This Kills AEFW eggs!!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
At this point the only people with relevant information would be MAMMOTHREEFER, EWW, THERMOJOE, UNIQUE CORALS, Pleas ask them questions. Pleas stay on subject. O ya your not a BETA over 120k went into this before you even got a chance to use it on testing.......
negative reviews??????? none yet????????
 
Have you posted anything relevant on this thread? Your sitting around watching these people testing your product hoping nothing goes wrong I'm sure, and yea there is a negative when people are placing corals back in there tanks and it's killing inverts something other dips do not do. Not everyone has a coral qt and can set one up I'd say that's not a good thing for your product. And honestly I now really hope unique corals says this stuff sucks and doesn't do as advertised. Because you my friend seem like a JA and there's plenty of dips that can kill the long list of pests as well if it can't kill the eggs like you say it does than nobody cares and your product will get bashed and go down in flames pew pew
 
@ BIGCEFA no one is testing at all they may think they are but there not...... This has been tested beyond your comprehension. This is simply a review....... anything elts?
 
Well I just used the dip. I placed a nice big stag which clearly had flatworms on it and they all died as expected from a dip. Nothing happens to the rest of my system and everything looks fine. I can't say if the eggs were killed or not since I didn't really see any. I will say the dip does a better job at killing the flatworm not just stunning it like other dips do. I think I will put down the bayor for a while and use this more often.
 
Seahawks do nothing for me and I still don't see proof that it kills eggs other dips work great too just come back to me with some dead aefw eggs which I have no idea how you'd know they are dead after a dip then ill be happy
 
OPE here is one, when we started this endeavor the company registered on this forum see the date from conception? SEP 2011, Yes that is correct.
 
Again, the instructions seem to be a little unclear. Maybe it's just me.

My experience with the death of two shrimp was after using the product on every acro in my tank. Maybe the volume of coral I dipped had something to do with it? A little residue on one or two corals will not affect anything in the system, but the residue from 15 to 20 dipped corals might?

Anyway, the instructions state to place the coral in qt after the dip. Does this mean that the manufacturer does not recommend placing dipped corals, even after a thorough rinse, directly back in the DT? Should the product not be used without a qt?
 
hja99 said:
Again, the instructions seem to be a little unclear. Maybe it's just me.

My experience with the death of two shrimp was after using the product on every acro in my tank. Maybe the volume of coral I dipped had something to do with it? A little residue on one or two corals will not affect anything in the system, but the residue from 15 to 20 dipped corals might?

Anyway, the instructions state to place the coral in qt after the dip. Does this mean that the manufacturer does not recommend placing dipped corals, even after a thorough rinse, directly back in the DT? Should the product not be used without a qt?
Click to expand...

That can happen with any product. I once dipped my whole tank with bayor, I didn't rinse very well and my whole tank was closed up for a few days.
 
Reefpestsolutio said:
@allmost, Have you tried all out?
Click to expand...

I have not. and will not after seeing you post !

and the way you post and think you are joking, while you are providing no proof, shows that you have no Idea if your product does what it sais ....

I will not be wasting my money on your products. I do not respect reps that take no pride in their product and decide to use "humor" instead of proving their claims.

when I make a product at work, I stand behind it 100%, support all my claims, and I never joke with my clients ... I do not post you tube videos of seagals neither.

shouldnt you be a sponsor to be able to advertise here ? time to clarify with mods.
 
Yes, I understand that it can happen with any product. That is why I said in a previous post that I was not blaming this product. However, I have used other products without resulting in the death of other animals in the system. I have used other products on only one to three corals at a time and rinsed those less than I did when I used this product.

Again, I'm not blamig the product. However, I used the recommended dose; dipped for 15 minutes like it states in the instructions on the bottle (I used a timer, so I didn't just guess); placed the dipped corals in two and a half gallons of clean water; let them sit in there for 15-20 minutes; swirled them off before placing them back in the DT.

The results are that I found at least one large flat worm that was dead as a doornail, asterena stars, and some pods. There may have been more but it is difficult to see the bottom of the container as the solution is very blue. My two shrimp were also affected soon after placing the coral back in the DT. At least 3/4 of the corals I dipped bleached a bit too.

Although other products could produce the same unwanted results, they never have for me. So, I am not sure whether I did something wrong (maybe I had some solution on my hands?), whether a qt is required, or whether the dip is that much more potent than Coral Rx and Revive. At least one other person who posted here seems to have had similar unwanted results though.
 
Allmost, I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks his post are just rediculous he's not repping his company well at all I think it's kinda sad the way he acts. Very arrogant and not helpful at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

C
Maxspect jump led issue
Replies
0
Views
99
Cruzersmith
C
JeannineC
Clownfish eggs?
2
Replies
26
Views
2K
Anemone
Anemone
S
Its been a while.
Replies
8
Views
257
sleeperls
S
revclyburn
Need some thoghts on skimmers
Replies
7
Views
396
Timfish
Timfish
R
Cyano and nutrients
2
Replies
22
Views
641
Radicalrob1982
R
Back
Top