Nice fixture. I was leaning in that direction after seeing rogers fixture. Bobby how do you like intensity of light compared to radion?
I respect everyone's choice and preference in lighting.
From one who isn't a stranger to spending money on the latest technologies I can comment on LED.
LED can absolutely grow anything. However there is a learning curve like anything else.
T5 & MH are very forgiving in comparison to LED.
Forget about heat and power consumption for a moment.
Referring to effectiveness.
LED is a spot light.
The more narrow the the optics the more narrow the spotlight.
If is extremely easy to bleach your corals with LED.
Once you spend enough money buying new corals (you will kill/bleach coral in the beginning) and figuring out the brightness or intensity, if growing SPS, you will never get the same color as T5 or MH.
If you are an LPS/ZOA person than LED is great!
If you are a die hard SPS person than T5/MH should be for you.
My opinion the whole goal of SPS is getting reflective pigmented color.
There is a super fine line of providing just amount of strong light exposure to an SPS to achieve this. Hard to estimate with LED due to the possiblility of bleaching.
In regards to heat, I have an open canopy and the T5's only heat up my water one degree through out the entire day. Once I install my second fan, it will probably be even less.
I am using twice as much energy to run T5's than my 3 radions BUT the extra $20 or worst case scenario $50 per month is worth it to me to have a good looking SPS tank.
T5's and MH are plug and play. 10 hour total photo period.
10 hour dusk and dawn channel 11am - 9pm
8 hour daylight channel 12pm - 8pm.
Everyone has their own preferences - this just happens to be mine.
One of the biggest features I enjoy more about T5's is that I can see my tank now. The DIM look was annoying me.
T5/MH is a "blanket" of light. Covers all portions of the tank. No shadowing.
LED's focus/spotlight energy down. Yes to shadowing.
On my 120 tech Tank 3/4 years ago I had an ATI 8x54 Power Module. I knew less then than I do now and growing corals was super easy for me. I also remember enjoying the hobby much more then than I did now simply because it was easier to be successful with T5.
If you are thinking about LED's than to be safe, install the widest angle optics possible. My radions that I sold had the 120 optics. They will give the new owner a much better chance of being successful than the years I had with the 90 degree optics.
LED are expensive but last a very long time.
My ultimate choice was about setting myself in my comfort zone. I was willing to take the financial hit of buying new EcoTech radions and then buying a new ATI fixture .. .. .. so I can enjoy the hobby like I once did.
Light penetration and PAR is awesome with an ATI light fixture. The 8 bulb is designed for 34/36 inch tank depths. I have these mounted 9 inches above the water line. My Tank is 27 inches tall. Perfect!
Keep it simple .. .. if it ain't broke!