PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay I'm in the planning stages for the fish going into QT in a few weeks. The tank is a 120G mixed reef tank with mostly SPS and LPS. Still cycling from an upgrade from a 55G. 30G sump, G2 skimmer, running carbon and GFO after cycle.

Here's my list in probable order of addition.

Green chromis
Tank raised bangai cardinal
Neon Goby
Pair of clowns
Whip fin fairy wrasse
Line spot flasher wrasse
Bartlets anthias
Royal gramma
Kole tang
Mandarin after a 1 year maturity of tank and seeding of pods.

Bio load okay? Thanks!
 
Okay I'm in the planning stages for the fish going into QT in a few weeks. The tank is a 120G mixed reef tank with mostly SPS and LPS. Still cycling from an upgrade from a 55G. 30G sump, G2 skimmer, running carbon and GFO after cycle.

Here's my list in probable order of addition.

Green chromis
Tank raised bangai cardinal
Neon Goby
Pair of clowns
Whip fin fairy wrasse
Line spot flasher wrasse
Bartlets anthias
Royal gramma
Kole tang
Mandarin after a 1 year maturity of tank and seeding of pods.

Bio load okay? Thanks!

Bioload is fine, only behavioral consideration is the the Whip fin fairy wrasse which can be aggressive; you have various prolific jumpers so you will need a tightly closed top with 1/4 inch holes
 
Bioload is fine, only behavioral consideration is the the Whip fin fairy wrasse which can be aggressive; you have various prolific jumpers so you will need a tightly closed top with 1/4 inch holes

Would a filamented or a similar flasher wrasse be more compatible and less aggressive?
 
My QT has been cycling for 4 weeks and my display tank has been cycling for 1 week. I'm getting close to making my first purchase and I want to make sure my wish list is okay to become a stock list.

Display tank is a standard 120 gallon 4'x2'x2' that I just put 1/4" mesh on today the rest of the details or in my signature.

The following list are in approximate introduction order.

The list of fish I would really like:
1 or 2 bonded or mated pair of Firefish (Nemateleotris magnifica)
Seems like the only way to get a pair is to buy 2 and hope or buy a bunch and hope 2 find each other and return the ones that survive.
So if I get lucky in the next few weeks and find a pair I will get a pair but most likely it will be 1.
1 - 2 (MF) Orange Stripe Prawn Goby (Amblyeleotris randalli)
Want to attempt to pair with pistol shrimp
1 - Midas Blenny (Ecsenius midas)
1 - Carberryi Anthias (Nemanthias carberryi) swimmer
1(M) or 3 (MFF) Carpenter's Flasher Wrasse (Paracheilinus carpenteri)
Hard to find females and almost impossible to find a harem so again probably only one.
1 (M) or 2 (MF) ( mated ) Green Mandarin (Synchiropus splendidus)
Will add after my tank matures
Will I be able to support 2?

Selection of optional fish:
1 Tanaka's Pygmy Wrasse (Wetmorella tanakai)
1 Yellow Assesor ( Assessor flavissimus )
1 Orange-Back Fairy Wrasse (Cirrhilabrus aurantidorsalis)
1 Lineatus Fairy Wrasse (Cirrhilabrus lineatus)
1 Blue/Green Reef Chromis (Chromis viridis)
1 Kole Tang (Ctenochaetus strigosus ) or 1 Starry Blenny (Salarias ramosus)
Share the same ecological niche so one or the other
Concerned about the Tang making the tank look small and aggression issues

I want to keep multiple species of shrimp, the standard all snail COC, 1 or more Clam(s), and SPS coral

How far off am I on stocking? How many of my optional fish can I add?

Thanks for the incredible service you are providing here.
 
My QT has been cycling for 4 weeks and my display tank has been cycling for 1 week. I'm getting close to making my first purchase and I want to make sure my wish list is okay to become a stock list.

Display tank is a standard 120 gallon 4'x2'x2' that I just put 1/4" mesh on today the rest of the details or in my signature.

The following list are in approximate introduction order.

The list of fish I would really like:
1 or 2 bonded or mated pair of Firefish (Nemateleotris magnifica)
Seems like the only way to get a pair is to buy 2 and hope or buy a bunch and hope 2 find each other and return the ones that survive.

Actually, you keep the ones that survive. However, the odds are against. Best chance for two is to purchase two that are "hanging out together" and hope that they bond. However this will take a few months. In salt water, it is difficult to get most fish to work as pairs. There are a few exceptions, but this is slightly more advanced concept.
So if I get lucky in the next few weeks and find a pair I will get a pair but most likely it will be 1.
1 - 2 (MF) Orange Stripe Prawn Goby (Amblyeleotris randalli)
Want to attempt to pair with pistol shrimp You can get one prawn goby and two pistol shrimp, but a pair of prawn gobies is unlikely to work and will only work if it is a male plus female.
1 - Midas Blenny (Ecsenius midas)
1 - Carberryi Anthias (Nemanthias carberryi) swimmer
1(M) or 3 (MFF) Carpenter's Flasher Wrasse (Paracheilinus carpenteri)
Hard to find females and almost impossible to find a harem so again probably only one.
1 (M) or 2 (MF) ( mated ) Green Mandarin (Synchiropus splendidus)
Will add after my tank matures
Will I be able to support 2? It should, but be sure you are getting a male and female and introduce the female first; females are often difficult to acquire because they are brought in less frequently because they are not as vibrant coloration

Selection of optional fish:
1 Tanaka's Pygmy Wrasse (Wetmorella tanakai) excellent fish
1 Yellow Assesor ( Assessor flavissimus )
1 Orange-Back Fairy Wrasse (Cirrhilabrus aurantidorsalis)
1 Lineatus Fairy Wrasse (Cirrhilabrus lineatus) I would only do one fairy wrasse given the number of other fish
1 Blue/Green Reef Chromis (Chromis viridis) I would skip as they often come in less than healthy
1 Kole Tang (Ctenochaetus strigosus ) or 1 Starry Blenny (Salarias ramosus) you cannot have two blennies
Share the same ecological niche so one or the other
Concerned about the Tang making the tank look small and aggression issues no, one Ctenochaetus tang should be fine

I want to keep multiple species of shrimp, the standard all snail COC, 1 or more Clam(s), and SPS coral a function of flow and lighting but that is beyond the scope of this thread which is only marine fish compatibility

How far off am I on stocking? How many of my optional fish can I add? since you are doing small fish, you should be fine behaviorally and from the respect of bioload, although that is getting up there.

Thanks for the incredible service you are providing here.

always a pleasure
 
Yes. However the optimal would be one or more female of the male flasher wrasse.

Thank you very much! Glad my stocking list didn't have too many issues. What a great service this thread is. I've always bought what caught my eye and thew it in the tank without proper research or guidance. This will be there first truly planned tank I've done so thank you for the help again!
 
Thank you very much! Glad my stocking list didn't have too many issues. What a great service this thread is. I've always bought what caught my eye and thew it in the tank without proper research or guidance. This will be there first truly planned tank I've done so thank you for the help again!

Always a pleasure. The problem with the catching one's eye strategy, is a lot of the very interesting fish often get too large or have behavioral characteristics which do not mesh with existing tank mates. That is one of the primary reasons for this thread which is going on 6000 responses.
 
I would like to get a school of Anthias. What is recommended? I have about $200 for it, but I really don't know which is most compatible with me system. What info do you need from me to get a better idea?
 
I would like to get a school of Anthias. What is recommended? I have about $200 for it, but I really don't know which is most compatible with me system. What info do you need from me to get a better idea?

In your sized tank they will not "school" but they may aggregate to a degree and shoal. Keep in mind that anthias do best with multiple feedings per day. Your budget should be sufficient for about 3-5 with the ones I would choose being carberryi or replendent.
 
Hello Steve,

Would like to get your opinion on keeping two chromis of different species. I would like to add a C. atripectoralis and a C. cyaneus at some point, but was not sure if they would fight. I know multiple chromis of the same species will whittle themselves down to one or two, but what about distinct species? Below is the rest of my stocking list (tank specs in sig):

Current:
Firefish (N. magnifica)
Bicolor Blenny (E. bicolor)
(2) Ocellaris Clowns (A. ocellaris)
McCosker's Flasher Wrasse (P. mccoskeri)

Planned:
Blackaxil Chromis (C. atripectoralis)
Blue Reef Chromis (C. cyaneus)
Kaudern's Cardinal (P. kauderni)
Orchid Dottyback (P. fridmani)
One-spot Foxface (S. unimaculatus)
Kole's Tang (C. strigosus)
 
Hello Steve,

Would like to get your opinion on keeping two chromis of different species. I would like to add a C. atripectoralis and a C. cyaneus at some point, but was not sure if they would fight.

singles should not

I know multiple chromis of the same species will whittle themselves down to one or two, but what about distinct species? Below is the rest of my stocking list (tank specs in sig):

Current:
Firefish (N. magnifica)
Bicolor Blenny (E. bicolor)
(2) Ocellaris Clowns (A. ocellaris)
McCosker's Flasher Wrasse (P. mccoskeri)

Planned:
Blackaxil Chromis (C. atripectoralis)
Blue Reef Chromis (C. cyaneus)
Kaudern's Cardinal (P. kauderni)
Orchid Dottyback (P. fridmani) may be aggressive towards flash wrasses although P. fridmani is one of the least aggressive Pseudochromis
One-spot Foxface (S. unimaculatus)
Kole's Tang (C. strigosus)
 
As always...thank you! I'm still debating the P. fridmani; may go with a Gramma melacara instead. I like the fact that P. fridmani are available as tank-bred, though.
 
Last edited:
OK I'm back, tank is still cycling but I want to check on the family wish list before we start shopping...
picture.php
picture.php


55 gallon display with 29 gallon sump. Chaeto in sump. Water temp is 80 right note with salinity around 1.025.

Birds nest coral
Blue mushroom
Christmas tree coral
Frogspawn coral
Lavender and red mushroom
Purple gorgonian

*Black and white ocellaris clown pair
Dracula goby
Fire fish
Helfrichi fire fish
Purple fire fish
*Flame angel
*Green mandarin
*Mccoskers flasher wrasse
*Orchid dottyback
*Fire shrimp
Radiant wrasse

I feel like that's too much and we want *anemone, *cleanup crew, *maxi clam, *starfish, emerald crab, *feather dusters and *urchins...

I'll star the most desired ones, but we are still considering what for sure we want...

Your comments on how these would go together are appreciated.

Thank you
 
OK I'm back, tank is still cycling but I want to check on the family wish list before we start shopping...
55 gallon display with 29 gallon sump. Chaeto in sump. Water temp is 80 right note with salinity around 1.025.

nice aquascaping!

Birds nest coral
Blue mushroom
Christmas tree coral
Frogspawn coral
Lavender and red mushroom
Purple gorgonian

*Black and white ocellaris clown pair
Dracula goby long term success with this fish has been limited
Fire fish one fire fish only, introduce early
Helfrichi fire fish see above
Purple fire fish see above
*Flame angel
*Green mandarin marginal in this sized tank unless you add a refugium and it has matured
*Mccoskers flasher wrasse
*Orchid dottyback P. fridmani, especially in small tanks, may take issue with flasher wrasses or firefish
*Fire shrimp
Radiant wrasse needs a larger tank

I feel like that's too much and we want *anemone, *cleanup crew, *maxi clam, *starfish, emerald crab, *feather dusters and *urchins...

I'll star the most desired ones, but we are still considering what for sure we want...

Your comments on how these would go together are appreciated.

Thank you
 
Wow thanks, I kinda figured on some of that, but very glad to know the list need only slightly be modified.

And thanks for the comment on the aquascaping.
 
OK revised to ensure I understood your comments...


Birds nest coral
Blue mushroom
Christmas tree coral
Frogspawn coral
Lavender and red mushroom
Purple gorgonian

*Black and white ocellaris clown pair
Fire fish
*Flame angel
*Green mandarin
*Mccoskers flasher wrasse
Neon goby
*Fire shrimp

*anemone, *cleanup crew, *maxi clam, *starfish, emerald crab, *feather dusters and *urchins...


Now counting the inverts and corals etc... Is this an appropriate bio-load?

Your comments on how these would go together are appreciated.

Again
Thank you
 
OK revised to ensure I understood your comments...


Birds nest coral
Blue mushroom
Christmas tree coral
Frogspawn coral
Lavender and red mushroom
Purple gorgonian

*Black and white ocellaris clown pair
Fire fish
*Flame angel
*Green mandarin remember this would need a producing refugium for success
*Mccoskers flasher wrasse
Neon goby
*Fire shrimp

*anemone, *cleanup crew, *maxi clam, *starfish, emerald crab, *feather dusters and *urchins...


Now counting the inverts and corals etc... Is this an appropriate bio-load?

Fish count towards bioload and should be fine

Your comments on how these would go together are appreciated.

this thread is only about marine fish compatibility, but I am sure you can get lots of opinions in a separate thread.

Again
Thank you
 
75 g DT with 29g sump.

Current stock:
1 banggai Cardinal
2 black clowns
1 kole tang
1 labout's fairy wrasse
1 YWG with tiger shrimp

was thinking of adding either a Midas Blenny or a red head solon fairy wrasse

Your thoughts would be appreciated.

Thank you
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top