Bubble king 400 ext. VS Deltec AP 1004

D

Daniel_ber

New member
(I have a friend who is not a member here on RC, so I am asking this question on his behalf)

Which skimmer do you guys think I should use for a normal - high stocked 2100L system, and why?
Bubble king 400 - external, or Deltec AP 1004 (which I would feed with a Red dragon pump who is used for the Bubble king skimmers, and gives an output of 3000L/h, assuming that it is "possible")?

Please do NOT base your answer on the price, and only the skimmers quality etc. Imagine that the price is not an issue...

Thanks in advance and
Best Regards / Daniel

Note: 4.5 litres = 1 (Imperial) Gallon
 
If price is not an issue, BubbleKing is going to be an awesome skimmer for a 500 gallon. Deltec makes a very good skimmer, but the quality isn't on par with a BK.
 
Im thinking the same ap1004 or bk ext 400 . I dont get it how BK is better and only have 1 pump and deltec have 4 eheim pumps....

Thanks

David
 
Last edited:
The thing is that the Bubble King uses a titanium needle wheel which is top notch! And it creats very, very, small bubbles.

But what I dont get is how the BK could still be better if I would use the Red dragon pump with the same titanium needle wheel used for BK, to feed the AP 1004?
The Deltec AP 1004 has a total air intake of 2400l/h, and BK draws in about 2000l/h. The BK 400 is recommended for systems from 1500-4000L, while the AP 1004 is recommended for systems from 4500-6000L.

Is there anyone on RC who has had the both skimmers mentioned above?
I appreciate all the help I can get. I have read almost all sites I could find about these skimmes (the AP 1004, and the BK in general). But it is still very hard to choose one.
For now I think the probability is 60% AP 1004 and 40% BK 400.

Do you guys think that the BK 400 still would out skim the AP 1004 even if the AP 1004 would be feed with the red dragon pump and the titanium needle wheel?

Best Regards / Daniels friend.
 
Last edited:
dav99: you are probably right. But as I mentioned, even if there is a big difference I want to but the skimmer that can skim better. Regardless to the price.

By the way. which skimmer are you leaning to? And why? And how big will your tank/system be?

Best Regards
 
Im thinking about 500 gallons aprox.....is not for my current tank is for a future tank......... And price here does matter but i want to buy 1 skimmer in my life that can be the best.

I was thinking about the ap1004 with self cleaning head.....but people recomends the bk400....i know people with the deltec that is very happy but dont know anyone that use the bk.
 
I don't think the BK is using the titanium impellers anymore.

Maybe i misunder standing this runing the AP 1004 with Red Dragon pump?

Deltec are awesome skimmers, BUT the BK is better for a number of reasons, the pump (air volume, much lower watts, higher air to water ratio) is only one (or 3). The flow pattern insures max interface of air and water, the diffuser minimizes turbulence for max skimmate formation. plus other little reasons. I do like the self cleaning though. For me BK all the way.
 
Last edited:
"the pump (air volume, low watts, high air to water ratio) is only one"

Roland, here is the info I have about the BK 400:
For tanks from 1500 â€"œ 4000 L
2.000 L/H air intake and 4000 L/H Water input
Total hight : 80 cm. 68 Watt/h

The Ap 1004 use 4 x 1260 eheims. Which have a total output of 9600 L/H, total air intake: 2400L/H and they draw 65w/pump (but the high wattage is no problem assuming that it is/would be the best skimmer).

Conclusion for AP 1004:
For tanks from 4500 â€"œ 6000 L
2.400 L/H air intake and 9600 L/H Water input
Total hight : 98 cm. 260 Watt/h

Assuming that the info I have from the manufacturers are correct, the Deltec has a higher air intake and... well everything (including the negative point: almost 4 times higher energy consumption, which as mentioned dosn´t matter if it is a better skimmer).

The thing that keeps me from ordering the AP 1004 right now is the BK´s rumor, high air to water ratio and the extremly small bubbles that it is able to create.

2-0 in favour of BK. Which makes it that much harder to decide.
Well, I am back to 50% deltec and 50% BK =(

BTW, Roland, the reason for me wanting to use BK`s skimmer pump was becuase I have heard that the single most important thing with the BK skimmer is the modified pump.

You say that they dont use titanium impellers anymore, do you know what they are using now? And if it is better or worse, compared to the titanium one?

Best regards
 
Last edited:
I have a BK 300 skimmer and I am very happy with it. I would not purchased a proven product deltec, bubble King etc. and modify it by changing the pump. Each have been tested with that particular pump, why risk altering it.

You will be happy with either skimmer both are in the top category of skimmers. Self cleaning is nice though.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9278550#post9278550 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sjm817
He was going to use a RD for a feed pump, not a mod.
Click to expand...


If you use a RD for a feed pump, the skimmer will never work. Too much flow.
 
toothman: I wasnt going to modify the skimmer. The Deltec AP 1004 must be supplied with water either by gravity feed from the aquarium or via a separate pump.

richconley: I would use a pump with a output of 3000L/H (which is recommended by deltec, for the AP 1004),
Here is some info about the pump I was thinking of using if I would decide to go with the AP 1004:
Red Dragon pump, used for Bk skimmer´s:
airintake :1000 L/h energyconsuption: 42 Watt waterflow: 3000 L/h
 
Isn't there a crazy long wait for BK skimmers? I think either one would perform as a high end product should.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9279433#post9279433 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sjm817
You dont want that type of pump for a feed. You want a pump that only pumps H2O
Click to expand...

I was afraid of that. :(
What are the disadvantages of using that pump?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ClownBubbaJoe
Skimmer, TALL skimmer vs short under cabinet type ?
Replies
13
Views
891
BeanAnimal
B
asmodeus
skimmer vs skimmer
2 3
Replies
49
Views
5K
wildman926
wildman926
F
Bubble King 400 internal issues
Replies
1
Views
614
slief
slief
3
Ammonium Chloride and oxidizer (KMnO4), to grow corals, less water changes, and very low organo-phosphates:
2
Replies
24
Views
4K
JCOLE
JCOLE
N
Bubble King Double Cone 150 Surging
Replies
6
Views
9K
slief
slief
Back
Top