Scrapz's Ultimate Gamble 3x3 SPS Cube

Ok, I'll bite.

From the scenario you set for the dosing pump, it's seems that it's mainly user error. You were running fluids through your lines and forgot to shut it off and were reminded by your APEX since your PH was out of wack. By taking the time to manually hold the on button for your doser and making sure the lines were full of fluid and shutting it off, that scenario could have been adverted. Instead you chose to run the pump automatically and begin fiddling(hypothetical) with other things before 1 task was complete and forgot about the doser. Another way this could be adverted is having your doser hooked up to a PH controller which would shut off the dosers if the PH raised past a certain level.

For the heater scenario, why would a person trust their tank to 1 heater? My ranco simply turns on and off the temp but I go beyond that. I personally run 3-4 heaters in my tank and all in different chambers. If you take a look at my picture, I even go to the next level of adding a heater directly to my display without a secondary controller. This heater is tested every water change (2-3 weeks) to have a working built in controller. This method makes the tank uglier and raises my electricity bill a bit each month. However, In the event of a return pump fail, my display, where all my livestock is held is still being heated. A single 250w can easily keep a 100g water safely at 75+ depending on ambient temp.

I don't know how everyone else sleeps, but if a text comes in during the night time. I won't even hear it. On the other hand, if there was a flood going on, the alarm from my Tunze ATO would definitely wake me. Yes, I know there is an extension that allows apex to do this also. My point is most the equipment we have already has the features we need built into it. Dosers have timers, programmability and auto manual controls. Powerheads have wireless controllers/syncing, flow control, and different settings. The list goes on for the equipment we buy with the options we want.

Like I said, I have buyers remorse because to ME it wasn't worth the money. I already have all the equipment that this controller replicates. I bought it solely for the purpose of being able to monitor it wirelessly and I got hit with another $35-100 bill to get it to do what I wanted.

Again, I'm not saying the APEX is bad. It's a great piece of equipment backed by a even better company which is why I'm keeping it. I'd just rather have spent the money on more livestock:lol:


- To anyone who misconstrues this as attacks on each other. We're not, just having a friendly discussion about our opinions. I harbor no ill thoughts towards anyone :love2:
 
Good discussion on the APEX. If it werent for the fact I just bought 3 Radion Pros, a new MP40, MP10 and a Reeflink, I would have bought one.
 
hate that he was the one who began the trend of attaching $2000 tag to corals.

That aspect I really dislike too. It's not about growing a nice piece and sharing it amongst friends so that others have backups of a NICE piece...its about making money...tiny frags sold to whoever can afford to pay the highest amount...

Royal Blue+TINY pieces of coral = $$$$$$$$$$$$$$

I see so many nice corals come into the UK shops, but the prices are crazy...driven up by how much the coral fluoresces...not all the time, but often its someone who's only been in the hobby a short while and this person buys it only to lose it some days or weeks later. :headwally:
 
Ok, I'll bite.

From the scenario you set for the dosing pump, it's seems that it's mainly user error. You were running fluids through your lines and forgot to shut it off and were reminded by your APEX since your PH was out of wack. By taking the time to manually hold the on button for your doser and making sure the lines were full of fluid and shutting it off, that scenario could have been adverted. Instead you chose to run the pump automatically and begin fiddling(hypothetical) with other things before 1 task was complete and forgot about the doser. Another way this could be adverted is having your doser hooked up to a PH controller which would shut off the dosers if the PH raised past a certain level.

For the heater scenario, why would a person trust their tank to 1 heater? My ranco simply turns on and off the temp but I go beyond that. I personally run 3-4 heaters in my tank and all in different chambers. If you take a look at my picture, I even go to the next level of adding a heater directly to my display without a secondary controller. This heater is tested every water change (2-3 weeks) to have a working built in controller. This method makes the tank uglier and raises my electricity bill a bit each month. However, In the event of a return pump fail, my display, where all my livestock is held is still being heated. A single 250w can easily keep a 100g water safely at 75+ depending on ambient temp.

I don't know how everyone else sleeps, but if a text comes in during the night time. I won't even hear it. On the other hand, if there was a flood going on, the alarm from my Tunze ATO would definitely wake me. Yes, I know there is an extension that allows apex to do this also. My point is most the equipment we have already has the features we need built into it. Dosers have timers, programmability and auto manual controls. Powerheads have wireless controllers/syncing, flow control, and different settings. The list goes on for the equipment we buy with the options we want.

Like I said, I have buyers remorse because to ME it wasn't worth the money. I already have all the equipment that this controller replicates. I bought it solely for the purpose of being able to monitor it wirelessly and I got hit with another $35-100 bill to get it to do what I wanted.

Again, I'm not saying the APEX is bad. It's a great piece of equipment backed by a even better company which is why I'm keeping it. I'd just rather have spent the money on more livestock:lol:


- To anyone who misconstrues this as attacks on each other. We're not, just having a friendly discussion about our opinions. I harbor no ill thoughts towards anyone :love2:

I appreciate the discussion, I'm just trying to let you know that the purchase was better than you see at this moment:)

The Dover was totally user error, but it was because it is a 1.1ml/min doser and priming the line takes 15-20 minutes. Holding a button for that long isn't going to happen:p. I got busy with something else while waiting and just forgot it.

I use a Tunze ATO as well and that high level alarm has saved my butt quite a few times when my water change system was connected to the sump and I was draining into the sump unknowingly. That's a good piece of equipment I've never regretted buying. The reservoir it pulls top off water from is only 1.5-2 gallons with a float valve connected to the DI line. If something starts pulling too much water from the tank the ATO will drain it faster than the DI can fill it and the Tunze pump will shut off and go into error when it runs dry. I've read about too many tanks killed by ATO overfills and my setup is designed to be pretty stupid-proof.

I'd love to have more heaters but my sump is pretty cramped. Typically people use more than one heater and that is prudent for sure. With my old setup I had three heaters and set up the Apex to use the smallest heater first, then add the medium if temps continue to drop, then add the largest if the first two didn't do the trick.

Again, discussions of the merits of this piece of equipment are a good thing. If you hadn't bought one I'd not have bugged you about getting one since they aren't cheap, but since you got one I wanted you to know its not wasted money:)
 
Nice build. Looks like we have similar tanks. Looking forward to seeing your progress.

Also, I agree with everyone's comments regarding the Apex. It is expensive (but what isn't in this hobby) and not necessary in order to have a successful tank, however, it does make it easier to do so. I'll never setup another tank without one. I've averted so many disasters with mine I consider it cheap insurance.

Oh yeah, watch out for Jimmy. He's trouble. [emoji1]
 
@mhucasey

Thanks. Definitely not a waste of money. I look forward to using this piece of equipment more once I get it hooed up properly. Today I was just staring at my graphs and it was definitely cool info to browse through. Just waiting on them to add in CA/ALK monitoring. I can wish right?

@Mr. Sandman

Thanks! Hoping this time around the infamous Jimmy curse doesn't hit me.
 
Today is a sad day, well kind of. When I began building this tank, I already anticipated catching bugs from someone. I was just going to keep purchasing frags until I found some sort of pest and then I would begin the 8 week Bayer dip regiment before moving anything into my main tank. Guess it came sooner than I thought. Discovered red bugs on my garf bonsai and what looked like AEFW on my pink lemonade. Upon further inspection of the Pink lemonade and dip in Revive, I realized it was just what I originally suspected, it was just being hit with too much flow and losing tissue in that area. Good thing I decided to setup a QT system this time around.

I did some research but couldn't find a definitive dosage amount for the dip so I went light and mixed 25ml with 2 gallons of water and dipped all my sps for 10 mins. Basted the hell out of the corals, gave it a double rinse and visually inspected corals with a magnifying glass and noticed a few red bugs still moving. Guess the dosage was way too low. I'll be following the same dosage Sahin used for his battle the next dip.

Even though I didn't see any AEFW, I'm not going to take any chances this time around. It's going to be boring 8 weeks but I know the end result will be worth it. Time to live vicariously through everyone else's tank :sad1:
 
Redbugs are easy to deal with. I've done whole system wide treatments many times.

AEFW are a lot harder to deal with, but only in terms of a whole tank. Frags coming in with AEFW's, as long as you know how to QT/Dip/Inspect and remove eggs; its not too difficult for me now that I have had experience with dealing with them a few times.

At least you are dealing with the issues now rather than later.
 
Yup, redbugs are easy and can usually be killed with just a interceptor tank treamtment or just a single r dip. Apparently they are on their host 99% of the time instead of the water column and just like shrmps, they carry their eggs on them which making just dipping them very effective. Would also make for a n


AEFW on the other hand are a nightmare if you have anything but frags to deal with IME. The last time, I never set up a qt and just kept dipping them in the display. I think that was the biggest reason for failure as they probably fed on encrusted rocks where i couldnt fins them. I was actually thinking of doing the string suspending method only for my QT instead of using frag plugs to minimize egglaying locations if i do run into aefw.

In the other thread about aefw, they are mentioning blue saph damsels as an a natural predator. Some other threada mention an army of shrimps. Maybe ill run an experiment with just these two animals in a seperate tank when I find me some aefws. Would be cool if this turned out to be the natural solution to our problems.
 
Yup, redbugs are easy and can usually be killed with just a interceptor tank treamtment or just a single r dip. Apparently they are on their host 99% of the time instead of the water column and just like shrmps, they carry their eggs on them which making just dipping them very effective. Would also make for a n


AEFW on the other hand are a nightmare if you have anything but frags to deal with IME. The last time, I never set up a qt and just kept dipping them in the display. I think that was the biggest reason for failure as they probably fed on encrusted rocks where i couldnt fins them. I was actually thinking of doing the string suspending method only for my QT instead of using frag plugs to minimize egglaying locations if i do run into aefw.

In the other thread about aefw, they are mentioning blue saph damsels as an a natural predator. Some other threada mention an army of shrimps. Maybe ill run an experiment with just these two animals in a seperate tank when I find me some aefws. Would be cool if this turned out to be the natural solution to our problems.

Yellow "Coris" wrasses and Leopard wrasses are good natural predators for the tank as well. I'm glad it wasn't AEFW, the redbugs are easy to deal with but AEFW are bad news once stuff gets established.
 
Scrapz... Nice meeting you and thanks for the compliments. You are building a nice looking tank and I hope to see it someday.That purple frag above was sold to me as a "Plum Crazy." Its a deeper purple than other PCs ive seen. Im glad to see the other frags have held color as well, but i wouldnt be surprised if they brown a little with the new tank and the temp drop you experienced. Keep me posted as I want my frags to do just as well in your tank as they do in mine. As far as the pests, you didnt get them from me! Goodluck!
 
@maiowoie

Thanks for the ID. Definitely didn't get the pest from you. The frags have been fully extended and going great.
 
With the amount of money that goes into a tank, using a controller for safety is prudent.

Yeah, but sometimes the controller is what crashes the tank, like when it doesn't re-start properly in a power outage.

I'm oldschool too scrapz!!! :D I've been humming about buying an Apex, but I know of a couple people this last year that had some serious issue with theirs, and I'm not really sure about it. I do like the ability to check on it remotely, though I already have an HD camera I can access remotely from cell phone or computer, and I don't travel much. Oh, I don't know!!!! :debi:

Btw, I love the dimensions of the new tank and the scape is awesome! My tank is all branch rock too, but mine is a finer branch (and smaller tank lol).
 
Yeah, but sometimes the controller is what crashes the tank, like when it doesn't re-start properly in a power outage.

I'm oldschool too scrapz!!! :D I've been humming about buying an Apex, but I know of a couple people this last year that had some serious issue with theirs, and I'm not really sure about it. I do like the ability to check on it remotely, though I already have an HD camera I can access remotely from cell phone or computer, and I don't travel much. Oh, I don't know!!!! :debi:

Btw, I love the dimensions of the new tank and the scape is awesome! My tank is all branch rock too, but mine is a finer branch (and smaller tank lol).

My controller even texts me when the power is out and then restored;)
 
Its all gloom and doom with ya!:worried::eek2::uhoh3::facepalm:
Haha! When things screw up I want it to be my fault, not equipment. Still, if I get an Apex this year it certainly won't be running the entire show! Call me paranoid...
 
Haha! When things screw up I want it to be my fault, not equipment. Still, if I get an Apex this year it certainly won't be running the entire show! Call me paranoid...

Seems like we think alike. I don't think it's paranoia, more like strategically planning for when the problem arises, because it's not a matter of if. With all setups, redundancy is key. Simple things like not hooking up the main return pump to a controller, using multiple heaters or hooking powerheads on different outlets can save a tank.
 
Back
Top