Anyone with long term success keeping a Bandit Angel in a mixed reef?

[nuxx]

Hey everyone,

Starting to look at fish to add for our next round of personal QT.

One of the fish I'm looking at is a Bandit Angel (Apolemichthys arcuatus).

The goal of our display is a mixed reef with sps, lps and polyps.

Just curious if anyone has had any success keeping a Bandit long term in a mixed reef.

If so, any tips?

If not, what's on the menu?

Thanks :beer:

 

[RDtrack]

I've currently have a juvenile bandit so not much experience with one in a mixed reef.

However all my angels are in a reef tank with mostly softies. For the most part they leave everything alone.

I would be more worried if the corals can handle the water temp that most bandits like having. Mid to low 70 degrees.

The age old debate of corals like higher Temps and fish are better kept at lower Temps.

I think with a fish like a bandit you have to say are the corals more important to you or the fish. The question everyone should ask with angels.

For a bandit its more about the fish.

Also on advice I'd try to get one around 2 inches.

My current lady is less than an inch. She seems fine but I skipped Qt because I was worried about food. She definitely is feeding mostly on the live rock.

Good luck #2 on my angel list.

 

[nuxx]

I've currently have a juvenile bandit so not much experience with one in a mixed reef.

However all my angels are in a reef tank with mostly softies. For the most part they leave everything alone.

I would be more worried if the corals can handle the water temp that most bandits like having. Mid to low 70 degrees. The

The age old debate of corals like higher Temps and fish are better kept at lower Temps.

Thanks for the input

Running ~ 78 degrees for our Crosshatches, they've been pretty happy.

Hopefully that temp will be OK for a Bandit. Coral seem to be fine with the temp.

 

[RDtrack]

Thanks for the input

Running ~ 78 degrees for our Crosshatches, they've been pretty happy.

Hopefully that temp will be OK for a Bandit. Coral seem to be fine with the temp.

That's the reason I like purchasing juvenile angels yes they are a pain since they are so small but if you can raise them in your tank I think environmental concerns are less as they get older.

Not use to eating a particular food or water temp.

Also from my research bandits seem to not be prone to nip at corals.

One thing I've noticed that's different with the baby bandit than my other baby angels is that she does a lot more swimming in open water. My other baby angels didn't leave the rocks that often.

Good luck beautiful fish

 

[nuxx]

That's the reason I like purchasing juvenile angels yes they are a pain since they are so small but if you can raise them in your tank I think environmental concerns are less as they get older.

Not use to eating a particular food or water temp.

Also from my research bandits seem to not be prone to nip at corals.

One thing I've noticed that's different with the baby bandit than my other baby angels is that she does a lot more swimming in open water. My other baby angels didn't leave the rocks that often.

Good luck beautiful fish

Would definitely like to try a smaller fish if possible.

I've seen how active those tiny Bandits seem to be :thumbsup:

 

[bullitr]

I have mine for over a year maybe 2 years
On mixed reef , Temp raise up to 80 no problem. 81 it reduce its feeding since that too hot for it. Crosshatch juvenile pair maybe 3 years no issue with temp

 

[nuxx]

I have mine for over a year maybe 2 years
On mixed reef , Temp raise up to 80 no problem. 81 it reduce its feeding since that too hot for it. Crosshatch juvenile pair maybe 3 years no issue with temp

Awesome thanks

How large was the Bandit when you got it?

What corals are in your tank?

Sorry for all the questions :sad2:

 

[WayneL333]

I've had a trio for awhile with mostly SPS and A couple lps and a large clam. Mine like to mouth the corals every once in awhile but have never killed anything. The problem is is I have almost no PE which I makes a SPS dominate tank even less animate!

They were around 2" when I received them.

Here's a link to my tank thread. There are videos of them in it.

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2377665

 

[nuxx]

I've had a trio for awhile with mostly SPS and A couple lps and a large clam. Mine like to mouth the corals every once in awhile but have never killed anything. The problem is is I have almost no PE which I makes a SPS dominate tank even less animate!

They were around 2" when I received them.

Here's a link to my tank thread. There are videos of them in it.

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2377665

Hey Wayne thanks a ton.

Do you think the lack of PE is from being bothered by the angels?

BTW: Stunning Personatus!

 

[ca1ore]

The problem is is I have almost no

Not a bandit chez moi, but I'm convinced my lack of PE is a result of my two dwarf Angels. Same corals in my attached fish less frag tank show lots of PE.

 

[bullitr]

Anyone with long term success keeping a Bandit Angel in a mixed reef?

Awesome thanks



How large was the Bandit when you got it?



What corals are in your tank?



Sorry for all the questions :sad2:

SPS
LPS
Softies
Anemone

No clams, no zoa





Bandit doesn't eat corals

 

[nuxx]

Not a bandit chez moi, but I'm convinced my lack of PE is a result of my two dwarf Angels. Same corals in my attached fish less frag tank show lots of PE.

Which dwarf angels?

Was also considering a Potter's at some point...

 

[nuxx]

SPS
LPS
Softies
Anemone

No clams, no zoa

Awesome thanks. Have Zoas, no softies or clams though.

 

[ca1ore]

Which dwarf angels?

Was also considering a Potter's at some point...

Flame and a Potters.

 

[nuxx]

Flame and a Potters.

Have they totally destroyed anything, or just aggravating certain corals?

 

[nonimmigrant]

Mine has not bothered my corals (LPS or SPS) and I actually do have good PE for the most part. Mine's housed now with C. multifasciatus, C. aurantia and a host of wrasses, anthias, etc. I did tho have to get rid of my AT as they were continuously "having words".

 

[nuxx]

Mine has not bothered my corals (LPS or SPS) and I actually do have good PE for the most part. Mine's housed now with C. multifasciatus, C. aurantia and a host of wrasses, anthias, etc. I did tho have to get rid of my AT as they were continuously "having words".

Thanks!

AT = Achilles Tang?

 

[nonimmigrant]

Thanks!

AT = Achilles Tang?

Yeah... It's actually the first time in 10 yrs that I've not had a tang in the tank. Wife loves it. I'm staging an argument for a Mrs. Bandit lol.

 

[Dmorty217]

Mrs bandit and a juv AT!

 

[nuxx]

Yeah... It's actually the first time in 10 yrs that I've not had a tang in the tank. Wife loves it. I'm staging an argument for a Mrs. Bandit lol.

LOL why does your wife hate tangs so much?