I think this is what people mean by black PERCULA

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11264820#post11264820 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by criccio
be careful with that Rhodactis indosinensis (hairy mushroom), they're known clownfish eaters.

Yes they are; especially smaller clowns. I once rescued a small clown from one - I literally had to pry it open with my fingers to let the fish swim free. I don't think the little clown knew even then how close to death it was.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11250136#post11250136 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by OrionN
black-percula_146.jpg

That is what I call a very beautiful Black Perc

Hell hath frozen over. If ever there was ever a time that someone could use the term "black perc" and actually have it be correct, this is it. Now this is really gonna cause confusion in the world of clownfish...there is such thing as a "black perc", we have been wrong all along. :D The only problem is, she (or he?) is probably one of only a few to be found in the ocean.:(

That is an absolutely gorgeous fish. I don't make it over to rareclownfish so maybe my questions are already discussed over there. I am assuming that it is the only one of the pair like that? WC? Breeding? If so, what do the babies generally look like?
 
Like I said I have seen two pairs here (bangkok) just like that but did not have the funds or tank to get them next time...
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11271389#post11271389 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by adtravels
Like I said I have seen two pairs here (bangkok) just like that but did not have the funds or tank to get them next time...

Ahh, missed that response. Interesting. I wonder if it is just random or if there is a little pool somewhere out there of all black percs. $300 or so bucks doesn't really sound all that bad. I could only imagine what the price posted on LA Diver's Den would be for clowns that looked like that (and they would get snatched instantly).
 
I'm going to say that is not a black perc but a normal perc with more black. I obtained one a few yrs back. Black percs don't have orange fins.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11273763#post11273763 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ezcompany
gosh who cares it has enough black to be called a black perc its all subjective!

Black perc is a common name that people use to describe 3 different kinds of fish it doesnt matter how much black it has.

Isseym328 Black percs dont exist.... i know you know that but your post seems to indicate that there is in fact a Black perc.

This thread is leading to more confusion.:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
 
Oops. I was trying to get at the fact that the the fish is a true perc with more black, not that it IS a black perc. My mistake. Good catch.
 
black-percula_146.jpg

IMO, this fish have perfect bodyshape, beautiful Onyx A. percula. Even better than Rod's Onyx. I would love to get my hand on him/her and breed him with similar quality Onyx A. percula.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11274484#post11274484 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by OrionN
black-percula_146.jpg

IMO, this fish have perfect bodyshape, beautiful Onyx A. percula. Even better than Rod's Onyx. I would love to get my hand on him/her and breed him with similar quality Onyx A. percula.

I totally agree the body shape is the winner just looks perfect, My onyx and regular percs both have this shape, it makes it instantly easy to tell the difference between the Black( or as I would now like to call them "super onyx":rollface: :D :D ) percula and black ocellaris, polymnus dont even enter into the debate for me as they look, behave, swim differently. Although I konw that they are often sold as Black percs.
 
12258onyx1.JPG


This guy was solid black with white stripe except for a little part of one fin and the face. He was awsome. I wish I can get a pair of these super onyxs again.
 
Okay...did some homework...

You guys are right (not that there was any doubt, eh? :lol: )...my baby black clown fish is a 'true black percula' which is A. ocellaris...

Mostly a case of 'name confusion'...whoever called it a 'perc' in the first place needs to whipped with a wet noodle...or a wet anemone...

...I would've preferred to try another pair of A. percula, but now that I have the black A. ocellaris...I went back to the reef store...they had one lonely orange A. ocellaris left...so I brought him home too!

...and guess what surprise I found in my tank when I came home with the new fish?

My black ocellaris has adopted the GTBA....woohoo! That was the whole point of getting the reef tank...so I could have my own clownfish/anemone pairing! CUTE!!!

Then I had to run the kids to their activities...just got back in the house and ran to check on the new guy...

and guess where HE is???

IN THE ANEMONE!!!! Hahahahaha!

So the black guy is going strong in the front of the anemone and the the orange guy was hiding behind and underneath it...

Hope the anemone is up for it! I'm not too worried...it's looked good since I got it...eats very well...and the tips have 'bubbled' too...

I'm keeping my fingers crossed that all's still well come morning!
 
Last edited:
...hmm...honeymoon's over...Mr. Black is chasing Mr. Orange (wonder who's gonna be the girl when they sort themselves out?).
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11292589#post11292589 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Rue
...still no signs of 'em kissin' and makin' up...:rollface:

that comes months later, my females still chase the males away from the nem sometimes.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11275098#post11275098 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by adtravels
I totally agree the body shape is the winner just looks perfect, My onyx and regular percs both have this shape, it makes it instantly easy to tell the difference between the Black( or as I would now like to call them "super onyx":rollface: :D :D ) percula and black ocellaris, polymnus dont even enter into the debate for me as they look, behave, swim differently. Although I konw that they are often sold as Black percs.
I see my black perc has been in the news lately :p

This variant is marketed by my wholesaler here as black perculas, with a markup to match. Because the term is also used for a number of other clownfish, I think it's best to avoid it. Superonyx sounds nice :D

For those of you who are wondering....here's his daughter (hopefully! When she starts to breed, I will swap the pairs out and do some inbreeding to try to fix things a little)
645-Junior26Oct06.jpg
 
Marinebetta,
Can you give us a picture of her mother? Do you intend to do line breeding or inbreeding her with another sibling?
 
Back
Top