PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

Status
Not open for further replies.
65g with 20g sump currently have:

YWG with Randall's shrimp
Mated Percula pair
Firefish
Redspot Cardinalfish
Halichoeres Biocellatus
Linespot Flasher Wrasse
McCoskers Flasher Wrasse

Right now everyone gets along well and my parameters are good.

The LFS has some Paracheilinus Attenuatus and it's tempting to get just one more wrasse is this too much?

marginal in this tank size
 
125 gallon with 45 gallon sump. Lot's of live rock and two inch sand bed. Temperature would be kept at 72 - 74 range. Corals would be sps, mainly deepwater acroporas.

centre piece would be chaetodon declivis (deepwater species) 3x

I have read, that they like the precense of dither fish, so have been thinking of adding zoramia leptacantha 30x or pseudanthia parvirostris (deepwater species) / nemathias carberryi 10x (1 male, 9 female).

Are these really considered as a dither fish? Suggestions?

Valenciannea puellaris (for keeping the sandbed clean, though is this necessary?) or opistognathus rosenblatti.

Elacatinus oceanops, for parasite eating.

CUC:

Lysmata amboinensis
hermit crabs (have lot's of empty shells of different sizes)
snails
strombus spp.

Any other suggestions for stocking? ��
 
125 gallon with 45 gallon sump. Lot's of live rock and two inch sand bed. Temperature would be kept at 72 - 74 range. Corals would be sps, mainly deepwater acroporas.

centre piece would be chaetodon declivis (deepwater species) 3x

I have kept and love chaetodon declivis but I have never heard that they require a dither fish. My experience is they are out and about without issue, but I kept one in a 350 gallon mixed reef with acropora and montipora

I have read, that they like the precense of dither fish, so have been thinking of adding zoramia leptacantha 30x or pseudanthia parvirostris (deepwater species) / nemathias carberryi 10x (1 male, 9 female).

I have kept nemathias carberryi but you should know they do best with multiple feedings per day. I am not a big fan of cardinal fish except apogon parvulus as the remainder tend to pair off and are more active at night.

Are these really considered as a dither fish? Suggestions?

Valenciannea puellaris (for keeping the sandbed clean not necessary , though is this necessary?) or opistognathus rosenblatti. needs cooler temperature (the low end of your range), peaceful tank mates, and a deeper sand bed mixed with some rock rubble.

Elacatinus oceanops, for parasite eating. They don't really eat parasites. Some fish enjoy being cleaned, however.

CUC:

Lysmata amboinensis
hermit crabs (have lot's of empty shells of different sizes)
snails
strombus spp.

Any other suggestions for stocking? ��
 

Thanks for the advice!

As you have also kept chaetodon declivis, do you think I could later add one or two chaetodon mitratus in the tank? I have read mixed opinions about mixing roaops species together.

thanks for advance
 
Thanks for the advice!

As you have also kept chaetodon declivis, do you think I could later add one or two chaetodon mitratus in the tank? I have read mixed opinions about mixing roaops species together.

thanks for advance

I have also kept chaetodon mitratus which is a much more outgoing fish. However I have never tried both together.
 
I need your advice on this livestock for a 75 gallon DT (with a 30 gallon sump). This is my first tank, so I am still trying to get a feel on how much of a biomass the system can handle!

I have tried to get a variety of body types and colors for a nice tank. I also tried to get a good mix of those that hang out by the sand bed, those that hover over rock work, and those that swim in the water column. For coral, my goal is to have few corals but let them grow large "” that's what I find appealing.

Also, I am going to post this on two forums and send it to a few friends in email "” so if you see this more than once, I apologize. (Unless you are on of my friends "” in which case you have my sincere sympathies.)

Okay:

Fish:

Mandarin Dragnet (note: this won't be purchased for a year after the DT is up and running "” but this is the only fish I truly want "” so if I have to cut back on the bio load it WON'T be this one)
Starcki Damselfish
Firefish x2 (this is the only fish where I intend to get more than one "” until I get feedback to this message)
Red Hat Solon Fairy Wrasse (note: if this guy eats pods then he's out "” they're for the mandarin)
gold stripe maroon clownfish

Corals:

Open Brain Coral
Starburst Polyp
Cauliflower Colt Coral
Toadstool Mushroom Leather
Mushroom Rock Rhodactis

Inverts:

Blood shrimp
Blue leg and red leg hermit crabs
peppermint shrimp
skunk cleaner shrimp

Note: I didn't add any snails because I've heard too many horror stories about them breeding like rabbits on viagra. If you can recommend snails that don't have that problem then please let me know. (Or if you think the hassle is worth their benefit.)

Thanks for your feedback!
 
21 gallon Nanocube.

Current:
2 Ocellaris Clownfish
1 skunk cleaner shrimp
1 peppermint shrimp

Small CuC

Want:
I am wanting to add either a Cardinal and a purple firefish, or a purple firefish and a red firefish.

Thoughts? Concerns with adding either of the two pairs mentioned above. I will do one or the other, more leaning fire and cardinal. I will also be adding a goby of some type, have not decided yet.
 
21 gallon Nanocube.

Current:
2 Ocellaris Clownfish
1 skunk cleaner shrimp
1 peppermint shrimp

Small CuC

Want:
I am wanting to add either a Cardinal and a purple firefish, or a purple firefish and a red firefish.

Thoughts? Concerns with adding either of the two pairs mentioned above. I will do one or the other, more leaning fire and cardinal. I will also be adding a goby of some type, have not decided yet.

Your tank is barely large enough for a pair of clownfish. Adding additional fish would be undesirable.
 
I need your advice on this livestock for a 75 gallon DT (with a 30 gallon sump). This is my first tank, so I am still trying to get a feel on how much of a biomass the system can handle!

I have tried to get a variety of body types and colors for a nice tank. I also tried to get a good mix of those that hang out by the sand bed, those that hover over rock work, and those that swim in the water column. For coral, my goal is to have few corals but let them grow large "” that's what I find appealing.

Also, I am going to post this on two forums and send it to a few friends in email "” so if you see this more than once, I apologize. (Unless you are on of my friends "” in which case you have my sincere sympathies.)

Okay:

Fish:

Mandarin Dragnet (note: this won't be purchased for a year after the DT is up and running "” but this is the only fish I truly want "” so if I have to cut back on the bio load it WON'T be this one)
Starcki Damselfish
Firefish x2 (this is the only fish where I intend to get more than one "” until I get feedback to this message) only one firefish will survive long term
Red Hat Solon Fairy Wrasse (note: if this guy eats pods then he's out "” they're for the mandarin)
gold stripe maroon clownfish very aggressive, especially in this sized tank

Corals:

Open Brain Coral
Starburst Polyp
Cauliflower Colt Coral
Toadstool Mushroom Leather
Mushroom Rock Rhodactis can eat fish

Inverts:

Blood shrimp
Blue leg and red leg hermit crabs
peppermint shrimp
skunk cleaner shrimp

snails will not "breed like rabbits on viagra" but hermits will kill snails; I would go with snails not hermits

Note: I didn't add any snails because I've heard too many horror stories about them breeding like rabbits on viagra. If you can recommend snails that don't have that problem then please let me know. (Or if you think the hassle is worth their benefit.)

Thanks for your feedback!
 
Steve, thanks for the advice! I hadn't realized that the coral ate fish!

Why do you prefer snails over hermit crabs?

If I got rid of the wrasse and only had one Firefish, how do you think that bioload would be for a 75? Think it could handle more? Already too much? Fine as is?
 
Steve, thanks for the advice! I hadn't realized that the coral ate fish!

Why do you prefer snails over hermit crabs? You can get snails with a variety of capabilities whereas hermits are sort of single dimensional

If I got rid of the wrasse and only had one Firefish, how do you think that bioload would be for a 75? Think it could handle more? Already too much? Fine as is?

It is not a bioload issue, it is behavioral. If I were reducing, I would start with the GSM first, damsel second. But those are behavioral issues rather than bioload issues.
 
Good Evening Folks!, This is just a quick update on an earlier list that I had, please let me know what you think and in what order I should introduce them. I have a biocube 29, it's been running for 1 month now Bare bottom. It is stock, except for I took the bio balls out, and I didnt bother putting the filter in. Ive been doing a 10% WC weekly and havent missed one yet. Currently I have a small Colt coral, 2 skunk shrimp, and 3 Turbos (I had an algae issue and the LFS recommended 3 but I didnt realize how fast these guys actually work, I am currently trying dry seaweed sheets to supplement as my tank is super clean of algae now and I dont want this little guys to starve) Thanks in Advance!

1)Ocellaris Clownfish x 2
2)Firefish x1
3)banggai Cardinal x 2?
4)Royal Gamma x 1
5)Sailfin blenny x 1
6)manderin Blenny x1
7)trumpet coral
8)ricordea coral
 
Good Evening Folks!, This is just a quick update on an earlier list that I had, please let me know what you think and in what order I should introduce them. I have a biocube 29, it's been running for 1 month now Bare bottom. It is stock, except for I took the bio balls out, and I didnt bother putting the filter in. Ive been doing a 10% WC weekly and havent missed one yet. Currently I have a small Colt coral, 2 skunk shrimp, and 3 Turbos (I had an algae issue and the LFS recommended 3 but I didnt realize how fast these guys actually work, I am currently trying dry seaweed sheets to supplement as my tank is super clean of algae now and I dont want this little guys to starve) Thanks in Advance!

1)Ocellaris Clownfish x 2
2)Firefish x1
3)banggai Cardinal x 2?
4)Royal Gamma x 1
5)Sailfin blenny x 1 I suggest limiting tank mates to 4 fish from the above list.
6)manderin Blenny x1 These are dragonets not blennies and need a much larger, much more mature tank
7)trumpet coral
8)ricordea coral

Since this thread is only about marine fish compatibility, no opinions on the coral
 
Thanks Steve, I guess Ill go with the clownfish x 2 and banggai cardinal x 1 and firefish x x1...any particular order of intro duction? my guess is the clownfish first since they will be paired up
 
Thanks Steve, I guess Ill go with the clownfish x 2 and banggai cardinal x 1 and firefish x x1...any particular order of intro duction? my guess is the clownfish first since they will be paired up

firefish first, clownfish last
 
any particular order of intro duction? my guess is the clownfish first since they will be paired up

What I have done (for the tank that only exists in my dreams -- so take this with a grain of salt) is look up each fish on liveaquaria and go from nicest temperament to harshest -- so the nice guys can have the home court advantage when the meaner ones are introduced.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top