouldn't be condoned, here or elsewhere, please consider deleting.

In the future simply cite/link your source(s) :)
 
Last edited:
Used to have several FAMA magazines and other vintage prints by Dr. Axelrod. I was an avid fan of saltwater tanks even before I got into the hobby around 2004... :) Thank you Peter and Paul for this thread. :D
 
Chopped liver again eh Marty!!! :lol: Subic Bay was an area I dived when I was in your local. It still has a spot in my soul. While not as pristine as the GBR, some of the life got to me more. I was lucky to spend a few months in the Philippines as it was our home port. If you ever get down that way, get some pics for me. Mag Si Si Bvd comes to mind. Strange days indeed!!!!
 
NeilFox. Thanks for the seldom known info, but if I'm not mistaken your post is a direct plagiarism of Dr. Herbert R. Axelrod's Wikipedia page ...

Plagairism is the Cancer of Science ! It shouldn't be condoned, here or elsewhere, please consider deleting.

In the future simply cite/link your source(s) :)

It was a cut and paste coralreefdoc. I will delete, I should have cited the wikipedia source, although wikipedia is public domain. i wasn't trying to publish anything for gain or use this for a thesis, so I thought no harm.I actually was surprised to find out about him, I had looked him up to make sure his name was spelled correctly. I merely thought that info may have furthered the topic of reefing history. My apologies.
 
Well, I tried to delete the post but I don't know how? Anyhow post #66 is primarily taken from Herbert Axelrods Wikipedia page.
 
Paul

Your "serious" historical review was needed as I think the youngsters probably were mystified at my attempt of humor.

In the south, Ga., Fla. and surrounding states there was real fear about cyanide collecting. Most of us were afraid to buy anything from west of Hawaii. One or two collectors in the Caribbean/ Keys/ Bahamas tried using the poison, making no effort to keep it quiet, and were quickly blacklisted by the Fla. trade. This effort was also strongly supported by Robert Straugham. LFSs had signs stating no poison was used in collecting their fish. Florida wholesalers boosted their stock was cyanide free.
The stores and wholesalers really didn't know.

Although I had to sign a pledge my fish were collected w/o poison. I strongly suspected many collectors were still using some form. Research collectors did and continue today to use anesthetics to collect. I have seen commercial collectors using "anesthetic" in the Bahamas in the early 1980s. Today, the trade does use various anesthetics in the aquarium trade. The problem is these drugs have several drawbacks in their use. For collecting dosage levels are impossible to control, there is always other organisms affected, there will be animals that have adverse reactions and die. In the third world the "good" drugs are hard to obtain, store and are very expensive. This leads back to the cheapest option- cyanide.

I strongly suspect 90% of our pets are collected and transported using anesthetic/ tranquilizers. While much better than "poison", I am not sure we understand all the long term ramifications.

RJ
 
And just for fun: 4 score and 7 years ago.......

NeilFox. Thanks for the seldom known info, but if I'm not mistaken your post is a direct plagiarism of Dr. Herbert R. Axelrod's Wikipedia page ...

Plagairism is the Cancer of Science ! It shouldn't be condoned, here or elsewhere, please consider deleting.

In the future simply cite/link your source(s) :)

Really?

I doubt if anyone thought that was his own work and was trying to pass off as such.

Are you going to start calling others out when they fail to include the authority when nomenclature is used on RC?

Also we all know that anything can be put in a wiki page and it be taken as correct. :lol:

Relax and enjoy the history lesson.
 
Thanks Mike for addressing that.

Man, some of you guys really go a long way back in the hobby. It's enat to see the progression of the hobby. I've only been doing it 10 years and so much has already changed.
 
Man, some of you guys really go a long way back in the hobby.

You have no Idea. I had fish when Eisenhower was President. He was after Lincoln.

If you didn't like your bone white coral head decorations, you let let thick coats of algae cover them. You green coral kept you NO3 levels at healthy levels- anything under 100ppm. The real first algae scrubbers!

You can see some of those bleached white corals here in my tank under construction here Circa 1979. You can't see the rest of them because they were covered in algae.

Oldtank.jpg


And how it has changed today

IMG_2355.jpg
 
It's what my tangs loved on my FOWBCH (FOw/bleached coral heads). It was food. I remember in one tank I had, having the largest aptasia I've ever seen. It was beautiful swaying in the current from my aquaclear. It never put off others though. I fed it every day. The center disc was about 4 inches across.
 
Back
Top