recommendation on calcium reactor

josh.vince

Premium Member
I'm thinking of adding one to my system. I don't want to go the cheap route and end up with something I'm not happy with or doesn't work well.

Can anyone who has a calcium reactor give me some tips based upon their experiences?

Thanks!
Josh
 
Ca reactors might seem complicated to those unfamiliar with them but they're not. They can be a PITA to dial in at first HOWEVER once "dialed in" they can maintain your levels of Ca and alkalinity for a long period of time with no daily dosing hassles. You might want to monitor pH when using a reactor- a reactor uses CO2 to lower pH to "melt" aragonite in it's chamber in order to supply Ca and alkalinity. If the pH drops too low the reactor media can turn to mush. Reactors are a good choice for large tanks with high Ca/alk demands.
 
My Geo is very easy to maintain. Gary and a few other guys helped me get dialed in. Not as intimidating to run as I first suspected. A piece of cake really.
 
You need a regulator (with solenoid if you use a probe and controller) CO2 bottle, the reactor, a feed pump, mine uses an mj1200 and a circulator pump, my reactor came with a blue line 30x. that's about it as far as I can recall.
 
watch the used forums. check online. you could also check w/ Tim at ABC reefs, he might be able to get you a deal.
 
Anyone have some good article links for "Calcium Reactors 101"? I've read a few, but don't quite understand how people control the dissolution and addition of the aragonite.

(Hope I'm not hijacking, Josh!)

Thanks!
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12657805#post12657805 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Conesus_Kid
Anyone using a Ca reactor in conjunction w/ Kalkwasser? This may be the route I go w/ the school aquarium.
I would guess this is what the majority of people owning Ca reactors do. Dissolution rate of media is controlled by flow rate of effluent and bubble count (ie: pH inside chamber). Addition of aragonite is made manually when media in chamber gets too low- unscrew the top of the chamber and re-load 'er :D
 
I use a calcium reactor( a kr2 I think ) Bought it used about a year and a half ago. I run it 24/7. I have not touched the settings since set up.
The calcium reactor alone even if properly set will still produce effluent in the 6.7 to 6.8 range. This can lower ph in the system and many who use them have persistent low ph in the 7.8 range. Corals can work in this if alkalinity is high. However, you could be flirting with 7.6 or 7.7. The low ph and CO2 that comes with it can spur cyano problems.etc.
I also dose limewater(kalk) for top off at night. It has a high ph of about 12.4 and will grab up CO2,as it forms calcium carbonate.
The 2 balance each other very well. My ph is steady at 8.22 low and 8.35 high point on any given day. Also by using the two sources, I don't have to push the calcium reactor very hard or tinker with it. I can always reduce the amount of limewater more easily if necessary in case the calcium and alkalinity are too high or use a little calcium chloride and carbonate aka2 part if it's too low. I have not had to take either of these steps in over a year.

People set the calcium reactors up in two different ways.
One is to use a controller to maintain the effluent ph, turning the flow of CO2 on and off with a controller.
I do it the other way.
First, set the effluent flow per manufacturer's recommendation for the unit. Do this before turning on the CO2.You attach a small pump/powerhead and adjust the amount of effluent by dialing a valve on the effluent output line(usually a piece or large airline tubing) to your sump. This step takes a measuring cup to catch the effleuent , a clock to time it and a little math to multiply it out instead of gathering effluent for and hour per setting to get litres or gph. Once you have it, let it run for a day and recheck. If it's good, you are ready to set the effluent ph.
You do this by turning on the CO2 supply and adjusting the amount of CO2 entering the water that will pass through the media by turning the needle valve attached to the CO2 regulator. You can get a general idea of CO2 volume by timing the bubbles(one bubble every e 2 or 3 or 4 sec,eg) in the bubble counter which is just a clear tube where the bubbles are visible. After a couple of hours catch some effluent in a cup and check the ph. When you settle it out at 6.7 or 6.8, you are set.Now let it run and leave it alone.
Recheck you effluent flow and effluent ph a few times over the next week and you should be all set.
A controller should be installed between the regulator and the input line for CO2 to the reactor. The controller is a ph monitor with a probe and a solenoid which will turn off and close off the CO2 supply when the ph drops too low in the system which is where I put the probe ansd not in the effluent.. In this way if there is excess CO2 for some unforseen reason the CO2 will be shut down when the ph in the aquarium reaches a preset low point (eg 8.0).

New media can be added when about half empty. Unless the media in your reactor is very muddy you can just put new media on top of the old.

A couple of other points. The effluent tube for the callcium reactor should be kept several inches out of the water to allow it to blow off excess CO2. It is also good to let it drip near the skimmer intake, since the skimmer will also oxygenate.

Good Luck
 
Thanks, guys. I think I've got a pretty good understanding of it. Is it possible to "overdose" when using a Ca reactor and get a precipitation event? I would imagine you'd start with a low effluent rate and then slowly adjust upwards after checking each day.

Anyone using the Coralife brand of Ca reactor? They seem to be priced significantly lower than most.
 
Yes it is possible to overdose and drop ph increasing CO2 to unaccepotable levels. I don't think it will precipitate since that requires high ph.
 
I've got a used Calcium Reactor, if someone is looking for one.

I picked it up from someone in Rochester a couple years ago. It has been running on my 265 tank, but ever since I added a couple more tanks to that same sump, the reactor has not been able to keep up.

Its a Korallin C1502 Calcium Reactor with Eheim pump.
Here's some info on it.
http://www.marinedepot.com/ps_ViewI...s-Calcium_Reactors-Reactor_Alone~vendor~.html

It still works fine and even has some media left in it.

First 100.00 takes it.
 
Last edited:
I use a large dual chambered CA reactor for my system. When I had many SPS colonies in my 120, the CA reactor was unable to keep up with both CA and ALK. I had to add pelladow by the cupfull into my system to keep CA in check, and add baking soda by the cupfull to keep ALK in check.

Instead of using a maxijet to pump water into (and out of) the reactor, I simply submerge my reactor in my sump. This will suck sump water through the reactor without using an extra 20w of electricity for the maxijet. (It works because of the action of the circulation pump, a mag 2). Submerging the reactor also prevents problems from leaks.... it can leak all it wants...

Throughout the years, my reactor has been nothing but a major PITA... however, recently I rebuilt it and I also no longer have an SPS dominated tank. The reactor seems to work well for me now...

Buy a used reactor, you'll save a lot of money...

Steve
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12660567#post12660567 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Conesus_Kid
Thanks, guys. I think I've got a pretty good understanding of it. Is it possible to "overdose" when using a Ca reactor and get a precipitation event?
it's very possible to "overdose" using a reactor but like tmz posted you won't likely see precipitation but you might see calcification.... of everything. (Ever see a calcified sponge filter?) If you don't control your reactor you can turn a sponge filter (or anything in your system for that matter) into a cement block.
 
I have a Korallin C1502 Calcium Reactor with Eheim pump and I think they work great! I really like calcium reactors personally...
 
I lke mine but I don't view it as the calcium/alkalinity driver on the 500g system. It is more of a compliment to the limewater(kalk) dosing . It's also a good CO2 doser for the kalk better than adding vinegar or seltzer.
 
old thread bump

old thread bump

Randy- I seem to recall you mentioning a certain brand of calcium reactor that you preferred over others for ease of re-loading, use, etc. etc.

What was it?
 
Back
Top