tang mixing experiment

The steven liu

New member
First of all, I work at a LFS so I have the luxury to observe and pick the best livestock for a long while (if they aren't sold for a while) before I take them home with me. So I am always able to stock my tank with the sure survivor from collecting and shipping since I generally observe them for a couple weeks before I take them home. I have only a 50G tank with a 15G sump. I do intend to upgrade to a larger tank after the summer when I move. So whatever I put in my tank now as a juvinile will eventually be in a bigger tank when they grow up.:cool:

For the longest time I have only kept one 3" zebrazoma scopas together with 3 chromis and a pink skink clown. I wished to add alittle more vibrancy to my tank so I began hunting for another reef safe fish with moderate size potential.

After two weeks of observation at the store I brought home a female 3" Genicanthus Watanab (watanabe angel). I was really nervous when I put her in since I am not sure what the reaction of the tang will be. To my surprise the tang completely ignored her and let her be. She hid for two days adjusting to my tank's lighting and has been swimming around and eating fine since then.

After that I decided I would risk another Tang since my scopas seem to be tamer than I would hope for. So I picked up a 2" paracanthurus hipatus (hoppo tang) , again, from observing it for two weeks. I prayed that he will be a success mix since it is a totally different shape and color from the scopas. And again to my surprise not only the scopas left it along, the hippo tang was out and swimming the very next day and even feed with the scopas side by side as I feed them!

I think my success was based on :
1. dumb luck
2. tangs of different shape and color
3. patient and advantage of my work

Sofar these three fishes are all juvinile and are living happily together in my 50G. Obviously this will not be adequate setup once they grow up. But for the time being, I am very happy the introduction of the new fishes were smooth.
 
Well, it's good you have this hobby to teach you certain things about this hobby which in turn will make you more informed at your LFS. Most people know that mixing tangs of different species is fine - Acanthurus tangs (or paracanthurus like your blue) get on particularly well with Zebrasoma.
 
How about a Ctenochaetus with an Acanthurus?

I am under the impression that Zebrasomas are generally the heartiest; Ctenochaetus the least agressive.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7139563#post7139563 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by count mackula
How about a Ctenochaetus with an Acanthurus?

I am under the impression that Zebrasomas are generally the heartiest; Ctenochaetus the least agressive.
Ctenochaetus with an Acanthurus would be fine but Ctenochaetus can battle with Zebras (particularly aggressive yellow tangs). I have a passive YT and will be introducing a Powder Blue when he finishes quarantine and I will also add Ctenochaetus (Kole or Chevron). I think these three can co-exist very peacefully. At the end I'll be introducing a Clown Tang because I really want one. The Clown is one of the most most aggressive tangs but the Powder Blue will be bigger and well established and the Clown Tang will be small so I'm sure it will succeed.
 
If anyone of you are to make a suggestion which family of tang will you recommend against based on their temper? I was under the impression acantharus are the worst? but I could be wrong....
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7141014#post7141014 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by The steven liu
If anyone of you are to make a suggestion which family of tang will you recommend against based on their temper? I was under the impression acantharus are the worst? but I could be wrong....
You're right- Sohal and "Clown" Tangs are both Acanthurus Tangs and they have the "worst temper".

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7139896#post7139896 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by M. Python
My tang list.
1 powder blue tang
1 blond naso tang
1 hippo tang
1 yellow tang
3 purple tangs
I hope you're not placing all of these in a 180!
 
Clown tangs are too aggressive to be kept in any aquarium in my opinion. And yes all these tangs are all in my 180, most are over seven years in this tank. Only the powder blue is at eight months and doing fine with the other tangs. I hate to say this but I also have two triggers and a fox face also that have been in this tank almost from start up eight years ago.
 
Back
Top