PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

Status
Not open for further replies.
56 Gal mixed reef. Barebottom, 65 lbs live rock.

Currently have:
Falco Hawkfish
Unidentified combtooth blenny
CUC

Would like in the future:
Candy Hogfish aggressive
2 Clowns depends on species
One of the psuedochromis or dottybacks dottybacks are very aggressive, especially in small tanks
Banggi Cardinal
 
Hello, thanks for your response regarding my 120g.
I also have a biocube 14, running about 3 years. It's 15.5x15x16" including the filter section, live rock, sandbed, softy tank.
I currently have a Stonogobiops nematodes/pistol shrimp pair. I would like to add:
a clown goby, probably a green one
a yellowstriped cardinalfish

Am I pushing it too much with 3 small fish in this tank?

Thanks
 
439.9Litre tank.

1xOcellaris Clownfish
1xBlue Tang
1xYellow Tang
1xPorcupine Puffer
2xPinkface Wrasse
1xTracey's Damselfish
2xYellow Tail Damselfish
3xBicolor Dottyback

May you please let me know which ones I should/should not put in my tank, and how many of each fish would be the best. Thanks :)
 
Hello, thanks for your response regarding my 120g.
I also have a biocube 14, running about 3 years. It's 15.5x15x16" including the filter section, live rock, sandbed, softy tank.
I currently have a Stonogobiops nematodes/pistol shrimp pair. I would like to add:
a clown goby, probably a green one
a yellowstriped cardinalfish

Am I pushing it too much with 3 small fish in this tank?

Thanks

clown goby is fine but I would not do the cardinal
 
439.9Litre tank.

1xOcellaris Clownfish
1xBlue Tang
1xYellow Tang
1xPorcupine Puffer
2xPinkface Wrasse
1xTracey's Damselfish
2xYellow Tail Damselfish
3xBicolor Dottyback

May you please let me know which ones I should/should not put in my tank, and how many of each fish would be the best. Thanks :)

Sorry, I do not provide analysis of aggressive fish community tanks.
 
[quote name="cmcoker" post=23893763]Hello, thanks for your response regarding my 120g. <br />
I also have a biocube 14, running about 3 years. It's 15.5x15x16" including the filter section, live rock, sandbed, softy tank. <br />
I currently have a Stonogobiops nematodes/pistol shrimp pair. I would like to add: <br />
a clown goby, probably a green one<br />
a yellowstriped cardinalfish<br />
<br />
Am I pushing it too much with 3 small fish in this tank?<br />
<br />
Thanks[/QUOTE]<br />
<br />
<font color="Magenta">clown goby is fine but I would not do the cardinal </font>

Thanks! Is it the cardinal behavior/niche that is a no? Would another fish, like a Wetmorella sp. or helfrichi firefish work? Or is the tank considered stocked with two fish?
Appreciate your time.
 
[quote name="cmcoker" post=23893763]Hello, thanks for your response regarding my 120g. <br />
I also have a biocube 14, running about 3 years. It's 15.5x15x16" including the filter section, live rock, sandbed, softy tank. <br />
I currently have a Stonogobiops nematodes/pistol shrimp pair. I would like to add: <br />
a clown goby, probably a green one<br />
a yellowstriped cardinalfish<br />
<br />
Am I pushing it too much with 3 small fish in this tank?<br />
<br />
Thanks
<br />
<br />
<font color="Magenta">clown goby is fine but I would not do the cardinal </font>

Thanks! Is it the cardinal behavior/niche that is a no? Would another fish, like a Wetmorella sp. or helfrichi firefish work? Or is the tank considered stocked with two fish?
Appreciate your time.[/QUOTE]

A Wetmorella sp. or helfrichi firefish would do fine.
 
I'm upgrading my two mixed reef tanks to a 180 gallon with a 55 gallon sump. Just wanted to make sure all fish would get along and bioload wouldn't be too terribly high. The wrasses are currently split between two tanks will definitely use an acclimation box when introducing them to the new tank.

Squaretail Bristle Tooth Tang
Hybrid Powder Blue
Sailfin Tang
Hippo Tang
Coral Beauty angel fish
Snowflake ocellaris Clownfish pair
Leopard Wrasse x3
Orange back fairy Wrasse
Red Velvet Fairy Wrasse pair
McCoskers Wrasse pair
Blue Flasher Wrasse
Yellow Banded Possum Wrasse
Orange Spotted Blenny
Blue head comb tooth Blenny
Gold line Goby
Neon Goby pair
Greenbanded Goby pair
Citron Goby
 
Hello everyone! I was planning on starting a reef tank in the future and was hoping to get some advice on stock and a couple other questions. The tank would be a 125g reef with a 30 or 40g sump.
Would I need a heater and a chiller? (I live in Windsor ON)
What are some good beginner corals?

Stock:
1x White cheek tang
4x green chromi
1x mccoskers flasher wrasse
1x yellowhead jawfish
1x redhead solon fairy wrasse
2x clown fish
1x flame Angel
1x lemonpeel angel
1x firefish
1x Foxface one spot
1x Valentini puffer

I get that some of them might nip corals, but would there be any between fish aggression? Would it be overstocked? I checked aqadvisor and some of the fish weren't on there. Also what would my best options be for inverts and CUC? I really like long spine sea urchins, brittle stars, and pistol and cleaner shrimp. Would these be possible? Thanks for any help!
 
Last edited:
I'm upgrading my two mixed reef tanks to a 180 gallon with a 55 gallon sump. Just wanted to make sure all fish would get along and bioload wouldn't be too terribly high. The wrasses are currently split between two tanks will definitely use an acclimation box when introducing them to the new tank.

Squaretail Bristle Tooth Tang
Hybrid Powder Blue
Sailfin Tang needs a larger tank
Hippo Tang needs a larger tank


Coral Beauty angel fish
Snowflake ocellaris Clownfish pair
Leopard Wrasse x3 Should wait until tank is at least 6 months mature as they graze on copepods
Orange back fairy Wrasse
Red Velvet Fairy Wrasse pair
McCoskers Wrasse pair
Blue Flasher Wrasse
Yellow Banded Possum Wrasse
Orange Spotted Blenny
Blue head comb tooth Blenny
Gold line Goby
Neon Goby pair life span is 1.5 years
Greenbanded Goby pair
Citron Goby

You have some prolific jumpers so the tank must be covered with 1/4 inch mesh
 
Hello everyone! I was planning on starting a reef tank in the future and was hoping to get some advice on stock and a couple other questions. The tank would be a 125g reef with a 30 or 40g sump.
Would I need a heater and a chiller? (I live in Windsor ON)
What are some good beginner corals?

this thread is only about marine fish compatibility so equipment, invert, and coral questions should be addressed in your own thread in New to the Hobby

Stock:
1x White cheek tang I would not do a tang and the foxface in this sized tank
4x green chromi will winnow down to one or at most two over time
1x mccoskers flasher wrasse
1x yellowhead jawfish
1x redhead solon fairy wrasse
2x clown fish
1x flame Angel not coral safe
1x lemonpeel angel not coral safe
1x firefish
1x Foxface one spot I would not do a tang and the foxface in this sized tank
1x Valentini puffer not invert safe

I get that some of them might nip corals, but would there be any between fish aggression? Would it be overstocked? I checked aqadvisor and some of the fish weren't on there. Also what would my best options be for inverts and CUC? I really like long spine sea urchins, brittle stars, and pistol and cleaner shrimp. Would these be possible? Thanks for any help!

[welcome]
 
Is the 100 gallon tank size for a single specimen then?

Yes. However, your tank is 300 liters which is 75 gallons. A pair of some fish during mating displays need a fair amount of horizontal tank space. And I suggest you update your "About Me" as it specifies an even smaller tank.
 
Ah of course, it's a 100 gallon system but display volume only for picking fish!

Just checking as the suppliers had a lovely pair around 4" each and offered me a very good price on them but thought I'd check and make an informed decision :)


I assume the tank is too small to have a male and a female leopard wrasse pair?
 
Ah of course, it's a 100 gallon system but display volume only for picking fish!

Just checking as the suppliers had a lovely pair around 4" each and offered me a very good price on them but thought I'd check and make an informed decision :)


I assume the tank is too small to have a male and a female leopard wrasse pair?

That is correct.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top