Vodka, vinegar,biopellets and other organic carbon dosing

guys i have been dosing vsv in a 170 ltr tank and have been doing so for close to 2 months and im up to 4 mls morning and nite and have just started adding
microbactor 7 this last week and my nitrates are still 50 ppm :angryfire:

what am i doing wrong?

ive done it in the past and never had to dose more than two mls morning and nite to get my nitrates down to zero and gone to a mainatence dose.


:hmm4:
 
Rick,Been of this thread for a bit. Missed your ?
Live rock leaching PO4,using lanthanum.

If you want to keep the rock live use new clean salt water in a curing bin with a small powerhead. Test the PO4. Put the rock it in the curing bin ;test the PO4 again after a few days to a week,. If it's leaching PO4 add lanathaum chloride to bring the PO4 to zero;check every day or two and add more lanthanum to mainatin near zero PO4 in the water. It's beren years since I last did this but IIRC a cpaful(5ml) of seaklear as a daily dose to a 20 gallon bin was adequate. Once the PO4 tests give you consistently low to zero readings ,the process is complete. Ususlly takes a few weeks.

If you don't care about keeping the rock alive use fresh water . It has an advantage in terms of reducing PO4 to very low levels when used with lanthanum since there is 0 to very low carbonate in it ;so, lanthanum binding to carbonate instead of PO4 is avoided for the most part.

Usually coraline will tak space from microalgae .

I don't have a link handy but if you search on the Reef Chemistry forum you'll find several.
 
Judge,
How much sugar, vodka , vinegar doesthe vsv contain. Sugar is 2.5 as strong as vodka ; vodka is 8xs as strong as vinegar in terms of organic carbon content? Sine I don't use sugar I need the pro[portions to compare your dsingamount to mine.

Nitrates at 50 could take a while to drop. In some cases it takes months. Reducing them with water changes or otherwise before starting the carbon dosing makes it much quicker and easier to reach a maintenance dose. What is the PO4? The bacteria need some to go with the nitrates and organic carbon.
 
Thanks Tom!...I'm going with option 2,...using just ro-di water(no salt) with LC,...seems to knock the PO4 down quick, and then polish it off with a few days of GFO. I definitely will make sure it reads 0 for a number of days before it goes back in the tank, as pulling all my rock and doing it in batches is a real chore. :uhoh3:---Rick
 
I still get a bit of PO4 on my Hanna,....just making double sure this time before I put it all back lol. As I have read many times on RC,..."go slow"... in this hobby, really comes shining through. :)
 
tmz said:
Judge,
How much sugar, vodka , vinegar doesthe vsv contain. Sugar is 2.5 as strong as vodka ; vodka is 8xs as strong as vinegar in terms of organic carbon content? Sine I don't use sugar I need the pro[portions to compare your dsingamount to mine.

Nitrates at 50 could take a while to drop. In some cases it takes months. Reducing them with water changes or otherwise before starting the carbon dosing makes it much quicker and easier to reach a maintenance dose. What is the PO4? The bacteria need some to go with the nitrates and organic carbon.
Click to expand...


cheers for the reply,

200 mls vodka, 1 x table spoon brown sugar, 50 mls vinegar.

could i increase the dose?

i need to test my po4 but if the experience ive had in the past has anything to do with it i noticed my po4 was always higher than my nitrate and when i got my nitrates down to zero,my po4 with nitrate limited and had to dose nitrate to get my po4 down tonear zero.


thanx in advance :beer:
 
200 mls vodka, 1 x table spoon brown sugar, 50 mls vinegar.


 1table spoon of sugar = 14.78 mls x2.5 = 37ml (80 proof/40% )vodkda
50ml (5% acetic acid vinegar)=50 divided by 8=6ml vodka
So ,250 ml of your mix is : 200 +37 +6 = 243 ml 90 proof vodka equivalents.

It's 97% the strength of straight(80 proof/40% ethanol ) vodka.





could i increase the dose?


4mls your dose divided by 170liters =.023 per liter x ( 3.8 liters per gallon )= ..089ml per gallon x.97 = the equivalent of 0.87 ml per gallon or 80 proof vodka.

Most settle in between .04 and .08 ml per gallon ; so, you are already at the high end of the average dosing .FWIW, I use 0.06ml per gallon. about 70% of your current dose.;much more than that gives me some excess bacteria.

Sorry for all the math but going from metric to tablespoons to gallons to proof etc takes a while.
 
I've been reading all I can before I set up my first saltwater tank. I read this thread from beginning to end, and I just wanted to say: Wow, Tom, you should charge for your services here! It seems so few people know anything about carbon dosing; I might as well be looking up how to do magic. Thank you!
 
200ml of vodka seems to me a lot of vodka is this for a 120 gallon tank? Also it took me almost 4 months to get to zero po4 and zero nitrates using vodka. I ended up dousing 5mls a day and even that was a lot as I started to see the thin white slim algea. All I can say is go slow with this as it works well. One of the mistakes I made when I was dosing vodka was I ran GFO and this striped the water too fast and Sps bleached.
Good luck and please go slow.
 
Who's dosing 200ml vokda to a 120 gallon? I should say dosed since it's likely the tank didn't survive it.

Our friend from Austraillia is dosing 4 ml of a vodka vinegar sugar mix to a 170liter tank;almost .09ml per gallon

200ml for 120 gallons is 1.6 ml per gallon roughly 25 times higher and would surely destroy a tank.I personally don't go over .07 mls per gallon .
 
tmz said:
200 mls vodka, 1 x table spoon brown sugar, 50 mls vinegar.


 1table spoon of sugar = 14.78 mls x2.5 = 37ml (80 proof/40% )vodkda
50ml (5% acetic acid vinegar)=50 divided by 8=6ml vodka
So ,250 ml of your mix is : 200 +37 +6 = 243 ml 90 proof vodka equivalents.

It's 97% the strength of straight(80 proof/40% ethanol ) vodka.





could i increase the dose?


4mls your dose divided by 170liters =.023 per liter x ( 3.8 liters per gallon )= ..089ml per gallon x.97 = the equivalent of 0.87 ml per gallon or 80 proof vodka.

Most settle in between .04 and .08 ml per gallon ; so, you are already at the high end of the average dosing .FWIW, I use 0.06ml per gallon. about 70% of your current dose.;much more than that gives me some excess bacteria.

Sorry for all the math but going from metric to tablespoons to gallons to proof etc takes a while.
Click to expand...


thanx for the reply,

so ok the 4 mls dose seems high but have had no slime or anything so far
so do you think my levles will come down eventually?

ok to keep dosing 4 ml?

cheers
 
judgedread said:
thanx for the reply,

so ok the 4 mls dose seems high but have had no slime or anything so far
so do you think my levles will come down eventually?

ok to keep dosing 4 ml?

cheers
Click to expand...

It's not that high and tanks are different. Since you aren't getting any signs of excess bacterial growth , the 4mls might be right for your tank now;though it seems high for a maintenance dose.

It can take months in some cases to bring down intial NO3 levels. Some folks just keep upping the dose but that carries an increased risk for a bacterial bloom or total organic carbon buildup. Water changes to bring them down in a smaller tank or a sulfur dentrator in a larger system followed by a maintenance dose to keep them low is easier,safer and faster,ime.

I've never used bacterial supplements. They aren't necessary,imo.

If it were my 170l tank I'd do a series of 15% water changes while continuing to dose and probably tweak back the dose a bit once the nitrate level was under 5ppm. To keep the dose constant , you can add a proportionate amount to the replacement water.
 
Last edited:
tmz said:
It's not that high and tanks are different. Since you aren't getting any signs of excess bacterial growth , the 4mls might be right for your tank now;though it seems high for a maintenance dose.

It can take months in some cases to bring down intial NO3 levels. Some folks just keep upping the dose but that carries an increased risk for a bacterial bloom or total organic carbon buildup. Water changes to bring them down in a smaller tank or a sulfur dentrator in a larger system followed by a maintenance dose to keep them low is easier,safer and faster,ime.

I've never used bacterial supplements. They aren't necessary,imo.

If it were my 170l tank I'd do a series of 15% water changes while continuing to dose and probably tweak back the dose a bit once the nitrate level was under 5ppm. To keep the dose constant , you can add a proportionate amount to the replacement water.
Click to expand...
Great advice where were you when I was dosing vodka two years ago lol
 
Tom I think I read back on one of the carbon dosing threads that you should not carbon dose on a new tank . If this is correct I am curious as to the reason
 
I wouldn't personally.
The extra hetertrophic bacteria may impede the growth of the usual ammonia oxidizers and other cycling bacteria . They may not out compete them but it seems reasonable to think they would since they take ammonia directly. Also the general lack of stability in a new setup doesn't need to be more complicated ,imo. I prefer to let a tank mature a little before considering carbon dosing. There is no rule on it though.
 
Thanks, I was here and on the chemistry forum mostly. I started this thread two and a half years ago. First dosed vinegar 8 years ago. Started this run with vodka and vinegar over five years ago. Wow that's 37 liters of vodka so far.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

K
Carbon Dosing causes STN/RTN?
Replies
13
Views
700
Timfish
Timfish
R
Cyano and nutrients
2
Replies
22
Views
645
Radicalrob1982
R
S
Nutrient Export
Replies
0
Views
98
SantaMonica
S
S
Nutrients vs Nutrition
Replies
6
Views
754
Timfish
Timfish
Tamara Marshall
Comprehensive Article About Carbon Dosing - Manta Systems Article
Replies
9
Views
346
wvned
wvned
Back
Top