Frag Swap Exceptional Frag Judging POST HERE
- Thread starter funman1
- Start date
RonMidtownStomp
You can edit this?
Submit corals here, protest elsewhere.
Unarce
Unshackled
I just wanted to say that I hope you all continue to be patient and understanding with Chris and Justin's position. This is one of the most vilified aspects of frag swaps, and one that evolves constantly during the process. They've done a commendable job, thus far.
Kind regards,
Karl
Kind regards,
Karl
pbetito
New member
Chris....
Take it easy
I did not complain at all and am happy to go along with any decision you guys make. I simply pointed out what I thought. I am not complaining, nor is Pete. We were just sharing what we thought and asking for your consideration. You guys decided against it which is perfectly fine and understandable. I really appreciate the fact that Steve said why he felt the way he did. A brief explanation goes a long way. We are all in the same club and even if we don't agree on certain things, that is o.k. as long as everyone is respectful of others opinions. There is no need for arguing. but intelligent sharing of ideas should always be welcome. I have NO complaints and think you are all doing an awesome job. Keep up the good work :bum:
Paul
pbetito
New member
I agree Karl...That job is a royal PITA. No matter what you decide, people will disagree because in the end exceptional is just SOOOOOOOO subjective. All the guys can do is try to do their best and be as fair as possible. They have done a fantastic job and are very nice for giving up their own time to help us all out. Thanks again guys.
Brian Prestwood
Premium Member
FWIW - I agree that tubs blue zoos are common here. However, I think reversing any published decisions is not worth the trouble. Short of an error in identification, I'd say change the list the next time.
Justin74
New member
Come back from work and egads!
Please allow me to explain what has happened very briefly.
The time was pressing and we needed to get this ball rolling. I was unaware of the pressing time but jumped on board as soon as was asked. Through innitial discussion between Chris and I we intended to use the last swaps approval and unapproved list as a template for this year, and yes, one of our first thoughts was it needed some revising/editing to stay current with the market and trends.
However the list was posted before this could be done. Simple misunderstanding, and what is done is done. Furthermore, I am on board if the BOD in charge of Chris and I's judging would like some revisions but I think it would be wise to have a yay or nay on the subject formulated within the next 48 hours; or, just skip it all together and press on as some have suggested.
Thanks for your support everyone :thumbsup:
-Justin
Please allow me to explain what has happened very briefly.
The time was pressing and we needed to get this ball rolling. I was unaware of the pressing time but jumped on board as soon as was asked. Through innitial discussion between Chris and I we intended to use the last swaps approval and unapproved list as a template for this year, and yes, one of our first thoughts was it needed some revising/editing to stay current with the market and trends.
However the list was posted before this could be done. Simple misunderstanding, and what is done is done. Furthermore, I am on board if the BOD in charge of Chris and I's judging would like some revisions but I think it would be wise to have a yay or nay on the subject formulated within the next 48 hours; or, just skip it all together and press on as some have suggested.
Thanks for your support everyone :thumbsup:
-Justin
<a href="http://s21.photobucket.com/albums/b298/iairj84/?action=view¤t=100_0706.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b298/iairj84/100_0706.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>
How about these yuma's? The purple shows up a lot more in person, I have a Point an shoot.
How about these yuma's? The purple shows up a lot more in person, I have a Point an shoot.
dots
Premium Member
Ehhh......I have never heard some nit pick over what should be a FUN and Sharing event.
I suggest those who be gettin' thy panty in da' bunch, about what counts (or not) to chill and remember what difference it makes one way or the other........nothing.
Its not going to make your break you either way in the long run, and it just makes it a lame %^$# around for everyone, leaving a bad taste and resentment.
Like most LE things, the list is subjective and based on ones/group view of the current market. I have been watching with curosity what ends up on the list, and feel its been fair without being out of line with the classification either way. Would I agree with everything.......no......does it matter.......no.
Which is why different people have "judged" them in the past.
Good job so far, keep up the good work......too late to second guess, or to look back.....it seems Chris is busting his buns to get this going for you!!
Just have fun, and remember what its all about, and take notes for next time if you want something changed.
Trust me, nothing good will come about of it if this continues.
I suggest those who be gettin' thy panty in da' bunch, about what counts (or not) to chill and remember what difference it makes one way or the other........nothing.
Its not going to make your break you either way in the long run, and it just makes it a lame %^$# around for everyone, leaving a bad taste and resentment.
Like most LE things, the list is subjective and based on ones/group view of the current market. I have been watching with curosity what ends up on the list, and feel its been fair without being out of line with the classification either way. Would I agree with everything.......no......does it matter.......no.
Which is why different people have "judged" them in the past.
Good job so far, keep up the good work......too late to second guess, or to look back.....it seems Chris is busting his buns to get this going for you!!
Just have fun, and remember what its all about, and take notes for next time if you want something changed.
Trust me, nothing good will come about of it if this continues.
Last edited:
RonMidtownStomp
You can edit this?
How many heads of Duncans to qualify? I don't see them anywhere in the thread. I have 2 colonies and could see if I could frag one of them.
How many Candy Apple Red zoa polyps?
Thanks,
Ron
How many Candy Apple Red zoa polyps?
Thanks,
Ron
Justin74
New member
Pretty much in line with the guidlines of the last swap. The last swap spoke of a relative value in perportion to it's "awe" factor . I believe the relative value was $35+ per sm. frag. In some cases, yes, a slow growing coral may dictate it's market/trade value. But the market dictates that and is not necessarily a reflection of a particular coral(s) growth rate. An example of how these do not align in some cases is Tubb's blue zoas, one of the fastest growing zoas on the market at it's time of introduction, as well as one of the priciest. Or take Blastomussa wellsi, in some cases it takes a year+ to get one polyp due there slow growth and in regards to growth would leave them virtually priceless.
Time to move forward please
-Justin
Justin74
New member
I think duncans were brought up last swap and decided that they are not uncommon. But if not then, now. A flood of these came in shortly after they're popularity, along with being fast growers has reached a common place and can be found at pretty much every LFS in california.
lurchccd: albeit a very nice Palythoa, they are fairly common, and often referred to as RPE's (red people eater).
RonMidtownStomp: Candy Apple reds would be considered an EF. I or Chris will get back to you by tomorrow with polyp requirement~thanks!
-Justin
lurchccd: albeit a very nice Palythoa, they are fairly common, and often referred to as RPE's (red people eater).
RonMidtownStomp: Candy Apple reds would be considered an EF. I or Chris will get back to you by tomorrow with polyp requirement~thanks!
-Justin
Underwaterparadise
New member
:lol: :lol: :lol:
My how the swaps have changed since my first one about 6 years ago!!
My how the swaps have changed since my first one about 6 years ago!!
Similar threads
