New Reef Octupus Skimmer Thread (Pacific Coast Imports)
- Thread starter Psionicdragon
- Start date
- Status
Deuce, The only mod that I did was simply cutting a small notch out of the venturi o-ring. I'm going to be replacing it eventually with a Viton o-ring from mcmaster. TRMIV and others have used this one and is a direct replacement.
I think most of these guys that are purchasing these RPS skimmers are tinkerers in general. They work fine out of the box, but we all like to pull the Tim Taylor tool-time more power thing. Deuce, I know you are that type, due to the CSS thread, so don't be suprised if you don't start looking at the RPS as a canvas, if you will.
I'm completely content w/ mine, but I will surely check out the eheim needlewheel pump as a possible retrofit, just because I like to screw with things.
And as for Rich's comments about paying more for a skimmer thats not as effective....
How do you know it's not as effective? I don't believe well known manufacturers tank ratings, I'm certainly not going to believe what the little man in China is saying. That said, I'm sure the 8" skimmer does it's job. I wanted a external skimmer. I wanted more control. I wanted to be able to concentrate my organics. The RPS was the logical solution.
But don't take this the wrong way guys, I'm not trying to discourage anyone from the non-recircs at all. If you've got what it takes (Time, Metric conversion plans, Tools) Then save yourself some cash and go for it, let us know how it goes. You may convince me to buy another one!
Deuce, if you need any pics, or measurements, let me know.
Daniel
I think most of these guys that are purchasing these RPS skimmers are tinkerers in general. They work fine out of the box, but we all like to pull the Tim Taylor tool-time more power thing. Deuce, I know you are that type, due to the CSS thread, so don't be suprised if you don't start looking at the RPS as a canvas, if you will.
I'm completely content w/ mine, but I will surely check out the eheim needlewheel pump as a possible retrofit, just because I like to screw with things.
And as for Rich's comments about paying more for a skimmer thats not as effective....
How do you know it's not as effective? I don't believe well known manufacturers tank ratings, I'm certainly not going to believe what the little man in China is saying. That said, I'm sure the 8" skimmer does it's job. I wanted a external skimmer. I wanted more control. I wanted to be able to concentrate my organics. The RPS was the logical solution.
But don't take this the wrong way guys, I'm not trying to discourage anyone from the non-recircs at all. If you've got what it takes (Time, Metric conversion plans, Tools) Then save yourself some cash and go for it, let us know how it goes. You may convince me to buy another one!
Deuce, if you need any pics, or measurements, let me know.
Daniel
RichConley
New member
Honestly, I dont really know.
A Euroreef CS250 is rated for 250+ gallons. Its the same size as the PC3000.
A Euroreef RS135 is about the same size as a RPC-2000, and is rated for 135gallons+
So I dont know, but I do know that its generally believed that the bigger bodied skimmer can handle more. (In the case of the Euroreefs, the smaller skimmer is $100 less than the larger one. In the case of the PCI, the smaller skimmer is $50 more expensive)
Unfortunately, I can't find another skimmer company that makes both a recirc, and non recirc model,(not deltec, H&S,asm) but common thought is that generally an 8" skimmer will outskim a 6" recirc.
RichConley
New member
The deltec Turbo and AP seem to be totally different designs, so I dont really think theyre usefull for comparison. I'll look more at the H&S.
tonyf
New member
Yo Rich, we've been down the comparisons track before in this thread ... no need to flog the proverbial dead horse.
The previous thread was cut because it became a bun fight.
These skimmers work just fine straight out of the box and provide excellent bang for the buck. There's no comparison with top end skimmers like Deltec or BubbleKing or any others for that matter. It's like buying a Mercedes and comparing it to a Ferrari.
As Dan has pointed out above, some of us just like to tinker to max out performance. The point of difference with all of these like skimmers is the needle-wheel pump, the rest of the body is pretty much all the same.
Tone
The previous thread was cut because it became a bun fight.
These skimmers work just fine straight out of the box and provide excellent bang for the buck. There's no comparison with top end skimmers like Deltec or BubbleKing or any others for that matter. It's like buying a Mercedes and comparing it to a Ferrari.
As Dan has pointed out above, some of us just like to tinker to max out performance. The point of difference with all of these like skimmers is the needle-wheel pump, the rest of the body is pretty much all the same.
Tone
RichConley
New member
Sorry,
I'm just trying to decide between the PC-3000 and teh RPC-2000... I think I'm going with the non recirculating 3000.
I just posted the ER/Deltec/H&S stuff to point out that they rate their 8" non recirc a lot higher then their 6" recirc.
In this case, with the 8" non recirc cheaper than the 6" recirc, I think its a better deal, unless you really need an external.
sherm71tank
Premium Member
Rich, I'm with you on the recirc vs. non-recirc models. It just doesn't make sense. Yes a recirc if properly designed with the right flow rate will outperform a non-recirc but a properly designed non-recirc works just fine and costs less.
Well, got my RS1000 on Fri and it is already skimming like a dream! I ran it with Fresh water for about 4 hrs or so before I even got it near my sump. However, I did notice one thing, the Inner Diameter of the air inlet on the fitting was tiny. So after I plugged it in and got it running, my suspisions were correct! Not enough air. I took it to work and bored the hole out. Now she runns like a champ! Deuce, thanks to you I got my CSS 65. These skimmers are worth it! I love mine already!
Man, now I want to buy the 8 inch non recirc to try out. I really don't think its neccesary on this tank I have now, but I may be getting a larger tank in the future. What size pump is on it? The one thats on the RPS 3000, I'd assume. I just ordered a DAS ex2 as well. I'm kind of addicted to skimmers.
Anyone got pics of the non-recirc models in action other than the one that was previously posted?
Trip, get some pics if you can too, I wanna check out that 1000.
Daniel.
Anyone got pics of the non-recirc models in action other than the one that was previously posted?
Trip, get some pics if you can too, I wanna check out that 1000.
Daniel.
iNfaMous_reeF
New member
For all of you guys who are using the rps-1000 what are u using as a feed pump?
tonyf
New member
Dan, have you been to counselling about your affliction with skimmers ROTFL ... man, you crack me up!
The recirc 3000 model runs an OTP3000 needle-wheel pump -- same as its smaller 2000 brother.
I was thinking about hooking up my OR3500 needle-wheel as the feed pump -- that will really max out the recirc 3000 model!
Can't get the standard impeller off though to fit the needle-wheel -- anybody have some advice for me on how to do it without breaking it?
Tone :eek2:
RichConley
New member
I'm gonna buy the PC-3000. I'll let you guys know how it goes.
I started with a MJ1200, but that was when I was having air issues. I knocked it all the way down to a MJ 400. The skim it is pulling out is super dark and dry. Now that I have fixed the venturi problem, I might put the MJ1200 back on. Of course, I can't do it till the weekend because my tank is another state! When I get back on Fri I will be sure to take some pics of my 1000
Deuce67
New member
Again thanks for all your help on the info on this skimmer. But I think I will hold up for now. Like I said, my modified CSS with a Sedra 5000 as a recirc pump does the job well. I really need more flow in my tank and I think I will get 1 controllable tunze for now. Ill definitely consider this skimmer when funds become available again. Thanks guys!
ok..so who is going to be the first to convert their RPS3000 to a RPS 2x3000.... meaning, adding another recirc pump on?
I still need to measure the performance of my skimmer...see how much its collecting in a day... you guys think it should pull about 1/4 gallon if tank is med to heavy stocked?
G
I still need to measure the performance of my skimmer...see how much its collecting in a day... you guys think it should pull about 1/4 gallon if tank is med to heavy stocked?
G
- Status
