<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15002519#post15002519 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Jeremy B.
Given all things being equal, feed pump, pinwheel size, body size, etc... a skimmer with a smaller neck will skim more wet than a skimmer with a larger neck, which skims more dry. This is just the nature of the beast and the way physics work with a protein skimmer.
For example, look at the old AquaMedic Turboflotor line of skimmers, especially the 5000 Shorty, Single, and Twin. These bodies were huge, the pumps were tiny, and the reaction chamber wasn't even close to being milky white while running, but the neck size on them gets so darn small, about 2.5" in diameter, that they would pull out a ton of wet skimmate. Now look at the BK line for example, where you are 4:1 air draw versus that AquaMedic line, but neck size is 10:1 in some cases, and that AquaMedic will skim a heck of a lot more wet than the BK ever would.
Now, how do we judge quality of skimmate? That's for the consumer to decide on what they prefer to do. I think that everyone knows that BK skimmers produce a very dry to average wet skimmate by design. If you are wanting a skimmer that fills the collection cup on a daily basis, then you probably need to be looking at a down draft, beckett, or other very small necked pinwheel / venturi skimmer.